완전한 전환, 후회 없음 — 그리고 어떤 라벨도 맞지 않는다
남성 · 탈전환138
이 이야기는 AI를 사용하여 요약되었습니다.
Reddit에서 사람들은 종종 여러 댓글이나 게시물에 걸쳐 경험을 공유합니다. 이 정보를 더 쉽게 접근할 수 있도록 하기 위해 detrans.ai가 흩어진 모든 조각을 하나의 읽기 쉬운 요약 및 타임라인으로 수집합니다. 모든 시스템 프롬프트는 프롬프트 페이지에 표시됩니다.
때로는 AI가 환각하거나 사실이 아닌 것을 말할 수 있습니다. 그러나 일반적으로 요약된 이야기는 사용자의 원래 댓글의 정확한 반영입니다.
요약
저는 남성으로 태어났고 사춘기의 고통과 Reddit 조사 끝에 호르몬과 성전환 수술로 전환했으며 모든 단계에서 더 나아졌지만, 여성으로 보이려는 집착에 지치고 꼬리표를 붙이라는 압박에 화가 나서 5~6년 후 중단했습니다. 저는 제 전환을 실패라고 생각하지 않고 제 몸을 사랑하지만, 전환을 중단한/디트랜지션/논바이너리라는 꼬리표에 맞지 않으며 단지 제가 남성임을 솔직히 말하고 원하는 대로 살고 싶습니다. 저는 호르몬과 건강 문제에서 자유로워 행복하며, 다른 이들을 지지하면서 강경한 젠더 비판적 디트랜스와 시스 범주로의 동화 압박 모두에 비판적입니다.
전체 이야기
I was born male. During childhood I felt a bit alienated, but I had progressive parents, so I was free to play with both boys' and girls' toys and to do things considered for boys and for girls. Society at the time was selling the idea that "everyone is equal," so I didn't think much about gender back then.
During puberty things got worse. I hated all the changes and was always envious of the girls; I really wanted to have a feminine body, and I couldn't care less about men's bodies. I still loved sports and getting fit, but it was hard to stay consistent because my body always looked "meh" to me since it wasn't what I wanted.
I started "crossdressing," and it was fun for a while, but I realized that wasn't what I wanted either. I started going on Reddit, reading and asking questions, and ended up transitioning. I had HRT and SRS (sex reassignment surgery), and at each step I felt a lot better about myself. My self-esteem was greatly improved.
Then, after about five or six years, I stopped trying to hide all masculine features. Being so self-aware of my body "issues," trying to "pass" — all of that — I realized how toxic it was.
Nowadays I feel a bit angry at society. I don't have the desire to tell or force others into calling me a woman, female, biological female, or to hide that I'm male/man. But society isn't ready for that kind of talk, for people who really want to live beyond genders and labels. I don't really fit the desisted or detrans labels either — I don't hate the path I chose, I'm glad I physically transitioned, I like my body, and I don't consider the surgery or HRT a failure or a wrong decision. What I don't like is the discussion about trans people being assimilated into cis people, because being outed can mean losing your job, friends, sometimes being killed. I feel bad having to "lie" to people and tell them either that I'm a woman or a trans woman just to fit in. If I told them "I'm just a guy who likes what's considered a feminine body, but I'm also what's considered a tomboy," they would think I'm crazy or not know what to do with me.
I consider myself gender apathetic, or queer in the sense of not being inside gender roles, or having a body with a mixture of both sexual characteristics — though I never really understood non-binary. I think gender labels are very toxic and that society would do better without them, but we're not there yet. My approach has been to stop thinking in gender terms: tell people what they need to hear so they won't give me hell, focus on having the body and life I want, and ignore online discussions. My legal name is unisex, which makes things easier; my friends call me Cammie, which is a name I like and consider mine. Legally I use something else to prevent stupid discussions. I get read as female, so I roll with that legally to make things easier, even though I'm male and don't consider myself a woman any longer.
I've found that trans circles don't reflect my experience of gender and don't know where to put me — most try to tell me I'm non-binary, which isn't the case. I don't go in for "gender critical" or TERF positions either. I've also said that people on each side of the trans/antitrans debate throw studies, polls, and articles at each other and the other side doesn't care, and that professionals don't know what to do with "our kind."
I'm glad to be free from medical issues now. I don't describe regret about the hormones or surgery themselves — I explicitly say I don't consider them a failure — but I do resent the pressure to adopt a label and the toxicity of constantly trying to pass. I'm a parent, and I've said my bigger fear as a parent is that kids will start making mistakes on their own and all you can do is wish their mistakes aren't big enough.
I've been active in the r/detrans community, commenting on posts about losing friends after detransition, about people still taking testosterone, about body image and voice, and about the possibility of the subreddit being closed. I reported two suicide posts I saw on the front page of the sub. I've advised others to move on from toxic friends and communities, to work on not caring what others think, and to focus on themselves. I'm generally supportive of other people's choices — I've said "as long as you don't start bashing other trans folks, I don't really see any issue" and suggested sharing one's story anonymously if you want to speak up. I'm critical of detransitioners who go hard into "transition is bad for EVERYONE" alt-right territory. I find it weird how people relate haircuts to gender and note that racism is involved in that too.