Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerde, genderkritische lesbische vrouw die zich ongeveer een decennium als non-binair buiten vrouwelijkheid identificeerde, maar nooit een medische transitie nastreefde, dus noem ik mezelf een desister en geen detrans. Mijn identificatie kwam voort uit een zwaar gewelddadige, geseksualiseerde en afgedwongen vrouwelijke opvoeding, die me intense geïnternaliseerde misogynie en lichamelijke dysforie opleverde. Rond 2019 radicaal feminisme en genderkritisch denken ontdekken liet me desisteren, en de opluchting was zo diep dat ik op de vloer lag te huilen; mijn zelfvertrouwen is sindsdien omhooggeschoten. Ik blijf genderonconform in hoe ik me kleed en presenteer, voel me politiek thuisloos tussen GC- en transgemeenschappen en pleit sterk tegen het medicaliseren van genderonconforme jongeren. Ik beschrijf geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging; ik ben gelukkig, al krijg ik nog steeds vijandigheid te verduren vanwege mijn activisme.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I identified out of womanhood for about a decade — roughly from before I was old enough to be considered a woman until I desisted in 2019, so about ten years of living as an 'un-woman.' I never pursued anything medical: no hormones, no surgeries, no puberty blockers. I hesitate to call myself detrans since I never medically transitioned, so I describe myself as a desister, specifically an ex-nonbinary desister. Nonbinary was the only label that fit during what I now call my 'gender cult experience,' because I didn't belong to either of the two socially acceptable binaries.
The roots of this go back to my upbringing. I was raised in an insanely abusive environment involving sexual abuse as well as emotional and physical abuse, and I was forced into an extremely objectified, feminized role. I hated being objectified, hated feminine terms of endearment like 'adorable,' 'cute,' or 'pretty,' and hated my body reminding me that I was female. As soon as I had any autonomy I slingshot as far from femininity as I could — I bound my chest, grew out my body hair, tried to be more aggressive and masculine than was even in my nature, and denounced being a woman. I now understand all of that as crippling internalized misogyny planted by my upbringing: I had been abused into believing being a woman meant nothing more than being a sex object, and I lacked the 'womanly essence' I'd been told was required to call myself a woman. I felt 'othered' from womanhood since before I was old enough to be considered a woman at all. My very first experience of accepting myself had me literally lying on the floor crying my guts out.
I always knew I was biologically female and I always knew I was homosexual — a lesbian. I never believed I was the opposite sex. I never pushed the burden on others to change pronouns for me, though I lived with heavy discomfort being referred to as a woman, and I didn't correct people the many times I was accidentally called 'he' or 'sir.' I was partly in the closet because I didn't want to seem even weirder than I already felt, and because my experience of gender felt intensely personal rather than something I wanted validation for. I experienced physical dysphoria and mental anguish around it that was a huge struggle to overcome.
What moved me toward desisting was discovering radical feminism and gender critical viewpoints, around 2019. When I learned that gender wasn't innate but just the sets of stereotypes society agreed should dictate what 'living as a woman' and 'living as a man' look like, I was finally able to let them go. I had nothing to live up to and nothing to prove. Desisting was a huge turning point in my life; the relief I felt the first time, just over a year before I wrote this, was so intense that I tear up thinking about it. I've described it as a nightmare I didn't even realize I was in — one of those nightmares where you think you're awake but you aren't.
Since desisting, my confidence has skyrocketed, though nothing about how I express myself changed. I'm still gender nonconforming: I grow out my body hair, buzz my head short, never wear makeup, don't shave anything but my head, shop mostly in the men's section, swear a lot, and I'm a gamer with a personality slightly more masculine than feminine. I'm tall and androgynous and get mistaken for a man fairly regularly. I describe myself as living authentically as an androgynous woman rather than the hardcore butch I thought I needed to be to escape my pain. I've found that approaching situations with confidence and expecting to be treated no differently than a man tends to get me treated accordingly. I also note I've been self-conscious about my voice being more feminine than I'd prefer for as long as I can remember, and I considered HRT specifically to lower it but couldn't deal with the idea of facial hair or balding.
I consider myself gender critical and a gender abolitionist. I agree with GC arguments on a literal, rational basis — thinking critically about the concept of gender rather than blindly following it — but I've found the GC communities themselves hit or miss. I've had to call people out in those groups for being hateful or promoting female stereotypes and been attacked for it; I've seen posts about hating little boys for their male genes not widely downvoted, and 'zealots pushing some sort of hate-fueled anti-man agenda' make those spaces uncomfortable. I feel politically homeless or 'politically eclectic' — stuck between those groups and the QT/TRA side, which I also find toxic. I've felt isolated from any semblance of real community for a long time, which is why I was so relieved to find r/detrans.
I don't hate trans people — I hate what's happening to their movement. I don't hate men; I just want being a lesbian (a homosexual female) to be accepted in society. I've been verbally attacked by transwomen as well as by other lesbians who support 'male privilege to identify as lesbian.' I'm outspoken against medicalizing gender-nonconforming youth: I don't agree that medical intervention in a healthy body's natural development is essential, since many teenage girls horrified by their developing bodies grow out of it by adulthood, and impeding development robs them of that opportunity. I believe the discomfort comes from societal pressure to achieve beauty standards, accept a role as sex objects, and perform femininity. I've said the movement 'brainwashes people into total self-loathing denial about their biology' and that desisters have a role to play in pushing back: 'our experiences of going blind and then regaining our sight gives us the power to guide the rest of society through this dark period in history.' I'm 'never going to stop fighting' this movement despite the hostility it draws.
I'm a huge proponent of gender nonconformity and believe everyone should have the body that makes them most happy and express themselves however makes them happy, without denying biological sex. I'd be happy to date another desister or detrans lesbian. I've offered support to others considering detransition, telling one person 'you detransed the moment you embraced yourself as a man.' I also follow an eclectic spiritual path I've taken since I was thirteen, not devoting myself to any one school of thought.
Current status: I'm a desisted, gender critical lesbian woman. I'm happy and increasingly confident, though I remain politically homeless and continue advocacy against the gender movement and the medicalization of youth.