Alle verhalen

Een derde kamp na jaren heen en weer slingeren over gender

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd99
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die zich van binnen nog androgyn voelt en een genderneutrale naam en voornaamwoorden verkiest, maar zich niet langer als trans of non-binair identificeert en niet medisch wil transitioneren. Ik heb sinds mijn tienerjaren heen en weer geslingerd over gender, ben nog enigszins dysfoor en heb gekozen om in elk geval gedeeltelijk te desisteren terwijl ik me eerlijk en op eigen voorwaarden presenteer. Ik ben kritisch over zowel transactivistische als detrans-dogma’s, ontgoocheld door transactivisme en gefrustreerd door detransitioners die in de tegenovergestelde richting door gender geobsedeerd raken. Ik ben nooit een sterke pleitbezorger van de transitie van anderen geweest en altijd voorzichtig geweest met hormonen en operaties. Ik heb geen vermelde geschiedenis van suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging sinds mijn detransitie.

Volledig verhaal

I've flip-flopped on gender since my teens and I'm well into adulthood now and still in limbo — probably always will be, which is a good enough reason for me not to medically transition and to desist at least partially, even if I go through social roles like it's underwear until I die of old age. I still feel internally androgynous and prefer gender-neutral names, titles and pronouns, and I always will. But I don't want to medically transition, even though I questioned it before. That's led to a more easy-going approach to social transition too. I've found the best thing is to just be as honest and unrestrained as possible in my own presentation and self-expression, trying not to obsess with how other people see me or whether I pass or not, because that can be limiting. I like the odd bit of feminine accessories and was too afraid to wear them for ages. I try to let physical sex be the objective and relatively unimportant thing it is — think of it like having arms or hair. It's not the end of the world if people can tell what sex you are; it's freeing not to focus on that so hard. Taking really good care of the body I have improved my relationship with it — exercising, eating well, being the best version of my female self. I got into lifting; though I'm hardly Adonis, quite average really, it made me largely forget about physical dysphoria because at least I'm healthy. Part of why I stopped short of full medical transition is that it's too much effort and hassle, and I'm too much of a perfectionist — the level of transition I got to is just not good enough, so I'd rather be shrug about it. Friends and family making concerted efforts to treat me a certain way, while I'm grateful for it, feels much more shallow than the effortlessness of taking someone's sex at face value. It really highlighted how much of a performance it all is. I won't fill that male social niche in people's heads if I haven't gone the full nine yards, and by the time I decided against doing that I figured I should cut my losses. I never actively encouraged anyone to transition. I'd given passing tips before, lent a sympathetic ear, answered questions about name-change logistics if asked, but I've always been the cautious type about surgeries and hormones, so I never exceeded 'good luck, I hope it goes well for you.' I feel fine about it — I'm not a puppet master, I can't make anyone transition. On my name: I kept my chosen one because it was gender-neutral to begin with and I wanted a neutral one. I don't like my birth name for reasons unrelated to gender and wouldn't want to go back to it. I sometimes get tempted to change again because my current name, though neutral, is a bit stereotypically enby-sounding, but I'm far too lazy to get stubborn people used to a new name again — the first time was a chore. Since I'm neither trans nor enby anymore, I don't feel like a cliche anymore either. I've always considered gender to be all the subjective social stuff related to sex, whether it matches or no — 'man' the sex versus 'man' the concept. It's not worth lending too much material weight to; it's basically the sex equivalent of souls and spirits, and I'm not really a soul believer. I don't feel like I have a 'gender identity' and trying to apply one to myself and label it feels like a performance — being trans was merely another iteration of that. I'm just a me, and I happen to be a run-of-the-mill female of my species, and that's that; anything else is individual personality and ideas. I'm indifferent, and even trying to transition based on that indifference (enby transitions and such) would still be falling into the same trap of lending far too much importance to gender as an abstract. When I was a teenager I was a bit AAP — I used to get envious seeing gay men/boys make out with each other, and in my early 20s if I wore a packer I felt confident in a swaggy sort of way. I lost interest in that over time. I've noticed some people who detransition allow themselves to indulge in femininity or masculinity they didn't allow themselves in order to pass; I've started incorporating some femme into my aesthetic, but it wouldn't feel natural to go full-on hyperfeminine and wear strange clothes that make me physically uncomfortable. Other times I think it's overcompensation if prior medical transition really did a number on the person's appearance. Ideologically motivated detransition comes off a lot less natural, including when they're leaning heavily into their own sex's aesthetic or stereotype. I was already questioning and dysphoric when a certain film came out, so it really appealed to me. On policy: I'm all for bodily autonomy. I want an age limit for medical transition and I'm wondering whether 18 might even be too young, plus more thorough therapy leading up to it to rule out less risky dysphoria treatment first. But blanket bans will hurt more people than they help and will probably end up in more black-market HRT and backstreet surgeons resulting in even more complications. I have felt disillusioned towards trans activism for a long time and it causes me to do a massive eye roll whenever trans topics come up or a trans person is in the public spotlight again. I do sort of partake in a bit of transphobic humour for catharsis, but my actual values and principles are not transphobic and I don't want them to be. I've seen how far that disillusionment goes in some people and I don't want to become that, so I should avoid the gender-politics thing altogether if I want to move on and keep my principles intact. I've had issues with this detrans community too — the trans community's insistence that transition is the only way is wrong as we all know, but so is the detrans community dogma about transition always being wrong. It's very individual. On Discord especially it's very dogmatic; questioners who are more likely to stay trans at the end of the day don't get treated with the same respect as a questioner who is moments away from detransitioning, sometimes bordering on actual aggression. It's the same old shit TRAs do in reverse. It also frustrates and saddens me when detransitioners appear not to have truly learned from their experience and instead do a 180 and become gender-obsessed the other way. I sort of kept the pronoun stuff going longer than I needed to so I wouldn't lose my seat at the table — even though I wasn't even trying to pass and hadn't been for ages, I'd still use gender speak to refer to myself, especially online, because I knew whatever opinion I had wouldn't matter as much otherwise. I can't say 'as a...' to soften the impact of potentially going against the grain in a discussion. When I'm talking to trans friends and relate to something they say, I feel like I make things awkward when I join in because of the use of past tense — and if I talk in past tense I have to follow with what I do differently in the present tense, and I don't want to rub it in that I moved on or sound like I'm preaching. I'm not; I'm just chatting. On sexuality and kinks: people's kinks and sexualities can change over time naturally — I used to be AAP in my teens but lost interest. But it can't be forced, and I don't think it should be forced; that causes way more unneeded turmoil than accepting what you're into and finding the safest outlets. Consciously trying to rid yourself of a kink just gives it more presence in your head. On relationships: I'd tell someone not to force themselves to do anything they don't want to for a girlfriend, in case it doesn't work out anyway. While it helps widen your dating pool if you're not trans, you shouldn't repress anything for that reason alone. And if you have any doubt at all about a life-changing optional operation, don't do it. Songs that resonate with me right now: REM's 'Losing My Religion' and Dorian Electra's 'Yes Man' — ironic considering the artist is non-binary, but the lyrics still resonate.