Alle verhalen

Nooit getransitioneerd, maar toch gepost in detrans-ruimtes

Man · Gedesisteerd202
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een man in de dertig, vrij van detransitie, die zich de hele tijd dat ik in detrans-ruimtes postte als cis identificeerde; ik transitioneerde nooit, al had ik milde dysforie van mijn 12e tot 14e, geworteld in de hardheid die van jongens wordt gevraagd, en wilde ik in mijn vroege tienerjaren kort een meisje zijn. Ik kwam in de gemeenschap als linkse ‘weird Twitter’-commentator die pas rond eind 2019 hoorde dat detransitie een fenomeen was, en ik plaatste advies waarin ik gendernonconforme jongeren aanspoorde niet medisch te transitioneren. Ik ben scherp kritisch op transactivistische ideologie en de op winst gerichte medische aanpak, terwijl ik aandring op compassie voor dysfore individuen, en ik merkte op dat veel posters op de sub suïcidaal zijn. Ik heb geen spijt van medische ingrepen omdat ik er nooit een onderging, en mijn genderverwarring loste vanzelf op toen ik ouder werd. Ik steun mensen die zichzelf en gendernonconform zijn, maar ben sceptisch over medische transitie en non-binaire identiteit.

Volledig verhaal

I'm a man in my 30s who came up in the bohemian scene, and I've never been trans myself, but I ended up spending a lot of time in detrans spaces because I wanted to understand what people were going through and, honestly, because I had strong opinions about what I'd seen happen to young people around gender. My own brush with this was mild and early: I had dysphoria from about 12 to 14, driven mostly by the gendered expectations placed on boys — the toughness, the aggression, the constant goading to prove strength and courage through drugs, petty crime, sports, and sex. I also wanted to be a girl in my early teens for the same reason: the male role felt alien to my personality. But I never had serious dysphoria, and I never transitioned. I'm male by virtue of my sex, and that doesn't stop me from pursuing feminine interests, dressing how I want, or having close female friends. Over time the gender confusion burned off and I grew into myself. I'm SO glad I didn't have people pushing me to be trans. I described myself variously as a cis guy and, at one point, as a "(cis) man" writing to women on the detrans sub who thought they might be trans. I told them directly: if you're a boyish girl, medically transitioning will just turn you into an effeminate man, and that's no picnic. I spoke from experience as a relatively effeminate man who went through socialization as a heterosexual man — men are rough with one another, expect each other to be tough, and mock you if you're "a pussy" or a "fag." I endured a lot of physical aggression growing up. Even as an adult in male spaces, men are hard on other men perceived as weak. I told one poster I'd never met a trans man who comes close to passing in terms of manner or who would be accepted into the male social world, and that in private, reflexively, guys refer to them all as she/her. I also noted that three trans women are in one of my all-male group chats, but you never see trans men accepted as "one of the guys." I acknowledged this wasn't something to defend, just reality. I was pretty open about my own confusion and about how I'd wanted to be a girl as a teen because of what maleness demanded of me. I told posters that being a human is super confusing, that abstract gender roles feel alien to many young people of both sexes, and that once you get older you don't think much about your gender. I also said I don't really get the difference between a butch lesbian and a trans man — to me it's basically a semantic distinction — and that behaviorally, men and trans men are not similar at all. I came to the detrans community somewhat by accident. I described myself as a "left/weird Twitter guy" and said detrans simply isn't discussed in that circle. For about a year I only saw the super positive, ultra pro-TRA message; I honestly wasn't aware detrans was a phenomenon until a month or two before writing that (late 2019). I asked whether I shouldn't reply at all, since I wasn't detrans myself, but noted all my interactions had been positive. My views on the medical and ideological side are sharply critical. I have major reservations about "TRA ideology" and the for-profit trans medical niche. I think awareness of bad outcomes is treated as transphobic, that figures like Singal and Herzog are suppressed and stigmatized, and that the view presented on the left has such an optimistic spin it's basically fiction. I hoped for a more balanced view that's supportive of trans people but critical of the ideology and the full-steam-ahead medical approach. I said the detrans subreddit's existence is a particular threat to that ideology because it's not transphobic — it's people telling their own stories — and that it proves a laissez-faire policy in medicine has enormous risks. At the same time I tried to hold a compassionate line. I said disdain or disgust for dysphoric individuals is heartless and cruel; they're often very young and getting terrible advice from adults and woke society. I extended the same to AGP individuals, saying blame lies with social institutions telling AGP guys they really are women, not with teenage boys having confusing feelings — most get over it once they start dating and having healthy relationships. I explicitly warned other posters that many people on the detrans sub are fragile and some posts feature explicit plans to commit suicide, so harsh takes could push someone over the edge. I criticized a commenter's "open wounds" remark as unsympathetic to someone who'd already had surgery, saying gendercritical is a better place for unvarnished opinions. I distinguished GC feminists (typically left-wing, sympathetic to detrans people) from right-wing transphobia, though I also said misgendering people to their face comes off as cruel. I was skeptical of non-binary identity in particular: I said I don't believe a non-binary gender exists and consider non-binary people men or women, and that Tumblr Gender Theory picks and chooses based on what people want to believe, allowing mutually exclusive categories to be claimed together. I also asked genuine questions — whether the autism-trans link reflects social rather than innate dysphoria, whether dysphoria would exist if the male social role aligned better with one's personality. I never had surgery, never took hormones, and never socially transitioned. My dysphoria resolved on its own by my mid-teens. I don't regret anything medically because nothing was done to me; if anything I feel a kind of survivor's gratitude that I wasn't caught up in it. I'm supportive of gender non-conforming people — my advice to a boyish girl was simply "be yourself, be gender non-conforming, who cares?" — but I'm critical of medical transition as currently practiced, especially for minors and for people whose dysphoria seems rooted in discomfort with gender roles rather than sex itself. I don't advocate for banning anything; I want a culture that can discuss detransition openly and that treats dysphoric individuals with sympathy rather than either gloating contempt or uncritical affirmation.