Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I have never made a full transition myself, but I went through a period where I thought I might be trans, and I worked through it without medically transitioning. Looking back, I describe it as a pretty normal thing people go through — sometimes the brain just decides it wants something, and that doesn't mean it can or should have it. I compared it to getting a crush on someone who wants nothing to do with you, where your brain goes into a kind of mourning even though there was never a relationship. I mostly got over thinking I might be trans by distracting myself with other intense interests, and it went away on its own. I told others in similar positions not to beat themselves up about it, figuratively or literally.
I've thought a lot about what contributed to my own feelings. I noticed that teenage dysphoria can run in families: my mum decided when she was 14 that she didn't want to be an adult and starved herself, while I decided I didn't want to be a woman. We are both the eldest child, which I understand to be another risk factor for being gender non-conforming in women. I also believe gender dysphoria can arise from many sources — it can be a symptom of other problems, including OCD or psychosis, and I've noted that AGP can lead to gender dysphoria in very masculine middle-aged men just as much as being gender non-conforming can. I've said that many people get gender dysphoria from transitioning itself because they start worrying about passing.
I've also reflected on mourning identity change generally. I read a book called The New Black that described mourning as a process of rewriting your whole life without the person you've lost in it — and I applied that to people mourning their old life and identity after detransitioning, saying that once you get through that process you can move on. I've advised people who are considering detransitioning to first build a new social circle of openly gay people and to distance themselves from people who might become abusive or manipulative, so that if they make the change those people can't hurt them as much.
I've been critical of the affirmative model of care. I've said that even if therapists got more training right now, it would just be 100% toward being more affirmative. I've also commented that big pharma has pressured doctors to affirm anyone who says they are a chicken nugget. I've cited statistics — in the UK only 5000 people have GRCs, in Scotland around 50, and the Tavistock clinic got 2500 referrals last year — and I've argued that research into detransitioning has been shut down. I've said we are currently seeing a spike in young female detransitioners because there has been a spike in girls transitioning.
On medical matters I've given practical advice to others. I've discussed laser hair removal sessions (15 minutes is fine, use sunscreen, dark hair responds best), noting it's permanent but not 100% and won't remove lighter hairs. I've talked about the cost — my sister got a laser deal for all of her body for £1k about 10 years ago. I've discussed binding-like sensations, surgical risks including bowel-related smell issues in certain surgeries, and advised getting multiple second opinions before surgery. I've warned against feeling forced into surgery because of someone else's long waiting list and suggested asking to be moved down the list. I've said testosterone causes cysts and is basically like giving yourself PCOS at a far worse level than any woman would get naturally, and I've discussed PCOS, metformin, insulin spikes, and low-GI diets. I've also discussed skin differences (men and people on T have oilier skin), breast ligaments and bra fit, and stretching exercises for height.
I've been open about my own employment history: I crashed out of university without qualifying and was out of work for a good 6 months before I got an offer, after which I haven't had much issue finding work. I joined an amateur dramatics group when I was friendless and made around 50 friends straight away. I've described myself as an introvert who finds the social expectations of being a woman really hard, but I've said that dislike doesn't make me a man.
On sexuality and relationships I've been frank. I've said I would date a trans person if they didn't have any red flags. I've criticised what I see as manipulative dynamics in some relationships, comparing them to incel thinking. I've said the trouble is a lot of guys who transition really believe that submissive, lazy sex is feminine. I've advised someone whose issues stemmed from sexual frustration to seek a proper sex therapist rather than one who concentrates only on feelings and history.
I've been a regular presence in detrans and gender-critical online spaces through 2019, commenting extensively on posts from people considering or going through detransition, and I shared a post about a detrans piece on BBC2 Newsnight and a BBC Radio 4 programme. I've expressed sympathy for people detransitioning after surgery who post in hopeless states, saying I can rarely give them comfort, and I noted it's good to know some might just be getting on with their lives. I've also reacted supportively to someone who found comfort in being themselves, saying they look like a blond version of me.