Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde (gedesisteerde) vrouw die sociaal transitioneerde, een mannelijke naam en voornaamwoorden gebruikte, en daarna terugging naar mijn vrouwelijke naam, nadat radicaal-feministische lectuur en de ervaringen van andere detransitioners op Tumblr me hielpen vrouwzijn weer te zien als biologisch en waardevrij. Ik denk niet dat transitioneren een goede behandeling is voor genderdysforie, al respecteer ik de keuzes van anderen en gebruik ik de gevraagde voornaamwoorden. Het loslaten van genderrollen en het concept gender was wat het grootste deel van mijn dysforie deed verdwijnen, al steekt die af en toe nog de kop op. Een gendertherapeut die zei dat mijn twijfels geïnternaliseerde transfobie waren, hielp me niet; desisten voelde veel beter. Ik ben vrouw, val op mannen, ben gender-nonconform en noem mezelf nu een gedesisteerde/gedetransitioneerde vrouw.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up gender nonconforming, and I developed gender dysphoria at some point in my life — though the transcript doesn't give me a specific age for when it first started. What I do know is that I ended up socially transitioning and living as a man for a period, using a male name and male pronouns, before eventually desisting and going back to my female name.
The path toward desisting was largely intellectual and community-based. Reading radical feminism and second-wave feminist writing helped me a lot in dealing with my dysphoria. I also found it really helpful to read the experiences of other detransitioners on Tumblr. Even though I had previously believed in theory that men and women could be anything personality-wise, it took seeing other women's experiences of gender nonconformity and/or dysphoria until it really clicked, and the concept of woman stopped seeming foreign and unreachable to me — it became value-neutral. One blog I liked in particular was permutational.tumblr.com, which talked about living as a bearded lady and other detrans experiences.
A key turning point was realizing that gender itself functions almost like an ideology. Part of my desisting was realizing that all the things that make a trans woman a woman are not actually related to being female at all. That fundamentally changed my definition of woman to biological female, because that's what I am — and if it were anything else, I couldn't be it, and neither could plenty of other dysphoric or butch women. I also came to think that most people don't have a 'gender' in the way trans people do, so by a trans person's definition they aren't even 'cis.' If cis means not defining yourself by artificial gender roles, then I guess I'm cis.
I also want to be clear about what happened with therapy. I had a gender-related therapist who thought my questioning was just internalized transphobia and that I should learn to accept that I'm trans. I desisted anyway and felt a lot better. That experience made me cautious about gender-focused therapists in general — I think they can be helpful for dealing with underlying trauma or other emotions that may be causing dysphoria, but I wouldn't suggest them as a fix-all solution for gender questions.
The people who opposed my transition while I was going through it tried to say dysphoria didn't exist, which was really not helpful. I get frustrated when people imply trans people are just doing it because they think it's cool. I wish more people would acknowledge dysphoria and the reasons for transition while still being able to criticize transitioning as a solution — which is how I figured out desisting, through radfem arguments.
Coming back to my female name wasn't easy at first. I disliked the name and pronouns initially, but I didn't want to change again because it's confusing when the name doesn't match legal documents and changing those takes work. Once I got used to hearing them again, I like them now. A big part of the reason I decided to go back to my female name was that it's the one on all my official documents, so it's less confusing.
On the substance of what resolved my dysphoria: finally completely letting go of gender roles, and the concept of gender completely, was what made my dysphoria go away. I still get it occasionally, but I realize the source isn't actually my body, even if it feels like it — it's the discomfort of being in a feminine role that I don't like. As a female, finding other gender nonconforming females helped; I was mostly seeing butch people online, since it isn't easy to find gnc females in real life who aren't some flavor of trans. I think internalized gender roles probably make up most of dysphoria, even when it presents as body dysphoria.
I also think a lot about the role of homophobia. A lot of homophobic people may agree with components of trans ideology — the idea of being in the wrong body was originally used against gay people. I could see someone with internalized homophobia trying to 'solve' their same-sex attraction using trans rationalizations. I also believe AGP and AAP exist and can make someone stick to transitioning when they might otherwise detransition, with the amount seeming much higher in trans women, which partly explains why they detransition less. Even AAP female-to-male cases seem also motivated by internalized misogyny a lot.
On sexuality and relationships: I'm only attracted to men, as far as I know. While I hated feeling objectified by nature of existing as female, I also see ways it sucks to be male, and the assertive/submissive roles common in relationships make sense to me. I feel like I'd never want to date a guy because even if there's technically some guy out there who shares my views on gender, finding him seems pretty much impossible. I guess I could just be single forever — that was my plan when I was younger anyway.
I live in an LGBT dorm with a lot of trans people who would not agree with my views on gender. I've said to trans people before that, as it relates to me, I define a woman as someone with two X chromosomes because I couldn't be one if the definition were any different (as a gnc female with dysphoria), while making clear I still respect other trans people's decisions and use their pronouns. I've never had issues with them outwardly being offended, though I don't know what they actually think. I stay away from talking about the movement's issues for feminism with people in real life.
My current beliefs: I don't think transitioning is a good treatment for gender dysphoria, so I can't agree with it, but I don't think there's any reason to be a jerk to people about it, which is why I'm happy to respect them if they want me to refer to them in a certain way. I also don't think there's such a thing as 'cis' or 'trans' in the way people usually think of it — transition is a choice you make based on whether you think it will be beneficial to you. I've advised people considering HRT to think about how happy transitioning will make them in the long run, since it's constant upkeep, goals keep moving, and gender euphoria generally wears off after a few years.
I don't describe myself as having had any surgeries, and the transcript doesn't mention hormones for me specifically — my transition appears to have been social. I don't have any stated regrets about medical interventions because I don't recall describing undergoing them. I also don't have any stated mental health diagnoses in this transcript. I do mention that taking breaks from the internet can be great, since spending too much time at a screen is bad for your connection with your body and can lead to dysphoria too.
I currently identify as a detransitioned/desisted woman — a gender nonconforming female with dysphoria who chose not to continue with transition.