Alle verhalen

Zichzelf dagelijks overtuigen — tot ze ermee ophield

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd730
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die een tijd als trans identificeerde nadat ik eerst als lesbienne had geïdentificeerd, en medio 2021 desisteerde nadat ik besefte dat ik mezelf uitputte met elke dag proberen mezelf te overtuigen dat ik trans was. Ik ervoer ernstige dysforie vanaf de puberteit rond 2011, verergerende depressie en suïcidale gedachten — op een gegeven moment geloofde ik dat ik mezelf voor het eind van de maand van het leven zou beroven als ik als trans bleef identificeren. Ik ben nooit met hormonen begonnen of had een operatie. Ik steun nu de transities van anderen terwijl ik geloof dat transitie mij niet zal helpen, en ik ben kritisch over zowel het afwijzen van detransitioners door de transgemeenschap als over TERF-/transfobe retoriek van detransitioners. Mijn dysforie en twijfel zijn aanhoudend en wisselend geweest, en ik ben soms onzeker, maar ik verankert mezelf door te willen moeder worden en me voor te stellen als oma.

Volledig verhaal

I first hit dysphoria 'like a fucking truck' during puberty — this month marks the tenth anniversary of that, so it started around 2011 when I was going through puberty as a female. I grew up in a deeply religious and conservative family and community, which meant I had no one to talk to about what I was feeling. I started questioning my gender around a year before June 2021 (so roughly mid-2020). At first I identified as a lesbian for a while, and then I started identifying as transgender. My dysphoria, which had already been worsening over the preceding few years, skyrocketed once I identified as trans. I drove myself insane questioning — I would swing from 'of course I'm trans, it's so obvious' to 'transitioning is the biggest mistake I will make in my life' within five minutes. I broke down crying numerous times, which I usually never do. Those months were some of the hardest and loneliest of my life. I was suicidal and got through each day by reminding myself that I was going to transition and it would all be okay in the end. Even before the bullying I experienced, I already had a lot of dysphoria, which is why I don't agree with people who claim 'the bad patriarchy made you feel that way.' I have tons of feminine hobbies, and my dysphoria was unrelated to gender stereotypes. I told myself early on what I now know to be true: that I would have felt just as uncomfortable as a guy, if not more, because my personality, hobbies, and even my dysphoria don't fit within the narrow realms of gender, and I can just be myself. But then the dysphoria, depression, and questioning got too much and I couldn't take it anymore — I needed the answer that could give me hope for the future. I was looking for something I could control, that at least if I fucked up my life I would be in control of it. Around June 2021 I desisted after my mental health got really bad from obsessing over gender-related stuff, and I was honestly surprised at how happy I felt — happier than I'd felt in years. But it didn't last; I posted that I was 'so sick of these kinds of generalizations' and that I was 'tired of questioning.' I said I feel like a guy, but that I like being a girl and don't necessarily want to be a guy — I just want the terrible feelings of dysphoria to go away. Things that ground me: I really, really want to be a mum (not a dad), and I can't imagine myself as a guy past the age of about 30 or being happy as an older man. On the other hand, I get really happy imagining myself as an old grandma knitting in an armchair. I wished for a time machine to skip straight to that age. In May 2021 I posted that I was proud of the detrans community for being brutally honest about what it's like to transition and then detransition and realize you made a mistake. I criticized the trans community for treating detransitioners as a tiny percentage that can be dismissed, and for implying detransitioners were pressured into it or never had dysphoria — I found that offensive and infantilizing. I said a big reason the trans community is dismissive is that many detrans people had very similar pre-transition experiences to other trans people (hating secondary sex characteristics, being uncomfortable in your body, disliking enforced gender roles), and realizing that people with similar experiences still detransitioned is terrifying for them. At that point I wrote that I was 'still not sure if I want to transition or not' — I had posted about a month earlier saying I had officially desisted, but 'it turns out that things are not that simple.' I have no respect for detrans people who become TERFs/transphobes or try to gatekeep trans medical healthcare (like Kiera Bell). I also pushed back against a poster on this sub who called trans people 'delusional' and described trans women as men who want to invade personal spaces — I said that language is offensive and helps no one, that every detransitioner was once a trans person, and that I have on-and-off really bad dysphoria and wouldn't want anyone to feel that pain. I said if transitioning helps someone else, I will support them 100% — I just know it won't help me. I also disagreed with blanket statements like 'no one is really trans.' The final straw for me was realizing I didn't want to spend my life running away from myself and fighting my family and society at every turn. Funnily enough, the practical details were part of it: thinking about all the documents I'd have to make from three different countries (one of which would almost certainly ban me from entering it) and the cost of top surgery. And just realizing I was so exhausted from the energy it took to keep convincing myself I was trans every single day. One time I literally opened a website that would analyze a subreddit's viewership by gender and panicked that I was on mostly female-majority subs. Then something snapped in me and I realized this was not healthy or normal, and I was going to kill myself by the end of the month if I kept identifying as trans because of how depressed I was. I realized how many of my problems were unrelated to me being trans, and working on them one at a time would be better than just taking hormones and praying they would solve everything. I'd developed such a distorted and sexualized view of what it meant to be female, when in reality all I need to be a 'real girl' is to exist any way I want to. I never started hormones or had any surgeries as far as my posts indicate. On sexuality: I've always been really grossed out by sex and dreaded the idea of having sex in real life. I thought this was because of my dysphoria and that transitioning would help, because I did fantasize about having sex (just with me not in it) and read erotica. I thought there was something wrong with me because everyone seemed to want to have sex no matter how dysphoric they were, but to me it seemed like a chore. I asked if others here are asexual. Separately, I've said I'm bi but can't really see myself with a girl, and that it sucks because I feel most guys wouldn't date a masculine girl, though the dating pool of straight guys is larger than gay guys. I'm critical of makeup as a concept — that 90% of women have to wear it or they're told they look unprofessional or ugly, and I hate how the industry frames products as 'empowering.' I also pushed back on Tumblr notes claiming girls naturally like dresses and makeup. I've advised that phrases like 'explore your gender,' 'stop being in denial,' or 'transition now before it's too late' are especially harmful to people with anxiety or OCD-ish tendencies. I offered to DM someone who was tired of questioning, and sent love to someone struggling. As of my last post in June 2021, I was still desisted but dealing with ongoing, on-and-off dysphoria and exhaustion from questioning.