Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben geboren als vrouw, voelde me sinds mijn peutertijd een jongen en transitioneerde als kind sociaal en met onderbrekingen tot halverwege of eind van mijn tienerjaren, maar koos ervoor nooit medisch te transitioneren omdat FTM-operaties me nooit een volledig functioneel mannenlichaam zouden geven. Ik desisteerde halverwege tot eind van mijn tienerjaren en gebruikte radicale zelfacceptatie, een reïncarnatiegeloof, feminisme als doel en het bewust vinden van een onconventionele vrouwelijke stijl die ik mooi vond om mijn dysforie door te werken. Ik kreeg ook de diagnose BPS, waar jaren DGT niet bij hielp, tot gespecialiseerde C-PTSS-traumatherapie die klachten oploste. Ik ben nu een gedetransitioneerde vrouw in de dertig, helemaal gelukkig in mijn vrouwenlichaam, en heb al meer dan tien jaar geen genderdysforie meer gehad. Ik pleit voor zichtbaarheid van detrans en ben uitgesproken over mijn zorgen over de snelle medische transitie van kinderen, omdat ik geloof dat ik tegenwoordig als kind zou zijn getransitioneerd en daar diep spijt van zou hebben gehad.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female. I can't remember a time before I felt like a boy — I was saying I was a boy in the wrong body since I was a toddler, and I lived as a boy socially in every conceivable way as a child. I dressed like a boy, played rough and tumble, and if anyone had asked me as a kid, I would have been 1000% certain I wanted to transition; I wasn't questioning or fluid, I just felt like a boy. I socially transitioned as a child and then on and off again through my mid-to-late teens, vacillating between tomboy and living as a boy during my teen years. My dysphoria was worst as a kid and a teen, and got worse at the onset of puberty before calming down toward the end of it.
I never medically transitioned, and I never mistakenly transitioned due to external factors like trauma or peer pressure. I didn't have any sexual trauma. What stopped me was looking honestly at what medical transition would actually produce. I realized I would never be a real man — not functionally and not aesthetically. I wanted to look down at male pecs and a real penis, not chest and arm scars, feminine hips, and what I called a "barely functional pseudo-penis made out of forearm skin." FTM surgery results just weren't adequate to what I actually wanted, which was to be a natural man with fully functional male genitalia. So I made the decision to desist and focus on accepting the body and gender I had in this life.
A big part of how I got there was a belief system I was raised in. I was raised in a religion that believes in reincarnation, and it was simply understood that people often feel like a different gender if they were that gender in their most recent past life(s), and that most people grow out of it as they become accustomed to their new body. That framing made my dysphoria feel less like a cruel error I had to fight or suffer through, and more like something with a purpose. I came to believe there was something valuable for me to learn from being a woman in this life. I also found non-religious research on past lives — Ian Stevenson's work at the University of Virginia, with thousands of case studies of children remembering past lives, including cases of children who were other genders — which aligned with my own experience and reinforced my decision.
My process of acceptance was deliberate and structured. First, I radically accepted myself — I took transitioning off the table entirely, because I'd been going back and forth for years and it was exhausting. There was a real sense of freedom and closure in saying "we're done with that now." Second, I gave it a purpose: feminism. If I had to be a woman in this life, I decided I might as well do good with it, the way some prisoners become prisoner-rights activists. Third, and this was huge, I focused positively. I actively looked for what was good about being a woman and what was unique to that experience. A trick that helped me early on was realizing I would like certain body parts on another person even if they felt foreign on me — my breasts, for instance, felt weird, but I could acknowledge they had a nice shape and were a good size. I focused on things like my strong legs, on appreciating female friendships and the special bonds in them, and on being an active feminist. Fourth, I found and created a version of femininity I actually liked. I've always been a tomboy type — I hate pink and frilly things, they made me feel like a boy in a dress. When I started wearing all black, form-fitting clothes, I felt better. My energy is strong tomboy, not girly and submissive. Figuring out I liked to be dominant in sexual relationships also helped.
Over time this worked. The dysphoria faded steadily, and I haven't had it in over a decade now. By my mid-twenties it was gone. I don't even dress like a tomboy anymore, though my style is still edgier and black rather than frilly — I fully wear women's clothes now and I even happily own a pink frilly dress, which is remarkable given that used to be the one thing that could still trigger dysphoria. I became a big fan of my body. I'm fully happy being a woman and mostly just don't think about it anymore. I'd still prefer to have been born a man with working male genitalia — that would have been easier — but I'm genuinely happy now, and I've grown through learning to accept something that wasn't how I'd have chosen it.
I was also diagnosed with BPD at some point and did years of DBT-style therapy for it, which didn't help. I was later diagnosed with C-PTSD and did specialized trauma therapy, after which my doctor said I no longer fit the BPD criteria. The trauma specialists I saw explained that BPD is really just a cluster of personality traits that develop from untreated complex trauma disrupting healthy personality development, usually neglect. I didn't think anything "that bad" had happened to me until I found a good trauma-informed therapist; then I could see all the ways my childhood affected me. That work helped me understand myself generally, separate from gender.
I'm now in my thirties. I think about my experience a lot in terms of what it means for kids today. If I'd grown up now, with how fast and easily children are medically transitioned, there's no way I wouldn't have ended up at a gender clinic, and I would have thought it was right at the time. It terrifies me that I might not have been given the chance to grow out of it, which for me happened after puberty. I'm very happy with my body and gender now and would have deeply regretted transitioning. I don't oppose transition for everyone — I believe dysphoria is real and trans people have always existed — but I don't agree that transitioning is the only way to resolve it, since that hasn't been my experience. I encourage detransitioners to speak up and at least tell their doctors, since studies show only about 24% of us do, which makes the medical field think we're rare. I try to be honest about my experience with trans friends without pushing an agenda, and I've advocated for people to question big decisions carefully, get to a good place mentally first, and not rush permanent changes for external reasons like insurance windows.