Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die mijn eerdere identificatie als trans nu ziet als geworteld in zelfhaat en geïnternaliseerd vrouwenhaat, en niet als iets wat intrinsiek bij mij hoorde. Dat mijn vriendengroep me verstootte om niet-gerelateerde politieke meningen, plus een vriend die me hielp mijn vrouwelijkheid te waarderen, bracht me richting desisteren, en toen ik dat deed vond ik het leven als vrouw veel makkelijker en gelukkiger. Ik geloof dat vroege blootstelling aan porno/fanfictie en seksueel trauma een rol spelen bij sommige mensen die zich als trans identificeren, en ik ben sceptisch over kinderen die toestemming geven voor medische transitie. Ik beschrijf zelf geen medische ingrepen te hebben gehad en blijf over het algemeen transitie steunen voor wie die echt nodig heeft.
Volledig verhaal
I believe there are people genuinely mentally ill enough that, with current technology, transition is what makes their life livable — that's roughly where I land on the question of whether transition is ever appropriate. But for me, looking back, I don't think transition was ever really my idea.
I've spent time trying to figure out how I realized I wasn't trans, and I've come to the conclusion that a good chunk of me leaving that space was people within it pushing me out, not the things the people in my life were saying to pull me. My mom was someone who knew me well enough to call it early, though at the time it felt like nothing anyone could say would help. I don't think that's true anymore. There's no code word that wakes you from a trance, but I do believe there are things that are genuinely beneficial to say — I'm just not always sure exactly what they are. Personally I think a ton of reassurance helps: family reminding a confused teenager that they are loved and more important to the family than the disagreement or situation. I want to be clear I'm not saying you can talk people out of being trans, but I think you may be able to talk a confused teenager who thinks they're trans out of the label.
What actually moved me toward desisting was a combination of things. My group of trans, gay, and liberal friends ousted me from the group over a difference of political opinions over something unrelated to identity — opinions I had always held that they suddenly started to take issue with. After a few months of not being around them, I realized I wasn't enjoying it anymore. Without the instant and constant validation from them, the hassle became more than it was worth.
Around the same time I got a boyfriend who actually made me enjoy my feminine characteristics for the first time. He helped me realize it was self hatred and, as much as I don't love the buzzwordiness of the phrase, internalized misogyny — and I don't mean he convinced me through conversation, I mean through showing me that I could be comfortable in a more male/female dynamic, and more so the way I was drawn to falling into it. Then I started hearing opinions that showcased the strength women can have, and that it's not just a weakness or something to hate about myself.
Once I desisted and saw just how much easier everything is and how much genuinely happier I was being a woman, that was it. I could finally see that it wasn't even my idea in the first place.
I also think a lot of people who end up identifying as trans get there partly through sexual factors. In my experience and observation, some are influenced by being exposed to porn too young — I hint at my own experience with a parenthetical about hardcore fanfiction. I've told someone directly to stop reading gay fanfic, that in my experience they probably aren't as into reading as they think, it's that it's porn. I also point out that all the fanfic is written by women, that those are 'men written by women,' which are nothing like real men and don't exist. If my guesses hit for someone in that situation, switching back to regular books might help.
On the argument that respecting someone's identity is about respect, I remember making that argument myself — 'it's about a lack of respect.' At least in my case it wasn't that it was disrespectful to be called a woman when I was one; it was more 'I've asked you to respect me by calling me XYZ and you're not.' I saw it as similar to calling someone a nickname you know they don't like but everyone calls them — I had that growing up too.
On the broader question, I've commented that anecdotally more girls are transitioning, so there are more of them able to detransition or desist. On the question of children medically transitioning, I've said it also wasn't really your decision if you were a child — I mean it was, but are we saying children can consent now?
I've also been on the other side of these conversations, offering reassurance to people early in or considering transition: telling someone flat out even though you're nervous that people are either nice and accepting or they aren't; complimenting someone's appearance; telling someone they're '100% female every time'; and telling someone not even a month off testosterone that they already look good and to give it time. I showed my mom a before-andafter-style post of someone going from miserable-looking to glowing, and told them I was so happy for them.
As for where I am now: I desisted, I'm happier as a woman, and I see my prior identification as trans as rooted in self-hatred and internalized misogyny rather than something intrinsic to me. I don't describe any medical interventions I had, so I can't speak to those. I don't talk about formal diagnoses, therapy, or medication. The main mental health thread I name is the self-hatred itself. My family — my mom in particular — was supportive and perceptive throughout. My social world shifted when my friend group ousted me, but I gained a boyfriend who was important to my detransition. I don't describe any specific regret about medical changes because I don't discuss having had any; the regret I express is more about lost time and the realization that the identity wasn't mine to begin with. I'm generally supportive of transition for people who genuinely need it, but skeptical that most people who end up identifying as trans — especially teenagers — actually do.