Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw en radicaal feministe die in de tatoeagebranche werkt. Ik heb publiekelijk gepleit tegen medische transitie, anderen geadviseerd dat ze hun mindset kunnen veranderen in plaats van hun lichaam, en ik heb angst geuit voor kinderen die nu opgroeien. Ik heb sterke opvattingen over de effecten van hormonen op persoonlijkheid, gebaseerd op mijn eigen zwangerschapservaring. In deze berichten heb ik geen persoonlijke transitie- of detransitietijdlijn beschreven, noch operaties, medicatie of diagnoses. Ik blijf bij mijn standpunt, ook als het massaal wordt gedownvoted.
Volledig verhaal
I'm a woman who works in the tattoo industry — I've said before that I'm a 'woman in the tattoo industry' and that there are 'a few of us' in this community, so I know I'm not alone in holding the views I hold. I've been tattooing people for a while, including emergency service workers, and I've noticed that the darker the things a person sees in their work, the darker their general sense of humour tends to be — I think it's a coping mechanism for tremendous strain and it works, and when you know it's all in good nature it's also an incredible bonding tool, a way of someone saying 'I trust you.'
I identify as a radical feminist. I've said so explicitly when arguing with people online: 'for reference I am a radical feminist.' My feminism shapes how I think about gender, transition, and womanhood. I'm critical of what I see as the objectification and dehumanisation of women in certain views of femininity — I've argued that 'is femininity just a performance of submission for the viewers pleasure? That's a male mindset,' and that 'only a self hating, emotionally unhealthy woman would view their womanhood like that and only because it's been pressed upon them by men.' I don't think wanting to be objectified is inherently feminine — I've said it's 'just a kinky thing. You can do and be that as male.'
I have strong views about hormones and personality. I've argued that hormones have a huge effect on personalities, pointing to my own experience of pregnancy: 'They certainly did mine, I learned a lot about sticking up for myself from pregnant me that plain hormone me would have taken 10 years of incremental shifting and working against my former personality to achieve.' I've also referenced the words of transitioners who claim their personality shifts once they start hormones, and I've argued that testosterone's effects on personality — particularly in conjunction with mental illness — help explain why 'war and rape and control issues' are more of a male issue than a female one. I reject the idea that female subjugation was purely societal construction, arguing that it existed 'even before we knew about hormones' and that framing it as social construction 'suggests we're socially weak enough to be willfully subjugated for thousands of years, which couldn't be further from the truth.' I also raised the point about medication that changes internal chemical balancing issues as part of the same conversation.
I distinguish between clothing and style, which I see as 'pure culture,' and masculinity and femininity, which I believe 'are found regardless of culture, time, religion etc. They're separate entities.'
I've given advice to someone considering transition, encouraging them not to change their body: 'No bit of you needs to die off, my darling, you can be a man with a femme side... The only bit of you that needs to die, my friend, is the idea that you need to change your body rather than your mindset.' I told them to take the moment as a turning point, to better understand themselves, and that 'if you get good at that (it's hard and takes lots of practice) the rest will fall into place around you.' I praised them for making 'a brave call.' I've spoken about my own partner — describing him as soft, chatty and gentle in personality, femme enough that people question if he's gay — and about an older partner who was femme in image more than personality but used that as camouflage in a corporate setting. I've also referred to having been 'through a hurdle of narcissists and nutters right out the womb,' which suggests difficult relationships early in my life.
I've expressed concern about the current climate around gender, saying simply: 'I fear for kids today.'
In arguments I can be blunt and combative — I've accused others of 'internalised misogyny and social re-training' getting in the way of reading arguments clearly, and I've pushed back hard when I feel people are putting words in my mouth, saying 'you're reading things from me that were never stated.' Some of my comments were heavily downvoted, which suggests my views are unpopular in the spaces I've been posting in, but I hold them firmly.