Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd, maar bij mezelf dezelfde aantrekkingskracht tot transitie herkent die ik nu bij jongeren online zie. Ik was een extreme fujoshi, een meisje dat van m/m-inhoud houdt, en kwam dicht bij het te ver doorvoeren van transitie voordat ik mezelf accepteerde als mannelijk, waarschijnlijk lesbisch of homoseksueel meisje. Ik post en reageer nu actief en betoog dat de meeste adolescente genderdysforie normaal is en dat veel jongeren eigenlijk gewoon homo of lesbisch zijn, en ik veroordeel online transcultuur als regressief en homofoob. Ik heb spijt van de jaren dat ik geloofde dat ik een wezenlijk deel van mezelf moest veranderen om geaccepteerd te worden, al beschrijf ik geen eigen operaties of hormonale ingrepen. Ik zie mezelf nu als vrouw en pleit kritisch tegen transitie voor jongeren.
Volledig verhaal
I came to understand my own experience through arguing with young people online who were heading toward transition, because I recognized exactly what they were describing — I had been the same way myself.
I was a girl who was deeply into m/m (male/male) fictional content, what people call a fujoshi. Looking back, I describe my younger self as "just an extreme version of a fujoshi" who "got a little carried away and took it too far." I consumed so much of that material that it shaped how I related to my own sex and to the idea of being a woman. When I was younger I also wanted to be a tomboy or a lesbian, and I think that was the healthier, more accurate expression of who I was.
I did not transition, and I now push back hard on the idea that someone who never transitioned can claim experience as a gay man. When I see young women who are really just lesbians or gender-nonconforming girls heading toward hormones or surgery, I tell them plainly: "Your probably just a lesbian not trans," and "You might be gay this is is how gay people feel." I believe a lot of what young people experience as gender dysphoria is actually normal adolescent discomfort — I say that "everyone gets gender dysphoria at adolescence and most grow out of it," that it is a documented phenomenon, and that the feeling of being out of place in your body or in how society perceives you is completely normal and something most people simply grow through.
What troubles me most is the scale and the speed of it. I have written that "so many young people are going through this right now" and asked them to ask themselves why. I posted that "Toxic trans culture online is ruining the youth of the west. It is regressive and homophobic," and in another post titled "We are regressing somehow" I argued that what is happening to so many young people in the West "should count as a crime against humanity." I see it as a deeply homophobic movement — one that tells young gay and gender-nonconforming people that they must change their bodies to fit in, rather than accepting them as they are.
The core of what I feel is sadness and anger at the idea that we are taught to reject an integral part of ourselves. I have written: "Its sad we think we need to change an integral part of ourselves and mutilate our bodies to be accepted." It took me a long time to accept myself as I was — to accept that I was a masculine, possibly gay or lesbian girl rather than a boy — and I recognize that struggle in the young people I argue with. I know the pull of that identity, the sense that changing your body is the only route to being understood, because I felt it too.
I do not describe a formal medical transition of my own — no hormones, no surgeries are mentioned in my posts — so my regret is not about irreversible physical changes but about the years I spent believing I needed to become someone else, and about how close I came to taking it further. I now advocate openly, mostly in online communities, urging young people to consider that they might simply be gay, lesbian, or tomboys, and to question why so many of their peers are going down the same path. I am critical of transition as it is currently offered to young people, though I do not frame my views as blanket opposition for everyone — my focus is on young people, on gay and gender-nonconforming youth, and on the online culture I see as driving them toward irreversible changes they may later regret.