Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde (gedesisteerde) vrouw die vijf jaar, van mijn 19e tot 24e, als non-binair identificeerde zonder ooit medisch te transitioneren. Mijn trans-identificatie hing nauw samen met kindertrauma — een verslaafde moeder, een afwezige vader, meerdere verkrachtingen als pre-tiener — plus autisme en PTSS die op de universiteit werden vastgesteld, en een verlangen naar gemeenschap en zelf onder andere tienermeisjes die zich buiten vrouwelijkheid identificeerden. Ik desisteerde op mijn 24e door persoonlijke groei en therapie bij een therapeut met kennis van trauma/C-PTSS, wat me uiteindelijk deed accepteren dat ik een mens ben. Ik beschouw mezelf als desister in plaats van detransitioner, en ik steun voorzichtige, goed gescreende transitie voor echt dysfore mensen, terwijl ik kritisch ben over transitie om door trauma gedreven of sociaal beïnvloede redenen, vooral voor minderjarigen.
Volledig verhaal
I came out as a lesbian and identified as nonbinary from age 19 to 24 — five years of identifying as trans, though I never medically transitioned. I consider myself a desister rather than a detransitioner because I only socially identified as nonbinary; my perception is that all detransitioners are desisters but not all desisters are detransitioners. I never felt connected to my birth name, and I chose a name on the masculine side of gender neutral while identifying as trans, which I still enjoy using.
I strongly considered medical transitioning at various points, primarily because of the potential benefit of male privilege. I'm a 6 ft tall butch woman from a family of tall bearded men and already get mistaken for a man in certain outfits, so passing would have been easy for me if I had gone on T. Even though I never identified as a man, there were times I was so frustrated by things like having women stare at me in women's bathrooms that I considered transition, because navigating the world as a man would have been easier than navigating it as a gender nonconforming woman. I don't think it would lead to automatic respect, especially during the period where I wouldn't be passing — just less of a hassle in certain areas of life.
Trying out he/him pronouns helped me make sure I'm not a man, and I'm happy I went that route rather than starting T while in the middle of my depression. I believe social transition should be the first step, and that if you aren't sure after socially transitioning you definitely shouldn't medically transition, because hormones have long lasting and potentially detrimental effects.
My childhood trauma definitely contributed to me understanding myself through a trans lens. I grew up with a mom who was addicted to hard drugs (meth) and an absent father. I was exposed to sex at a young age — hearing my mom have loud sex — and was raped multiple times as a pre-teen. I gained a lot of weight around puberty from eating to cope with my feelings and trauma, and started to feel dysphoric then as well. I was diagnosed with PTSD and autism in college shortly after I started identifying as trans, and I think it's all connected. For many years I felt like I was scrambling to build an identity for myself and to understand my discomfort with being perceived. I highly recommend working with a therapist knowledgeable in trauma/C-PTSD, because that's ultimately what made me okay with being a person.
When I started identifying as trans I was a deeply traumatized autistic teenager, and a lot of the teenage girls I was trying to be friends with were identifying out of womanhood and seeming to find community, connection and a sense of self in that — and I wanted it too. I was yearning for a sense of self, community and connection. I don't think I was manipulative when I was trans; I genuinely believed in most of it. I did perpetuate misogyny by identifying as trans and saying I wasn't a woman for being gender nonconforming, but I see that as internalized misogyny from living in a misogynistic society rather than something that made me a bad person. It was misguided but not manipulative.
I desisted at 24 after five years of identifying as trans, and it was definitely related to personal growth for me.
On the broader questions: I believe trauma can cause people to believe they're trans, and that an identity caused by trauma isn't as valid as an innate identity, though people's pronoun choices and presentation should be respected and mental health issues should be addressed as much as possible before medical transition. I think mental illness can cause trans identity because for some it's a coping mechanism, and that professionals often don't look hard enough into why people think they're trans — though trans people need to be doing their own introspection too. I think exposure to trans concepts online, especially with looser definitions of trans, can lead people to believe they're trans; a lot of how being nonbinary is described are feelings that lots of cis teen girls and boys feel too, especially those who are gender nonconforming, gay or lesbian, on the autism spectrum, or who just don't like gender roles. I believe fetish-based reasons for identifying as trans happen, more often in male-bodied people, though not a huge percentage of trans people. I think there is true gender dysphoria best treated with transition, but also body dysmorphia and other things that can be confused with dysphoria. For dysphoric youth, I think social transition and reversible changes are fine, but there should be more obstacles, vetting and research for anything permanent, more research into puberty blockers' effects on the developing brain, longterm therapy (3+ years) and treatment of underlying mental health conditions before HRT — possibly waiting until 18 — and GRS should only be performed after at least 5 years identifying and living as trans, a minimum of 3 years on HRT, and consistent therapy. I believe sometimes transitioning is the best option for people, but it should be undertaken with caution, especially for minors. I also think it's good to question, that it's okay to drop or take up labels, be unlabeled, or not be sure.
I've also seen patterns of abuse within the trans and queer community: I have an AFAB nonbinary ex who was a bit abusive (gaslighting and sexual coercion), who is popular in the queer scene and told me right before we broke up that they like manipulating people for fun, and who was sexually abused by a much older trans woman and friends as a teen. I have another ex, a trans woman, who was abused by a trans man and went on to have awful, bordering on abusive behaviors toward her nonbinary and trans partners. I believe predators are predators and we need to talk about abuse and coercion in all communities, including the trans and LGB communities, even if it happens at a lower rate than among straight white men.