Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die als trans identificeerde, rond mijn 20e ongeveer een jaar met testosteron begon en in september 2019 op mijn 21e detransitioneerde nadat ik besefte dat mijn nood voortkwam uit geïnternaliseerd vrouwenhaat en gebrek aan controle over hoe anderen me zagen, en niet uit trans zijn. Sinds mijn 8e had ik de diagnoses ASS, PTSS en BPS, ik bracht mijn tienerjaren door ondergedompeld in trans-gemeenschappen op Tumblr, en begon op T een afscheidsbrief te schrijven voordat ik r/detrans vond en besefte dat detransitie een optie was. Sinds ik met T stopte verbeterde mijn mentale gezondheid bijna meteen, ik identificeer me nu volledig als vrouw met zij/haar, en ik laat mijn haar laseren en doe stemwerk terwijl ik operaties vermijd. Ik blijf trans mensen steunen, maar geloof dat veel minder mensen gemedicaliseerd zouden moeten worden, en ik heb me actief ingezet om te voorkomen dat r/detrans wordt gesloten. Ik heb spijt van hoe ik mijn lichaam behandelde en van de verloren tijd, maar ik ben hoopvol en gericht op mijn levensdoelen zoals paardrijden en reizen.
Volledig verhaal
I first started questioning my gender at around 15, and by 16 I was spending most of my teenage years online on Tumblr rather than in real life. I had followers and 'friends' there who told me my discomfort with being a girl meant I was probably trans. Nothing alternative was ever suggested to me, and I didn't look for any. I was an impressionable, asocial, overweight, insecure teenage girl with ASD and PTSD diagnoses, and my Tumblr community convinced me that my self-image and self-hate were due to gender dysphoria specifically, and that hormones and surgery would fix everything.
I came out and socially transitioned from female to male. At first being trans felt better — when people started using my preferred name and pronouns I loved it, which only re-affirmed that I must be trans. I started testosterone about 1.5 years before September 2019 (so around early 2018), at age 20. There were many arguments with my parents and many appointments before I was allowed to start. The hormones didn't make me feel better. They made me feel like an incomplete person; having a mix of both sex characteristics made me feel like a total freak, and I hated the hairiness. The only time I was pleased with the changes was when I got recognised as a man in public, because that made me feel safe. I felt wrong, like an empty shell, an imposter amongst family and friends. Identifying as trans and being on HRT turned me into a social recluse, riddled with worse anxiety than ever, gave me no hope for the future because I could never afford the surgeries I thought I needed, made me feel like I'd never have a relationship, made me angrier at the world, and made me miserable. I constantly felt like my body was a cage and that I was living a facade whenever someone referred to me as male.
After about a year on T, over roughly three months before September 2019 I began questioning more seriously. It started with 'I actually really don't want to be trans and I'm not going to ever turn into a biological male' and escalated from there. I challenged myself as to why I hated the idea of being female so much and concluded it was not because I was trans. Around the age of 21, after about a year on testosterone, I started writing a suicide note — I didn't want to be trans anymore and saw that as my only option. In a last-ditch attempt to save my own life I sought out stories from detransitioners, most of them from r/detrans. They made me realise going back was an option, that detransitioned people can live full happy lives, that I wasn't alone, and that I was nowhere near too far gone.
I stopped testosterone about a month before mid-September 2019. On 12 September 2019 I posted publicly that I was starting my detransition journey. I told my mum and my best friend that day, and both were supportive. I shaved off all my body hair, tied my hair up in a pink scrunchie, and put on a beautiful red dress I'd missed wearing. I was elated — I felt like a real person for the first time in a year, and I felt pretty and feminine and loved that I felt pretty and feminine. Mental health improved near-instantly: I felt more hopeful about the future, more at peace, more excited about life. By 28 September 2019 I posted that I saw a beautiful, cute young woman in the mirror and she was me, and I was proud to be a woman.
Initially I said I identified as bigender or an nb girl and wanted she/it pronouns, but within 10 days I edited to say I was comfortable completely identifying as a woman and using she/her pronouns, no longer feeling the need for a label different from my sex just because I'm somewhat gender nonconforming. I still support trans people with all my heart and think transitioning might be right for some people, just a lot fewer people than are currently being allowed to; I accept those who think it's not right for anyone. I am not gender critical myself but I was willing to stand with all detransitioners to defend the subreddit as a safe space, and I became quite passionate about advocating against it being branded a hate subreddit.
Medically, I had my first laser hair removal session on 23 September 2019; the laser technician said that when my hormone levels returned to healthy female range there was a chance I might not need long-term maintenance on areas that weren't hairy pre-T. I also wanted voice training because my voice is still fairly androgynous and I want my old voice or close to it back, and I mentioned needing electrolysis. I decided against surgeries — I said I didn't want to 'slave away for tens of thousands of dollars for surgeries' when I could spend that money on more fulfilling things like buying a horse and travelling the world, and I thought my body would still feel too fake and foreign even with surgery. I was glad I worked this out before getting my breasts removed.
On causes: I now understand my hatred of being called by my birth name and she/her as having had no control over how people see me, mixed with internalised misogyny — I didn't want people to see me as weak or overemotional, the whole shebang of misogynistic stereotypes. I know you can't escape weakness and emotions by becoming a man; it was a pre-perception/stereotype thing that bothered me. I still missed many things about being a girl: fashion, make-up, horseback riding, being attractive to men, and feeling like my whole body matches. One reason I chose detransition was wanting to be attractive to men again and to be pretty — I had been stopped by strangers told I was gorgeous before I transitioned — though I said self-love is the priority reason. I have been mentally ill as long as I can remember: ASD, PTSD, BPD diagnosed in that order, first diagnosis at age 8, plus a substance abuse problem but no solid addiction. I also mentioned I take meds and go to therapy for a personality disorder.
Sexuality: I am bisexual, which I noted because a lot of detrans females seem to be lesbians. I've thought about why I like fictional men more than fictional women characters and concluded men are generally written better in media. I suggested to someone else that they consider identifying as a butch lesbian if they had no gender dysphoria.
Regret and current state: I feel sadness for past me and my poor body, which I treated like a garbage dump for years because I resented it; I want to apologise to it by improving my health. I want to get healthier, lose some weight, and finish getting laser, but I don't need those to be a woman. I said I definitely can't see myself regretting anything if I lead a similar life to a happy detrans person who commented. I want to buy a horse, travel the world, compete in endurance riding, and I said HRT made me a recluse but I'm excited to live life again. I also said that until I found r/detrans I thought the only option for opting out of being trans and miserable was killing myself.