Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I'm a medical student — actually, someone who's studying to become a psychiatrist — and I've been spending time in this detrans community because the discussions I've participated in have been very enlightening to me. I'm not writing from the position of someone who transitioned myself; I'm writing as someone who came here to think carefully about gender dysphoria, medicine, and how we treat people who are struggling with their bodies.
What drew me in was a thread where someone said something that really stuck with me: "it's probably more about me not liking the way my body looks than feeling like a woman." I told them that was a really helpful insight for the practical aspect of medicine, because in the workup of someone presenting with gender dysphoria, body dysmorphia or just body image concerns should be ruled out first. That's the kind of thing I want to be careful about as a future clinician.
I also commented on PCOS. In school, when we learn about PCOS, the signs and symptoms are usually described as really bothersome to the patient, so I'd never considered the possibility that some people might actually *like* them — that the masculinizing features could be welcome rather than distressing.
I read a lot of threads and replied thoughtfully. One parent wrote about hoping their son grows up to have "an expansive vision of what it means to be a man," and I loved that. It led me to articulate a question I keep circling: if gender dysphoria has to do with not feeling comfortable in one's assigned gender, why do we treat it by changing aspects of their biological sex? Sure someone who's born male has an easier time identifying as a man, but if someone who's born female wants to explore or channel behaviors that have traditionally been associated with men, I'm not sure adding testosterone or plastic surgery to that would be particularly effective. I'd even wonder if adding those things would be likely to make the person feel even less comfortable in their own skin. But I acknowledged that that kind of treatment has also been helpful for some people, so it's tricky to decide when it's warranted.
I tried to lay out the options as I understand them. For someone questioning their gender identity, one way to support them is through therapy, which challenges the person's way of thinking about their gender identity and role in society. Another is HRT to push the body into a state more associated with the other sex and gender. A third is surgery to make the body look more like what society expects the other sex and gender to look like. The goal is to reconcile the person's gender identity with how they actually are, physically and emotionally. The part I find frustrating is the notion that gender identity must correlate 100% with sex. I get that that's how it's been for millennia and how it happens to be in society right now, but part of the challenge is to shift society's mindset to be more understanding of non-traditional gender roles. HRT and surgery are targeted at the biological basis for sex and, by extension, gender identity — so we assume that altering the things that make someone biologically male or female will help them be more comfortable with the gender identity they feel they need to assume, but I'm not convinced that's actually true. I think it's more important to focus on the person's idea of their own gender identity first. I also said I hope we explore as many options as we can and then figure out *why* they're effective before jumping the gun to something as standard of care.
One commenter quoted someone saying "ok sounds like gender dysphoria" but it wasn't — or it was, but didn't mean they were trans. That made me venture an idea I was nervous about: I'm starting to think trans is not so much an identity as it is a description of one particular treatment modality for gender dysphoria. So maybe not everyone with gender dysphoria should be referred to as trans, especially since that seems to imply that they *have* to transition in order to be *correct*. I noted this would complicate the LGBT+ political side of things — are we fighting to accommodate just those who have transitioned or everyone with gender dysphoria? I edited my comment to say that I appreciate how respectful conversation has been on the sub, but I was getting more and more anxious that it would get brigaded and I'd get attacked for being "transphobic," which I was not ready to hear again. I said that word for me is just as harmful to hear as being called a f****t.
I'm gay — I referred to "us homosexuals" — and I had a conversation with a friend about how homosexuality used to be accepted as mental illness the way gender dysphoria is now. I observed that in my experience, once a homosexual accepts their homosexuality, they don't generally suffer from *all* of the same mental problems they did before, such as insecurities and internal conflict about their identity. Whereas for people with gender dysphoria, I'm not sure it's really the case yet that they can accept or come to terms with their gender dysphoria and start to improve emotionally. My friend suggested that could be partly because homosexuality is more accepted in society now, so we homosexuals who accept that about ourselves don't feel the added pressure of society to change ourselves. Whereas for people with gender dysphoria, even if they came to terms with their own gender identity, there's still the whole battle against society, which I think makes up a huge part of the continuing inner turmoil. That makes me think gender dysphoria would be considerably less emotionally taxing if society had a more "expansive" view of gender identity.
I also engaged directly with detransitioners. I asked one person what their goals were now — whether they were considering "reverting" so to speak, or accepting their body as it is now (outwardly male), or not identifying with either gender and just playing it by ear. I wished another person good luck, and thanked someone for sharing.
When the sub moved to restricted access, I wrote that while it's disheartening to see that this has to happen, I understand the need for such safe spaces. I asked whether they foresaw *ever* opening up discussion again to the general public, noting that from my experience in the sub and as someone studying to become a psychiatrist, the discussions I'd participated in had been very enlightening. I acknowledged that open general discussion isn't the point of the sub — it's a safe space for detrans folks to share their experiences — but I suspected open general discussion can also lead to more positive, progressive, and accommodating changes in detrans-relevant healthcare.