Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die als transman op testosteron leefde, eind 2021 sociaal detransitioneerde en uiteindelijk stopte met HRT. Ik transitioneerde grotendeels om te ontsnappen aan een patriarchale, streng religieuze opvoeding, geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat en de druk van mijn familie om met mannen te zijn, maar ik wist altijd dat ik nooit een ‘echte man’ kon zijn en voelde me een bedrieger, zelfs als ik voor man doorging. Feministische studie, tijd, reflectie en detrans-gemeenschappen hielpen me mezelf te accepteren als een masculiene, gendernonconforme vrouw in een relatie met een vrouw. Sinds ik met testosteron ben gestopt heb ik last van terugkerende pijnlijke menstruaties en nieuwe migraines, en ik maak me nog steeds zorgen over het verlies van mijn gezichtsbeharing. Nu steun ik anderen die hun labels in twijfel trekken en willen detransitioneren, terwijl ik zelf nog worstel met geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat en homofobie.
Volledig verhaal
I was raised in a patriarchal, Fundie/conservative household where the men were the only ones who worked, were rewarded and celebrated even when they were 'complete assholes,' while the women were bullied about their weight and how they looked and were expected to be housewives their whole life. I heard from friends in more progressive families with feminist mothers that they never felt less than for being a woman, and I think that played a big role in how I felt about being female. From a young age I was also disgusted by sexual oppression — I remember when we had to be separated into boys and girls in kindergarten, I would run and hide, and I later used that as 'proof' of being trans from an early age. I identified as male as a way to try to escape that environment along with damaging views of gender from how I was taught the Bible. Even though I was exclusively attracted to women, my family still tried to set me up with men, especially abusive and controlling ones.
I transitioned and lived as a trans man, taking testosterone. Before starting HRT I couldn't take photos or videos of myself or show my face at all; after HRT I was confident enough to do so, and a lot of my confidence came from thinking I could pass as a cis man and achieve more or less the exact same features as cis men. But I went into this knowing it was impossible — 'A 100% biological man with all the features and functions. Not a trans man. And I don't think any amount of hormones and surgeries could ever get me to a point where I would be able to see myself as a real man.' It didn't hit me how much of a difference there is between trans and cis until I went further along in my transition. The reality was I didn't succeed in passing, and that made me depressed; passing was always very important to me, and even when I did pass I felt like an imposter. I felt like an unconvincing man, fooling no one. My relationship at the time was straight-presenting, and thinking of it as a lesbian relationship made me uneasy, which I guessed was internalized homophobia. I was comfortable conforming but something felt off and disingenuous.
By September 2021 I was thinking seriously about detransitioning and found it very hard to accept myself as a gender-nonconforming woman instead of a cis man. I posted asking how to be comfortable as a butch lesbian. Around November 2021 I had lowered my T dose and detransitioned socially to those close to me. Even with a lowered dose I felt a lot more feminized than before and it freaked me out; my facial hair had gotten really light and patchy, and I knew if I went off completely it wouldn't grow at all. I had gone off for a few months in the past and my facial hair lightened to peach fuzz, and I was hoping this time it wouldn't happen. I knew I could never be male and because of that I'd rather live as a woman and not put myself in danger with HRT, but it was hard. I admired trans men who don't care about passing, but to me it was always very important.
What moved me toward detransition was time, reflection, and community. Going through the detrans subreddit and talking to people about my imposter syndrome surrounding my trans identity helped a lot. One day there was nothing worse to me than being female and now it doesn't even worry me at all. Looking into feminist literature and history helped me realize I could be as masculine as I wanted to be without needing to transition. I also watched detrans creators' videos, which helped me enormously, and I thanked one of them directly. I wished I'd never learned that transitioning was an option, because then I wouldn't have been dwelling on it and would have learned to live with it instead of being told it could be made into reality. I found TikTok especially harmful — it reinforces the gender binary and I was always jealous and insecure seeing really muscular, passing trans men on my feed, not recognizing that filters were involved. I also felt isolated because within about a year the very few androgynous/tomboy friends I had left started testosterone and got top surgery, leaving me seemingly the only one not doing those things.
I felt unwelcomed in LGBT spaces because they use the word 'queer' to describe everyone, and if you say you're uncomfortable with that word being used for yourself you're labelled a bigot; I was also uncomfortable with the pronoun thing and had experienced everyone in those spaces identifying as non-binary or trans. I hoped for a switch that would make those spaces more accommodating. I wanted to join more detrans-friendly communities and asked for recommendations beyond Twitter.
Medically, I eventually came off testosterone completely. After going off T I began experiencing a surge of migraines — while on T I never got them, and off them I got them every few weeks — and I asked whether this was related to hormone fluctuation. I also had always gotten really heavy, painful periods and cramps even off my period; going on T stopped this, and ever since going off I've been experiencing them again more painful than ever before, along with really bad migraines. I suspected it was cycle-related. I also worried about losing my facial hair entirely once fully off T.
Emotionally, detransition has been a process of accepting myself as a masculine, gender-nonconforming woman. I've battled internalized misogyny for years and internalized homophobia. As someone in a same-sex relationship now, I've felt the glass ceiling again — both I and my partner can't find good-paying jobs and don't want to be boxed in as secretaries. I've said I wish I'd never learned transition was an option. I've been supportive and encouraging of others considering detransition or dropping labels, telling them it's okay not to have everything figured out, that they're under no obligation to keep a label, and that they should dissociate these feelings from a specific gender identity. I've also emphasized prioritizing safety for women in violent or conservative environments, framing fear of being seen as a woman as a understandable safety reaction. I currently identify as a detransitioned woman living as a masculine/butch lesbian.