Alle verhalen

Vreemden adviseren even te pauzeren — terwijl ze haar eigen verhaal niet vertelt

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd118
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd persoon die een groot deel van 2022 in deze gemeenschap anderen heeft geadviseerd goed na te denken voordat ze onomkeerbare lichaamsmodificaties nastreven, op basis van de vele spijtverhalen die ik hier heb gezien. Ik vind dat mensen moeten doen wat ze nodig hebben om zich comfortabel te voelen, maar dat ze hun echte redenen moeten onderzoeken en de gevolgen moeten begrijpen, want de keuze is uiteindelijk helemaal van hen. Ik ben kritisch over culturele en postmoderne druk die subjectief gevoel als waarheid behandelt, en verdedig tegelijk het geloof van mensen tegen minachtende reageerders. In deze reacties heb ik mijn eigen medische ingrepen, tijdlijn of huidige identiteit niet beschreven. Ik sluit af met bemoediging voor mensen in crisis: „Zolang je hart klopt, kom je hier doorheen.”

Volledig verhaal

I have been posting in the detrans community through the summer and fall of 2022, mostly responding to other people's questions about whether they should transition or pursue body modifications. Looking back on my own path, I find it strange that I — and so many others — willingly did to ourselves what is forced on people in other cultures for the sake of conformity. I read an old headline about Iran, where gay and lesbian Iranians could not legally exist under Koranic law, so transitions were forced upon them to fit male/female coupling expectations, and it struck me that western people would do the same to themselves willingly, all while denying themselves health or happiness because they feel they have to undergo a major physical change to fit into a box. I believe there are other ways to be comfortable with yourself, and that many people refuse to open themselves up to them until it's too late. When I talk to people here who are considering irreversible procedures, I tell them they should feel compelled to do what they need to do to feel comfortable with themselves, but I also point to the many detrans stories on this sub about people who transitioned in their teens because they were uncomfortable with one part of their bodies and then suddenly at 18 or 19 changed their minds. I urge people to think very carefully before doing something irrevocable, to be cognizant of the reasons they want to do it and to remember why they're uncomfortable with their bodies. I note that body modifications can carry health risks and that this community has seen no shortage of "buyer's remorse" stories, many of which blame societal programming and the pervasiveness of different trans cultures. I also try to be honest about the limits of asking this community for advice: I pointed out to one person that if they're asking a community that has serious regrets about medical procedures affecting their sexual characteristics whether they should go ahead with theirs, it's unclear what answer they're looking for when they ask us if we'd be okay with what they're doing from a cultural standpoint. I framed it as coming back to them: are they wanting affirmation or are they looking for us to talk them out of it? I said the buck will always stop with them — if they want it, they'll go for it and deal with the consequences; if they don't, they'll deal with those consequences — and that having boobs or not doesn't have to affect their identity if they don't want it to. When one person asked "Can a ciswoman still want a double mastectomy?" I read it as looking for affirmation and told them unequivocally that they're still a woman if they don't have boobs, but that if it's not about their gender identity, then so be it, and to go for it if it's what they want. I've also engaged with people whose conflicts are rooted in faith. When someone said their faith prevented them from transitioning, I said it seemed a strange reason but that if their faith was that important to them they should follow it to its end, and suggested a more fulfilling approach would be examining why they feel that way — whether there's a scriptural reason they can't transition or a social one. I told them I wasn't trying to sway them one way or another but that their post made me feel they were having trouble reconciling different aspects of themselves, and that the more self-exploration they do the better they'll feel. When other commenters dismissed that person's faith, I pushed back hard, saying they were in a space where they didn't need more people telling them their beliefs aren't real, that they had chosen faith as their means of steadying themselves while sorting out their gender identity issues, and that inserting your own personal agenda into their turmoil is even worse — "There's more to life than being right all the time." I've commented on broader cultural and political currents too. I noted that the Green Party of Canada's interim leader is trans and was misgendered in an official meeting, with the Party President and another official resigning shortly after, saying the timing was too suspect for it to be unrelated. When someone told a poster "there's in fact nothing needed to 'suit' you being a girl: you just are," I replied, "If it were that simple, this sub probably wouldn't exist." I've also tried to articulate what I see as a post-modernist trend towards the primacy of subjective Truth and the appearance of Emotional Rationalism — the idea that whatever you're feeling is your truth and your truth is as legitimate as the Truth, where lowercase-t truth is your perception of reality and capital-T Truth is Reality, and post-modernism makes them equal. I try to offer encouragement to people in crisis, telling one person, "As long as your heart is beating, you can get through this." Throughout these exchanges I've tried to hold a balanced position: supportive of people doing what they need to do for themselves, but insistent that they examine their reasons carefully and understand that irreversible choices carry consequences they will have to live with.