Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerde, gedetransitioneerde vrouw — vrouw geboren, nooit medisch getransitioneerd, die als transman identificeerde en binders droeg voordat ik het label losliet. Ik geloof dat mijn borstdysforie en angst om vrouw te zijn voortkwamen uit trauma rond mijn borst, pesten als jongensachtig meisje en autisme. Sinds het desisteren is mijn dysforie grotendeels weg, heb ik mezelf geaccepteerd als masculiene/GNC-vrouw, en ben ik teruggegaan naar zij/haar met behoud van een mannelijke naam en presentatie. Ik heb ernstig PMS met depressieve en suïcidale gevoelens, endometriose en baarmoederfibromen, en ik ben kritisch over vroege medische transitie voor jongeren. Ik verken nu vrouwelijkheid en sta neutraal tegenover genderpresentatie, al zoek ik nog uit wat mijn seksualiteit is (queer/biseksueel, mogelijk lesbisch).
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up as a tomboy. Looking back, I was bullied a lot for it, and I internalised the message that I couldn't be anything except a man. As a kid I didn't really think about my gender at all — until somebody at an LGBT conference asked me, "What are your pronouns?" I remember being comfortable with the idea of being a woman who didn't care about pronouns at first, but that "soon morphed into being transgender instead." Through the internet I found myself in "the transgender rabbit hole," and then the dysphoria happened. I was trans for a while and pretty serious about it — I wore chest binders from my teen years into adulthood — but I never physically transitioned: no hormones, no surgery. I stopped identifying as trans and describe myself now as desisted rather than detransitioned.
Several things fed into my transition. I have trauma involving my chest that I don't want to go into detail about, and I believe my chest dysphoria came from that plus being bullied as a tomboy — a "weird double whammy." I was scared of being a woman because I was attracting the wrong attention, and scared of being a woman because I felt I was too masculine to be one. A high school friend once told me, "Do you look like a boy because you're insecure?" — an absolutely rude comment, but when I look back I tell myself, "Well, he wasn't -completely- wrong." I also had a gentle puberty with no acne or anything out of my control. I'm autistic (self-diagnosed first, then my autistic therapist detected it right away and mentioned an official test), and I have "other mental things," including dissociation. I've struggled with self-esteem, difficulty making and keeping friends, sensory overload, and stimming. I don't think my autism is the root of my gender feelings, though — I had bigger difficulties socialising.
Dysphoria was terrible for me: "It makes me hate myself and hate everybody around me (or be jealous of them)." I could barely look at men because I wished to be like them, and barely look at women because anything feminine made me vomit. When it was bad, it made me think about self-harm. Letting go of the trans label allowed me to appreciate everyone around me and accept myself, even while still dysphoric. It stopped feeling like a competition. I no longer felt at odds with my own masculine side and could dress masculine without taking it too far. I stopped needing my chest binder and the rest of being a trans male became history. The dysphoria is "mostly gone (so far)," though I'm still dysphoric sometimes and there's a lot left to unpack.
I've gone through a slow process of accepting myself as a woman while still being masculine. I still dress masculine, still use my masculine name, and I don't care much about pronouns — though recently I started using she/her again and I'm not sure about he/him anymore. I go by different pronouns and have multiple names, including a male name. I consider myself androgynous or GNC and my feelings about presentation vary. I've felt like a "fake girl" or a "failed girl," and I've struggled with equating being a real woman with dresses and pink. A part of me wants to be femme and give up all my "boy stuff," but another part thinks that feeling might not come from the right place. My dad once said, "I never taught you how to be a girl," and I'm now trying to experience femininity — something that should have been done when I was a kid. I'm still confused about what it means to "be a woman," but I'm thinking less in terms of feminine/masculine and more in terms of "what do I want to do?" I feel neutral about my gender presentation now and don't feel as pressured to perform.
I'm scared of being a woman in a practical sense: I'm GNC, I'm Black, and I still get stared at and hit on. I've had too many run-ins with men, some way too close for comfort. I'm afraid of trying makeup because I know it'll put me "on the map." I've had men ask personal questions (my number, where I live, whether I'm gay) and given them nothing; one later apologised. I put on a "bitch face" because I'm tired of being bothered. I get very bad PMS — very depressed and suicidal — but I deal with it because it passes. I also have endometriosis and uterine fibroids. I'm very skinny ("like a twig") and might have physical problems that are being investigated. I don't think I want kids.
On sexuality I'm uncertain: I've said I'm "probably a lesbian (I really don't know right now)," that I thought I was bi but "I might be gay, who knows," and more recently that I'm "bisexual or queer (Not a lesbian I don't think...)." I'm attracted to women and feminine presentation on other women. I don't have interest in anyone changing their bodies, and I feel weird in wlw spaces because I don't fit in. I once had the thought that if I were a man it would help me love more women.
I don't regret specific medical interventions because I never had any, but I do regret the time and identity: the trans label, the binding, the mental rabbit hole of overanalysing my past. I believe very few people benefit from surgery long-term and I didn't like the possibility of changing in the future. I'm critical of how heavily trans identity and transitioning are pushed on children and have heard too many stories of under-18s getting hormones and surgery. I'm uncomfortable with some trans women's behaviour in women's and lesbian groups and around menstruation — "the menstruation thing is just way too far to me." I think trans is a label and transitioning is a choice; you can be physically female and very masculine without changing your body. I'm reconnecting with spirituality — I believe in the unification of all things, which leaked into unifying my body and mind. Overall I've found acceptance and peace: I'm not at constant war with myself and my body anymore, and I'm good just the way I am — I always was.