Alle verhalen

Non-binair tot de ideologie niet meer klopte

Man · Gedetransitioneerd987
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die zich eerder als non-binair identificeerde en jaren geleden desisteerde nadat de ideologie ‘niet meer klopte’. Ik zie transitie nu als een soort gnostische sekte en kwakzalverij, en ik ben scherp kritisch over therapietaal, ‘passing’ en de medicalisering van gendernonconformistische jongeren. Sinds ik gedetransitioneerd ben, is mijn beeld van trans mensen radicaal veranderd — ‘de roze bril is af’ — en ik voel me gezonder over mijn geslacht, al voel ik nog wat resterend post-trans ongemak bij het woord ‘man’. Ik heb botte maar steunende adviezen gegeven aan anderen die twijfelen of detransitioneren, en ik geloof dat vrienden en familie stiekem wilden dat ik detransitioneerde. Ik identificeer me momenteel als gedetransitioneerde man en ben kritisch over transitie voor anderen terwijl ik probeer individuen te blijven steunen.

Volledig verhaal

I desisted years ago, and my detransition has reshaped how I see almost everything around gender. I used to identify as nonbinary myself, and in the months leading up to detransitioning I was 'tortured' by questions like 'What the hell is gender anyway? What's a man? What's a woman? How do I know I am one?' The illogic of the ideology is ultimately why I desisted — it stopped making sense, and accepting my sex felt 'as if awakening from a cult.' I am male, and I describe myself as 6' tall, 200 lbs with a beard. Even now I feel uncomfortable with the word 'man' — I'm fine with 'male', but I still have 'this almost post-trans identity that can't just erase the years of being trans.' When I desisted I didn't suddenly feel like 'one of the guys,' but I do have a healthier relationship with my sex and male identity. The root of my transition was 'a feeling of being alienated in our sex.' Since detransitioning, my perception has shifted dramatically. Trans people look totally different to me now — 'the rose-tinted glasses are off.' Well-off trans influencers who've had all the surgeries and hormones suddenly seem obviously non-passing; ContraPoints, once a feminine ideal to me, now seems 'clearly a man with a fake silly voice,' and Philosophy Tube and other trans creators similarly. Videos and interviews I once rewatched 'over and over' now seem cringe and incoherent. When my questioning started I desperately searched YouTube for trans-affirming content, and it all stopped making sense — they avoid addressing critiques meaningfully, often just saying having these thoughts groups you with 'all the bad people you don't like.' Someone messaged saying I only think this way because I'm jaded that being trans didn't work out for me, but it isn't that it didn't 'work out' — it stopped making sense. Once you stop orienting your life around 'passing' and quashing 'transphobia,' you stop seeing any of it as valid and start seeing it the way the rest of the population does. I'm critical of transition as it's currently framed. I've come to think transition was 'a snake oil among the rest, a cure-all to our woes,' promising unattainable abstractions like euphoria, affirmation, liberation, self-actualization, autonomy, equality, acceptance, feeling 'right' in ourselves — as if this is the baseline of human experience and we're simply deficient. I now sense an abundance of 'gnostic cults' in society, and I believe trans ideology is one of them; in neoliberal ideologies our 'authentic self' is our god. I think 'cis' people aren't assuming maladaptive identities and pronouns, dissociating from their sex, suppressing their hormones, or removing healthy organs to 'become their authentic selves.' I believe 'passing' is itself unhealthy and unrealistic, and that those who transition before puberty and pass better are 'almost always gay nonconforming children' for whom we 'have to provide less radical options.' I also believe detransitioning does not mean conforming to masculinity — 'be whoever feels authentic' — but that pronouns, identities, surgeries, etc. are not good for you. I've told others bluntly: 'You are a male. Everyone will and can always see you as male. 99% of the population identifies with their sex. Being trans is maladaptive and alienating.' I'm also highly critical of therapy-speak in the leftist trans milieu. I have a male nonbinary friend who is 'an upsetting reminder' of this: everyone who disagrees is a 'narcissist,' any conflict is 'abuse' and 'trauma,' differing opinions are 'violence,' logic and reason are 'modes of controlling queer people,' asking them to explain is 'demanding of emotional labor,' questioning them is 'intellectualizing,' a 'male behavior.' They mask spite with a false aesthetic of empathy, alienating loved ones and calling it 'beautiful' and 'liberating' self-love. I find it 'deeply cowardly, avoidant, and cult-like,' and it disturbs me greatly. I've observed that 'you'll find your trans and queer friends sound like they're in a cult after you detransition.' I believe our friends and family secretly wanted us to detransition the entire time, and that they'll be relieved. I've also reflected that our philosophy is 'like a lens to see the world,' and I'm shocked by how much it shapes perception. I think institutions are making a huge mistake assuming consensus on gender — even trans people are deeply divided — and that we're 'trapped in a corporate friendly version of this conversation, that censors all risk.' I try to be supportive to others in the community: I've reassured a detransitioning woman that all her photos are of a 'female' and that you can look and dress however you want — 'that's the beauty of detransitioning.' I've advised a detrans female on relationship issues around a partner's porn use, suggesting exploring lingerie or shapewear, while noting as a straight male I try to cut down on porn use in relationships because it helps me connect more deeply with my partner. I've told people not to be ashamed of their journey because 'this is what gives life meaning.'