Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerde vrouw die als kind seksueel werd aangerand door een mannelijke figuur en transitie ooit zag als manier om aan kwetsbaarheid te ontsnappen, maar die weg nu afwijst. Ik identificeer me nu als vrouw, heb een relatie met een zachtaardige, vrouwelijk getinte man en noem mezelf de klusser van het huishouden. Ik geloof dat seksueel trauma in de kindertijd een belangrijke drijfveer is van vrouwelijke transitie, in tegenstelling tot mannelijke transitie, waar volgens mij vaak fetisjisme meespeelt. Ik pleit voor een rustige middenweg en waarschuw voor zowel trans-ideologische als extreemrechtse content, en ik breng medische zorgen naar voren over de risico’s van oestrogeen: bloedpropjes, beroertes en hartproblemen.
Volledig verhaal
I've been on Reddit long enough to have run into its ban machinery before: after a moderator of my country's subreddit banned me for what I considered a non-reason, I made new accounts to keep using it and started getting site-wide bans. I eventually figured out how they identify you — hardware fingerprinting, cookies, and IP addresses — and I've advised others to ditch the official app, use the Brave browser, clear cookies, and either reboot their router for a new dynamic IP or use Proton VPN. I told someone flatly that "reddit bans are laughably easy to evade if you know what methods they're using."
On gender and sex I take a fairly firm line. In one exchange I told a poster, "You will not ever be female, no, but there's nothing to stop you from being pretty," encouraging them to dress and present however they chose. I pushed back hard on someone I thought was conflating sex and gender, telling them they were confused and should look up the definitions "before embarrassing yourself," and I insisted nobody was claiming you can escape your sex. I also argued that expecting only women to keep long hair or wear pretty clothing is "a sexist and regressive notion," and that sex and gender do not always correlate.
I am a desisted female. I was sexually assaulted by a male figure growing up, and for me femininity became bound up with vulnerability and victimhood in what I described as a male-dominated world. I was determined never to be predated on by a man again, and I thought the solution was to join their ranks — to transition — but I was wrong. I've noted that a chilling number of FTM people and desisted women report childhood sexual abuse and trauma, and I believe this is a key dividing factor between what drives women to transition versus men, which I think often stems from fetishism instead.
I'm in a relationship with a man who, by gender stereotypes, is the most feminine guy I know — gentle, sweet, peaceful, emotionally open — and I love him for it. I describe myself as the opposite in stereotype terms: I'm the DIYer in the household, I fix all the electrical problems, I'm waiting on a mitre saw to cut wood for a bay window seat, and if something breaks I fix it rather than him. I don't think any of that makes us any less man or woman.
I try to be supportive and middle-ground when I post here. I told one person who'd had surgery that they didn't look scruffy but "genuinely happy" and congratulated them. I told another that their dress was hideous — "A high neck with puffed sleeves, whoever designed that needs to go to the volcano" — and suggested A-line, midi, and skater dresses instead. When someone's sister sent them videos calling them a delusional, perverted, internally misogynistic woman who was fetishizing gay men, I said those videos were the reverse coin of the same right-wing extremism, that the sister had fallen down a "right-wing, brainrot rabbit hole," and that the person needed a calm, safe, middle ground to figure out who they are. I've also expressed concern about the increased risks of blood clots, stroke, and heart issues that come with taking estrogen.
I've been sympathetic when people are struggling: I told one poster I'd read their whole post and was terribly sorry they were experiencing it, saying they'd been put through the wringer. On a voice thread I told someone I played their video with my eyes closed so appearance wouldn't bias me and that they sounded female. I've also weighed in on body issues, telling someone their "buffalo hump" looked more like a lifestyle-created dowager's hump and asking if they'd spent years leaning over screens, and I've dismissed the idea that phytoestrogens from soya affect mammalian endocrinology as a right-wing grift. I've praised a reply arguing that suffering is normal and that modern people rush to fix suffering without following the right path to peace, calling it introspective and thoughtful.