Alle verhalen

Tumblr-uitroepcultuur en een breuk met links in 2019

Man · Gedesisteerd47
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd of gedesisteerd persoon die in 2019 in therapie mijn gedachten verkende en zeer kritische opvattingen over transactivisme kreeg, waarbij ik trans-kwesties zie als medisch/psychologisch in plaats van als linkse politieke zaken. Ik beschreef mijn eigen ervaringen met de uitroepcultuur (call-out culture) op Tumblr en sprak mijn verzet uit tegen autogynefiele mannen in vrouwenruimtes. In deze berichten beschreef ik geen medische transitie of formele detransitie. Ik gaf ondersteunend, niet-gemedicaliseerd advies aan anderen met een vrouwelijk lichaam die zich als man identificeerden. Ik blijf kritisch over wat ik „Queer-Transers” noemde en hun framing van elke afwijkende mening als transfobie.

Volledig verhaal

I came to these discussions in mid-2019, at a point when I was still working through my own thoughts in therapy. In August 2019 I told someone else to "stick with the therapy and explore your thoughts etc more," which is essentially the advice I was following myself at the time. Two days later I framed the whole question in very plain terms: "Your body your choice the way I see it." By that same week I had already moved into a much more critical position on trans activism. I described myself as a "Pre-Tumblr Lefty" and argued that Tumblr-style call-out culture had wrecked communication on the Left. I recounted my own experiences: a woman at a party wrote a Tumblr post six months later, four days after I broke up with her friend, linking me to "supporting rape culture and being a sexist and a misogynist" because she thought I had been "thinking of her as a woman, and not a fellow activist." I also described a gay male friend in his early 50s, new to activism, who was "literally chased through the city and away from an Equal Marriage activist meeting" by a trans woman who decided he was being transphobic, then banned from meetings and hounded on social media for weeks. I came to the view that "Trans people, particularly Trans women (who have the aggression of men)" who carry out these call-outs "aren't defending their existence, they are enjoying the power to hurt people as a social power from a base of having little power in the world." I stated plainly: "I now don't consider Trans Activism to be a Left cause - I see it as a non-political 'medical / psychological' issue." I said I don't support "the 'right' of gender dysphoric autogynephile men to enter women only spaces" or "autogynephiles calling women Nazis because they ask questions about transexuality." I noted that autogynephilia can coexist with right-wing politics, and that sections of the Right, such as the Libertarian Right, accept trans people. I compared gender dysphoria to other conditions: "Gender dysphoria was formerly considered a psychological disorder before Trans activists had this changed - Can you imagine if the Left championed the 'right' of Narcissists to be Narcissists?" I also drew an analogy to Body Integrity Dysphoria, noting the Left is more likely to support someone with BID than a Conservative Christian, though a Libertarian on the Right would too. I acknowledged I had "got ranting myself" on a sub that isn't political, and asked "why ARE Trans issues fought for by the Left?" I also mentioned "a few very rich persons that have gone Trans." In August 2019 I also offered advice to someone describing themselves as a man with a female body, recommending they "look for a mentor as in a (responsible) older male with a female body who you could share ideas with," and telling them "you are a part of all of humanity regardless and are loved." This suggests I was engaging with people who had a female body but identified as male, and framing that in a supportive, non-medical way. Later in 2019 I commented briefly ("Horrible") on something, and in December 2019 I commented on a medical report, saying there will always be "some margin of 'error' in medicine" but that "Queer-Transers will be triggered with this report, because anything that does not 1000% support their view is bigotry transphobia 'that literary kills transwomen.'" I did not describe any medical transition, surgeries, hormone use, or a formal detransition in these comments. My account here is of someone who was in therapy exploring their thoughts, who came to hold strongly critical views of trans activism and its political framing, and who engaged with others in the community in a supportive but non-medicalized way.