Alle verhalen

Zeven jaar dysforie verdween zonder één enkele dosis

Vrouw · GedesisteerdEerste dysforie 8 → Desistance 261,4K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedesisteerde vrouw, als vrouw geboren, die zich als trans identificeerde en ongeveer 8 jaar sociaal transitioneerde (grofweg van mijn 19e tot 26e/27e), maar nooit hormonen nam of een operatie had vanwege angst voor naalden en operaties en de wens om mijn vruchtbaarheid te behouden. Ik voelde me voor het eerst in het verkeerde lichaam op mijn 8e in 2000, leerde in 2012 op mijn 19e via YouTube over transitie en besloot op mijn 26e-27e niet te transitioneren, waarna mijn ernstige 7 jaar durende dysforie grotendeels verdween toen ik herkende dat die geworteld was in sociale normen, geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat en homofobie, en niet in mijn fysieke lichaam. Ik beschouw mezelf nu als masculiene lesbische vrouw en christen, denk volgens sommige definities soms nog „ik ben trans”, en ben blij dat ik medische transitie heb vermeden, vooral omdat ik kinderen wil en geen operaties of levenslange hormonen wil. Ik heb HOCD en geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat waar ik actief aan werk, en ik heb een ernstige enkelblessure gehad, maar mijn mentale gezondheid en levenskwaliteit zijn verbeterd sinds ik desisteerde. Ik geloof dat transitie na grondige begeleiding goed kan zijn voor een klein percentage volwassenen met ernstige dysforie die in de kindertijd begon, maar dat de meeste mensen die transitioneren dat niet zouden moeten doen, dat minderjarigen geen levenslange beslissingen moeten nemen en dat iedereen geïnformeerd moet worden over detransitiecijfers en complicaties.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and first thought I was in the wrong body around age 8, in 2000, when I was told repeatedly that girls couldn't play sports, take shop or automotive classes, drive, or do the things the boys did. I was a tomboy with a bowl cut who wanted to be called Henry and wore boys' clothing, and in the 1990s everyone just laughed it off — there was no gender-affirming care then, and when I went to counseling they just prayed for me and told me I needed to change or I would go to hell. My mom laughed when I first said it and told me that once I was an adult I could wear men's clothing, so I secretly wore boys' clothing I got from friends. I didn't even know what trans was until I was 19, in college around 2012, when I found it on YouTube — all these shy girls blossoming into handsome, popular young men, and I wanted to become that. I socially transitioned from about 19 onward: I wore men's clothing, drew on a beard when alone, and wore a packer, and I self-injured female body parts. I identified as trans for about 8 years total. I never started hormones because of a severe fear of needles and surgery — the thought of giving myself a shot every month for the rest of my life caused panic attacks — and because I didn't know at the time that testosterone could be taken in gel form. I mentioned dysphoria to a counselor in 2013 but nothing came of it and I didn't push harder. I had both physical dysphoria (hating my genitals, wanting larger muscles and abs, and having very small, tuberous A-cup breasts that meant kids at school called me a boy) and social dysphoria (hating being known as a "female athlete," wanting to be strong and a leader). I also had pretty severe genital dysphoria and at one point really pushed for genital surgery. What drove me toward transition was wanting to be good at sports, to lift heavier — after years of lifting I could only manage around 30 lbs on upper body — to be dominant and taken seriously in the workforce, and to date women without people thinking anything of it. Being trans also felt like an easy cop-out for my attraction to women and my insecurity issues. I thought I was just wired wrong and meant to be a boy. Social media had a big impact: I saw before-and-after timeline videos where sad, overweight people became fit and happy, and I only ever saw the attractive, Justin-Bieber-esque trans guys on YouTube, so I thought testosterone only lowered your voice and added a bit of toning. A few years later I found the "dark side of YouTube" with videos of horrible side effects of long-term testosterone on the female body — overweight, hairy, balding guys with complications and regrets — and that was a stark contrast. Then I read something about how you likely won't look like Justin Bieber but instead your uncle. I realized I only wanted to be a very specific type of man: athletic, good-looking, popular, a ladies' man — not a hairy, balding guy who stayed home with no friends. I decided at 26, in 2018, that I was not going to transition, and firmly at 27. A few days after my cousin's wedding in 2019 I wore a dress and the whole shebang — literally my worst nightmare, and I almost didn't go — and nothing bad happened. No one told me I looked bad, no creepy guys hit on me, I didn't feel lesser for being seen as a woman. That's when I realized transitioning was a lot of work for a small chance of a better life. Shortly after that, at 26 or 27, I realized I wanted to have a baby, which became one of the main reasons I'm glad I never transitioned. My dysphoria, which had been severe for 7 years, pretty much disappeared overnight once I realized I wasn't actually a man. I came to understand that my dysphoria was almost entirely cultural and social rather than physical: I never felt it sitting on the couch, working at my desk, or taking a bath — only in direct response to being told I couldn't do something, being compared to feminine women, or reading something. Once I realized all of my dysphoria stemmed from social norms, I stopped hating myself physically, because it wasn't fair to my body to keep being harmed because someone decided I wasn't supposed to wear basketball shorts. Gender-critical content partly helped me decide not to transition, because it taught me that the only qualification to be a woman is being an adult human female, and it didn't matter that I didn't like pink. I don't label myself a radfem or any type of feminist because I don't hate men, but some radfem content has helped with my internalized misogyny, which I still struggle with most days and actively work to overcome. I stopped identifying as a boy and started embracing being a masculine gay woman in my late 20s. I consider myself a desister rather than a detransitioner since I never medically transitioned, though I fit most definitions of trans and I still think "I'm trans" in some sense because I like men's clothing and stereotypical activities better. I just no longer think there's an issue with how my brain and body are mapped — the issue is with how society perceives masculine and feminine things. I'm a desisted woman, a Christian, and pretty much a lesbian or at least 99-to-1 bisexual. I've had HOCD (straight OCD) all the time, which makes dating hard — I'd be going out with a woman and suddenly can't stop thinking I have to be with a man — and part of the treatment is not acting on the thoughts, so I was single for years. I never had TOCD; when I identified as trans I was 100% sure of it with no doubts. I've never been autistic. I had a bad ankle injury in 2020 that forced me to shift from being a dumb jock to an artist and completely rewire my friend groups. I played hockey for 18 years plus softball at youth, high school, and adult rec levels. I'm 28 as of early 2021, so I was born around 1992-1993. I've never had sex and have been led on by 6+ relationships with people who weren't attracted to me. I've tried to date, getting only 1-2 matches per month from women versus 200+ messages from men, and I started matching with men just to get out there and stop having panic attacks on dates, but the quality was much lower. I'm now dating a great woman. My softball team told me I'm single because I'm not masculine enough — I look like the more masculine partner but have feminine mannerisms. One of the main reasons I considered transitioning was thinking I could get more dates as a trans guy, but I realized I didn't want a male body for the other 99% of my life. I've mostly dated straight women who were not into me physically, which caused real damage. I still prefer men's clothing and wear it daily, but I now wear women's clothing at work without it bothering me, and I have long hair now so I'm hardly ever mistaken as trans. I still have internalized misogyny I work on daily, and I watch shows with female leads and read literature with strong female characters to help. I'm glad I never transitioned because of fertility, health, and the fact that I don't want surgeries or lifetime hormones. I don't regret not transitioning; I'm glad I avoided the medical risks. I think transition is right for some adults with severe, childhood-onset dysphoria and no untreated mental health conditions, after thorough counseling, but that most people who transition shouldn't, that it should be a last resort, that under-18s shouldn't make lifelong decisions like that, that there should be a minimum counseling requirement before hormones, and that everyone should be advised of detransition rates and possible complications. I don't think trans people are bad and I don't consider myself a TERF, but I don't support TRAs and I think the trans narrative can be harmful. I've spoken up about desister voices needing to be heard and pushed back when I was told I'd be banned for posting as a desister rather than a detransitioner.