Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben als vrouw geboren, kreeg sinds mijn vroege kindertijd de diagnose genderdysforie, transitioneerde sociaal (kort haar, binder) maar nam nooit testosteron, deels omdat een clinicus waarschuwde dat het mijn autismepresentatie kon veranderen. Een psychedelische ervaring van ego-oplossing op LSD deed gender voor mij onbelangrijk lijken en bracht me ertoe een autismediagnose te zoeken en te krijgen, waarna ik desisteerde en me nu identificeer als non-binair/androgyn autistisch persoon die het prima vindt vrouw te zijn. Ik heb spijt van de stress van de transitie en de verloren tijd, maar sinds het desisteren ben ik veel gelukkiger. Ik heb geen blijvende medische behoeften door transitie omdat ik nooit medisch ben getransitioneerd. Ik blijf kritisch over hoe genderdysforie door geestelijke gezondheidszorg wordt behandeld en adviseer anderen niet te haasten met labels.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I have never had a solid sense of gender — I don't call myself cis, and I'd describe myself as pretty much non-binary, just fine with presenting as a female human because that is what I am. I was diagnosed with gender dysphoria and have had it since childhood, around the typical starting age of 4-6, though I no longer suffer from it.
Even as a kid I found the societal gender thing extremely unfair and irrational. Growing up, the only representation I saw of people like me was characters who were either minors (tomboys, usually with the whole 'they'll grow out of it' thing attached) or lesbians — and I am not a lesbian, so I couldn't identify with butch folk to that extent. I was bullied for not conforming: not physically, but verbally. I was called lesbian slurs (even though I'm not a lesbian), called a p*do because apparently being a tomboy makes you one — just lazy homophobia, I guess — and generally made to feel like trash for not enjoying stereotypical 'girl' things.
I socially transitioned: I cut my hair extremely short and wore a binder. I never went on testosterone. I was already becoming disillusioned with transitioning because my sense of self was still incredibly muddied, and I began to doubt that hormones or surgery would fix my dysphoria. On top of that, I'm autistic, and a clinician told me T could 'change the presentation of autism' — essentially either making my issues better or worse. I'm barely functional as it is, so I chose not to roll the dice. The clinician also said they would only offer me low dose, which seemed a bit pointless to me anyway. I have a friend on T who has been fine, but I didn't want to risk it.
The turning point for me was a psychedelic experience: one day I took LSD and smoked too much weed and ended up giving myself ego dissolution. When 'I' came back, gender just seemed like a complete meme and I no longer hated my body. I figured I'd just made associations with certain feelings, opinions and thoughts, and over time attached these to my body, resulting in the sensation of dysphoria. If you forget your human, the concept of time, the concept of a body, memories, opinions, people, places — just everything — coming back, gender seems a bit trivial. I think of it like an alien experiencing being human and how humans obsess over their gender. I think that was my problem: I was forcing myself to conform to a concept I just don't agree with. Another thing revealed to me post ego dissolution was that I needed to get an autism assessment like I'd considered for a while — mental health workers had already suspected it, and my dad was suspected too and I'm much like him. After that experience I decided to get assessed and ended up being diagnosed.
I decided I was going to accept desisting, just like I'd initially entertained transitioning. I was worried my LGBT friends would be mad, but none of them were. I felt better whilst desisting, although it was a long process because of the short hair and having to get used to not wearing a binder and presenting female again. The middle ground for me was not going back to a normal-presenting female but just being my GNC self. I've been much happier since I desisted and accepted being an androgynous and autistic person.
What helped me most was gender deconstruction and ego dissolution — you can achieve something similar with meditation, which is the safest route. I also agree about time in nature. I accept that being autistic has played a massive role in my gender identity and I don't think I could compare my experience of gender identity to that of a neurotypical person. I also thought for a while I might be a robot (or everyone else was), but that theory came to an end quite quickly.
I still don't really enjoy being called a woman (though I don't hate it either), but I'm fine with being female-sexed and pronouns don't bother me. On sexuality, I've had disappointing orgasms my whole life — like an unsatisfying sneeze, a build-up of pressure that sadly fades out — and I've only ever had one satisfying orgasm, when I was extremely drunk and high. I've largely given up hope on that front.
I don't have any advocacy or activism as such, but I do give advice online: try not to label yourself, because if you label yourself you'll most likely end up trying to fit that label consciously or subconsciously, which might not be accurate to you. GNC and NB people especially have this problem since there's stigma around not 'picking a side', so a lot of us feel pressured into a regular transition when transition might not be right for us. I also think mental health services have dropped the ball on gender dysphoria — there are so many things that can cause it, and now it's considered transphobic or 'conversion therapy' to try to treat those things first.