Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die op mijn 18e transitioneerde, een orchiectomie onderging, rond 2019 sociaal detransitioneerde terwijl ik op oestrogeen bleef, en in 2020 om gezondheidsredenen met testosteron begon. Een psychiater diagnosticeerde borderline-trekken en sekse-dysforie en opperde dat transitie een koortsachtige poging was om mijn identiteit te stabiliseren; ik heb te maken gehad met depressie, PDS en vroeger zelfbeschadiging (mezelf slaan), dat is afgenomen. Mijn gevoelens over de orchiectomie zijn gemengd maar niet echt spijtig, en ik voel me nog steeds ongemakkelijk bij aspecten van mijn lichaam, terwijl sociale detransitie mijn angst enorm heeft verminderd. Ik identificeer me nu als man, verwerp het idee dat transitie iemand tot vrouw kan maken en pleit voor ruimtes alleen voor detransitioners en tegen genderrollen.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and first struggled with gender dysphoria as a teenager; I transitioned at 18, in 2016, starting cross-sex hormones (estrogen) and later undergoing an orchiectomy a few years in. By 2019 I had socially detransitioned — going back to living as a man in my social circles — but I had no intention of stopping estrogen, which I described as making me more comfortable with my body and being "very kind" to my looks. I changed my name to a gender-neutral one with mostly masculine connotations in my native language, because my birth name carried negative emotional baggage for me.
What led me to transition, I now think, was rooted in gender roles and self-image rather than an innate identity. Growing up I wanted to be more gender non-conforming than my social environment allowed, I got grief for liking guys, and I envied the freedom the girls at school seemed to have. I came to believe I'd be better off presenting to the world as one too. I also wasn't (and still am not) entirely happy with sex-specific areas of my body, but I now believe that's something I can work through in therapy rather than treat as a strictly medical issue. I reject the idea that transition could ever have made me a woman, and I don't believe I have autogynephilic tendencies.
In June 2019, at 21, the reality of what I'd done hit me hard. I wrote that I'd made myself "a medical patient for life, even though I was in perfect health," and that I broke down in tears several times that week realizing there was no true way back. I described it as waking from a nightmare I had brought on willingly. Around that same time I was actively researching whether to return to testosterone after my orchiectomy, asking other detransitioned males about their experiences and asking which forms of exogenous testosterone (gel, patches, injections) worked, since I'm afraid of needles.
My feelings stayed contradictory. On one hand I wondered what my life would have been like if I'd let myself grow as a man, and I sometimes cried about why I thought transition and surgery were the answer; on the other, I was scared of remasculinizing. In July 2020 I laid out my reasoning in detail: my endocrinologist advised against testosterone for mental health reasons (dysphoria, a personality disorder) and cardiovascular ones, I feared losing the attractiveness others valued me for, and starting T felt like "admitting to the defeat" that both transition and detransition had been — a thought that once sent me into tears in front of my endo. I also worried about long-term health effects, though I noted my current low-dose estrogen regimen seemed fairly harmless and I was aware of osteoporosis risk without a dominant sex hormone. I was dealing with back pain, low energy, and unsatisfactory genital function, and reading other detransitioned men's accounts of restarting T made me think it would be functionally healthier. My view shifted within days or weeks, so I questioned whether I should wait until after months or years of therapy to decide.
By October 2020 I had gone on testosterone, about two months prior. I reported libido rising from the start, erections becoming more frequent and firmer within days, more energy, and an easier time building muscle. The unexpected part was an emotional whirlwind — mostly sudden intense crying spells — for the first two weeks, which then settled. I still questioned whether I wanted to stay on it indefinitely but tried to remember I went on it for "better health and future wellbeing."
On the mental health side, in January 2020 I saw a psychiatrist for the first time in my life. He was shocked I'd never had proper extensive diagnostic sessions; after an almost two-hour session he told me I display borderline traits and, although I meet criteria for sex dysphoria, transitioning may have been "a frantic attempt to get a hold of my unstable identity." I felt bad at first but came to think he was right. I was prescribed medication for depressive symptoms and expected a lot of therapy, though I said I was hopeful about recovery. I've also described social detransition as having made my life more bearable: mid-transition I was constantly anxious about how others perceived me and paranoid they were laughing at me, whereas afterward my anxiety and dissociation around other people largely lifted (except maybe one bad day a month) and I became much more productive. I still have days when I don't want to see my body or envy women, and I've thought about further body modifications, but HRT alleviates some or most of that discomfort. I also disclosed that I used to hit myself hard when overwhelmed by emotions or after confronting people, though by late 2019 I was doing it only a few times in six months, much less than before.
Medically, I was diagnosed with IBS about a year into estrogen, with recurring stomach pain not tied to specific foods; after nearly four years on estrogen it hadn't improved, and I sometimes wondered whether I'd have the problem at all if I'd never started. I have mixed feelings about the orchiectomy: I don't outright regret it, but I keep thinking about what kind of man I would have grown up to be without transitioning, and the surgery took away a natural way to find out.
Socially, I've found being read as a young guy mostly fine — I dislike being infantilized as a teenager — and I have no bad feelings about my chest. I don't conform to masculinity and don't care about gender roles; I prefer female friends "100%." After my social detransition I noticed male university classmates became comfortable making degrading jokes about women around me, which disgusted me. I'm critical of gender as a concept: I wish I'd known growing up that "gender is bullshit" and that being non-conforming without labels is fine, because that might have spared me years of confusion. I've advocated for r/detrans to remain a detransitioners-only space, pushed for rules against pushing medication as well as surgery, and supported a universal detrans-only rule. I recommended therapy and counseling highly to others in similar positions, and I advised a young person against top surgery and in favor of getting off testosterone, stressing that surgery and most T changes are permanent. I'm supportive of other detransitioned people choosing to stay on hormones — I've called that "definitely a valid choice" — while being wary of transition as framed in trans spaces, which I think sells "transition as the only option" as an easy way out of discomfort with one's sex rather than working through underlying issues.