Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd persoon die nu stellig gendercritical en religieuze opvattingen heeft, in de overtuiging dat transitie iedereen schaadt en dat geslachtsveranderende ingrepen en cross-sekse hormonen op elke leeftijd illegaal zouden moeten zijn. Ik ben drie keer van Reddit verbannen omdat ik zei dat transvrouwen geen vrouwen zijn. Ik beschrijf mijn leven als onherstelbaar verwoest: twee jaar isolatie, geen familie of vrienden, werkloosheid en vier telefoontjes naar een zelfmoordlijn het afgelopen jaar, en ik zeg dat ik nooit meer van mijn lichaam zal houden. Ik deel dit hier om anderen het lijden te besparen dat ik heb doorstaan en om vrijuit te spreken nadat ik geloofde dat de hele wereld me zou haten. Het gaat momenteel niet goed met me, maar ik vind verlichting in steun van de gemeenschap.
Volledig verhaal
I've been banned from Reddit three times now for saying that trans women are not women — even in detrans or gender-critical spaces — and I've concluded that stating it is treated like a slur on this platform. I'm not sure how this subreddit is even allowed to exist when I've seen that same sentence uttered dozens of times before.
My position is straightforward: woman has always been synonymous with female, and man with male. I'm not saying trans women lack femininity or trans men lack masculinity — only that they aren't that sex. I'm not in the camp of modern gender ideology that treats man and woman as feelings, and I find the resulting censorship pathetic. The meaning of the word hasn't changed; a small subset of people are using it in a way that suits their ideology while the world at large retains the original definition. We live in a time where minorities are policing language and the majority is penalized for not conforming, and this extends well beyond online forums.
I believe transition helps no one and harms anyone who undergoes it. I'm passionate about preventing harm because I care deeply about sparing other souls from ruining their lives the way elements of mine were ruined. I believe exclusively prescribing femininity to women and masculinity to men is the root cause of dysphoria in the first place, and that letting anyone be whoever they want while gatekeeping body modification is the solution to our gender crisis. I don't believe transgenderism is healthy for anyone, nor should it be legal to perform sex changes or offer cross-sex hormones to anyone of any age. If it were on a ballot in my state, I would ban any and all access to so-called "life-saving care" — in my eyes it's life-destroying fantastical thinking. I believe calling men women and women men perpetuates transgender ideology, which is harmful, and confuses the general public, especially children, who need objective truths taught to them.
I also hold spiritual views about sex: I believe in some sort of God and don't believe we're made the sex we are by accident. Each sex has its own sacred, unique experiences — women can gestate, men can impregnate — while at our core we're the same androgynous spirit experiencing life from two perspectives. There's no superiority, just difference. Running from the objective, immutable reality of what you are leads to tremendous suffering. There is nothing wrong with you, but there will be if you manufacture something being wrong by modifying your body unnecessarily — because you'd inevitably detransition anyway, only now truly stuck in a body that doesn't make sense.
I've been open about my own suffering. I've struggled with isolation for the past two years. I don't have any family or friends, and I was unemployed for about two years because I gave up on life. It was just me and my personal hell for quite a while. I started sharing here about a month ago. For the longest time it felt like not only was my life ruined, but that I'd never be permitted to do the only thing left for me — speak my mind — because no one would listen. I was convinced the entire world would hate me, every single last person. I know that's not logical, but I actually believed it at some point.
I've called the suicide hotline four times in the past year alone. I'm not doing well. Many of us aren't either. My life is ruined beyond repair. I will never live the life I dreamed of as a child. At best, a critical element of it — feeling at home and happy in my body — will never be in the cards for me. I'll hopefully get better at accepting what I can't change, but I'll never actually love my body ever again, and it will be part of every day of my life until I die. Everywhere I go, there I'll be — ruined. I want to spare others from this needless, ineffable suffering. What's been done can never be undone, but speaking freely here has offered me relief in knowing I'm not alone — not only in my experience but in my perspective.
I've also been in conflict with other members here. One person called my attempts to express what's on my heart "schizophrenic rants," told me to "leave us the fuck alone," and accused me of calling people freaks — which I never did and never would. Despite what people presume about me, I have more love and compassion for people I observe as just as confused about life and who they are as I once was than I can put into words. I also posted a thread mocking another member, asking how to report them to the mods, and joked that the fact they're still trans while I'm not is punishment enough — then caught myself. I've shared detailed research documenting people who lost work or were sanctioned for gender-critical views, from Maya Forstater to Sandie Peggie, because I think the pattern of compelled speech is serious.