Alle verhalen

ADHD vastgesteld, nooit getransitioneerd, voelt zich nog steeds ongemakkelijk bij het woord vrouw

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd2,9K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een vrouw met ADHD die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd, maar een leven lang worstelt met gender, door geïnternaliseerde misogynie – het kinderlijke geloof dat meisjes niet sterk konden zijn – en die nu alle genderlabels afwijst en zich noch cis, noch trans, noch non-binair noemt. Ik voel nog steeds schaamte als ik mezelf een vrouw noem en blijvend ongemak bij vrouwelijkheid, al namen mijn 'ik ben een kerel'-gedachten af toen ik me in genderneutrale herenkleding ging kleden. Ik ben politiek progressief, maar kritisch over wat ik zie als een echokamer rond medische transitie van jongeren, transvrouwen in de sport en geïnformeerde toestemming, en ik verberg die opvattingen voor de meeste vrienden en oud-klasgenoten. Ik heb geen geregistreerde geschiedenis van hormonen of operaties, geen detransitie als zodanig en geen gemelde suïcidale gedachten; mijn lijden draait om geïnternaliseerd seksisme, passingproblemen met kleding en me politiek geïsoleerd voelen.

Volledig verhaal

I have struggled with my gender for as long as I can remember. As a child I was convinced that girls and women couldn't be strong and were inferior, so I wanted to equate myself to being a boy as much as I could. I would tell my mom 'girls can't be strong.' She actively tried to combat this thinking — she made me watch Mulan a lot — but I still feel that internalized sexism and desire to escape femininity to this day. I wasn't taught an inferiority complex; there was no traumatic reason for those feelings to be there, which makes it a mystery to me. I presented as a tomboy until about age 10, and then when that 'went away' I would have to remind myself I'm a girl when I'd have thoughts pop into my head every day that I was a guy. In childhood I often opted for boys' clothes, then wore girls' clothes straight through for about 10 years, and then about 5 years before August 2022 I went back to men's clothes. I now dress mostly in men's clothes that look gender neutral, and ever since I started doing that those 'I'm a guy' thoughts decreased in frequency. I have ADHD (not autism), which I've noted is strongly linked to transness. I would strongly caution someone with ADHD about transitioning — we are impulsive by nature and take action before thinking things through, so 'informed consent' given to an ADHD person in distress is, in my view, an accident waiting to happen. My former childhood therapist commented to my mom that I was 'putting a target on my back' by not conforming to gender, criticizing both of us and essentially suggesting I was doing it to myself. I never medically transitioned — I have no record of hormones or surgery in my own account. I am grateful I grew up in the 2000s, because I say that I was one of those kids who now many people would advocate be put on puberty blockers. When people insist 'trans kids won't change their mind' or 'blockers are best practice and reversible,' I feel sick and personally attacked. I have never wanted a label. I've decided I don't identify as cis, non-binary, agender, or anything else, because those are all labels, and labels create cages. Gender itself creates cages for everyone, however they identify. In a perfect world I think we should abolish gender and just acknowledge biological sex. Yet I also cringe when I refer to myself as a woman, even though I know I physically am one, and I have intruding thoughts around my gender that I don't want to label. At least part of my dysphoria comes from internalized misogyny. When I think of femininity I think of weakness, powerlessness, and being a target, and femininity causes me embarrassment. It's also the physical weakness in comparison to men that bothers me — unfortunately nothing can be done to make that type of strength equitable. The overturning of Roe v. Wade made things worse for me. Clothes remain a challenge. I lost a lot of weight a few years ago and now most men's clothes don't fit, even XS sizes. In August 2022 I got so desperate I went to the boys' (children's) section to find something that would fit, which I felt showed my insistence on avoiding women's clothes had gone too far. When I tried on feminine clothes I saw a man wearing women's clothes, but when I tried too hard and didn't consider the women's equivalent of a men's shirt I saw a woman in men's clothes. Logically I know I should just buy whatever I want and fits; I bought a nice v-neck from the women's section that day and experienced no dysphoria. I'm very progressive on basically all social issues except what I call trans ideology around kids, trans women in sports, and 'informed consent' transitioning. I have a degree in a very politically progressive field and would be shunned by the majority of my now-former classmates if they knew my views. I have to hide these views from most of my friends and it sucks. I can't team up with the GOP or alt-right because I believe the intention of most of these politicians is to be mean rather than out of genuine concern, and I can't ethically team up with people acting out of hate versus compassion. I'm still left in the majority of my views — universal healthcare, environment, taxation equity — though I deviate on hating all cops and getting rid of all guns. I've spent a great deal of time critiquing the research: I've called out the Trans Youth Project/Princeton 5-year social transition study published in the AAP journal as biased and methodologically sloppy, noted affirmation therapy lacks sound long-term evidence, and argued that academia purposely excludes detransitioners from studies. I've also written about the sports issue in detail, arguing trans women have athletic advantage and that a separate/open competitive category is needed. I deleted my original Reddit account and made a new one because it had too many clues to my real identity. I wonder when detransitioners will come out of the woodwork on a mass scale — I believe the trans movement started taking off around 2015 and that detransition is often intended to be lifelong, not just a result of lack of support. I try to be clear that it's not okay to hate trans people; we dislike the ideology and call it out. I've advised others that if HRT is causing significant health problems they should quit, and I've recommended to one person that they continue their transition when their feelings seemed genuine after extensive therapy.