Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde, gendernonconformistische vrouw die sociaal transitioneerde (deels mogelijk gemaakt door een hormonale aandoening die me mannelijk-typische kenmerken gaf) maar nooit medisch, en later terugkeerde naar zij/haar. Ik ging mijn dysforie zien als geworteld in seksistische stereotypen, een conservatieve opvoeding met geïnternaliseerde homofobie, een slecht lichaamsbeeld en obsessief gendergedachten in plaats van een ‘verkeerd brein’. Ik identificeer me nu als butch lesbienne en pleit voor voorzichtigheid met medische transitie, waarbij ik mensen aanspoor om ‘de samenleving te ontleden, niet jezelf’. Ik heb geen operaties of hormoonbehandelingen beschreven, en ik beheer depressie en woede met medicinale cannabis. Ik blijf een GNC vrouw die ruimte probeert te maken voor anderen zoals ik.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and from my earliest memories I 'felt like a boy' — I had social dysphoria, was jealous of my brothers, hated my body, and wanted desperately to be attractive and loved while also hating the objectification and mistreatment that comes with a female body. I couldn't identify with the women in my life or in media because there were no visible women like me. I was quite butch: naturally tall, strong, and handsome, good at carpentry and boxing, and I dressed very masculine. I grew up in a conservative upbringing that gave me a lot of internalized hatred and fear toward lesbians, and I believed for a long time that I was a man who loved men (mlm). I also had a hormonal disorder that meant I was effectively 'on T' at one point, which caused me to be six feet tall with a jaw like Superman and to grow facial hair — children point at me and ask their parents what I am, and I get gendered as male about half the time. When I first 'hatched' I did not have medical access to transition, so I was forced to transition socially without medical support. It turned out that was lucky: social transition alone removed about 90% of my dysphoria, and I ultimately decided not to medically transition at all. Some years passed and I came to the conclusion that there was nothing about me that needed fixing — it was the box society put me in that made me unhappy, not the body that holds my brain, and crawling into a different box wouldn't fix that. I went back to she/her and now try to fix society instead of myself, mostly by being a big, obnoxious, unashamed, gender-nonconforming woman and digging out a space in the world for more people like me. Two things 'saved' me from a decision I would have regretted: realizing that gender is just a bunch of stereotypes (I used to feel dysphoria from being 'too masculine' to be a woman, but if women like me exist, why are those traits considered male? You don't operate a power drill with your dick), and not fearing the ugly — untangling my attractiveness from my sense of self-worth so I no longer needed to feel attractive to feel good about myself. I also came to realize I was a woman who loves women rather than a man who loves men; I was always grossed out by hetero stuff, I liked fictional boys written by women, sharp muscular bodies, masculine clothes with pretty faces, and it took me an embarrassingly long time to realize that's what a butch woman is — particularly because I am one. Realizing that butch-by-butch relationships exist and are valid was mind-blowing for me. I now think body and social dysphoria are a 'normal' part of being a woman in modern society and shouldn't be diagnostic criteria for being trans; I compare sex dysphoria to anorexia (both involve euphoria from self-harming or controlling behaviors, both are media and culturally influenced) and argue we would never treat anorexia with liposuction. I also see an OCD-like element to trans ideation, where obsessive gender thoughts can consume quality of life. I advise anyone with doubts about medical transition not to do it: 'Dissect society, not yourself,' and socially transition before medically transitioning if you transition at all. I work in retail (and previously moved to northern Colorado, where I work in a dispensary), and I've found medical cannabis has been incredible for my mental state, helping with depression and anger issues in a way no other medication or therapy did. I still dress very masculine but feel no need to pass or alter myself medically.