Alle verhalen

Niemand om mee te praten zonder transfoob genoemd te worden

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd206
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd of twijfelend persoon die in mei 2023 plaatste dat therapie vóór hormonen moet komen, dat dysforie vaak een copingmechanisme is voor trauma of psychische ziekte, en dat afwachtend toezien moet worden aangemoedigd voor jongeren die over transitie nadenken. Ik uitte frustratie dat ik niemand had om mee te praten zonder transfoob genoemd te worden, en ik raadde anderen in vergelijkbare situaties steeds kritische, zorgvuldige therapie aan. In dit transcript heb ik mijn eigen medische transitiestappen, diagnoses of operaties niet beschreven. Ik steun nog steeds dat mensen de tijd nemen terwijl ze twijfelen, en ben kritisch over wat ik genderideologie noemde die therapeuten beïnvloedt. Ik werk er nog aan om mezelf te vergeven en verder te gaan.

Volledig verhaal

I posted a long rant on r/detrans in May 2023 titled 'Mental illness and "Dysphoria"' because, as I wrote, 'I literally have no one to tell this to without being called a transphobe.' In it I argued that there is an increase in mental health problems in young people and that many are turning to transitioning as a way to help, and I was frustrated that people are 'pushed to transition without proper time.' I said I know people who have been depressed for years then come out and gotten HRT in the same year whilst also being under 18, and that 'we need to give people therapy not hormones especially when they're mentally ill.' I expressed sadness that 'a generation is gonna grow up and realise they made irreversible changes because they wanted to block out trauma,' said most children that transition later regret it, and argued we should encourage watchful waiting. I never described my own transition steps, dates, or medical history in this transcript, so I will not invent them. What I did express, repeatedly, was a belief that dysphoria is often a coping mechanism rather than a primary condition: I wrote that 'most people's Dysphoria is a coping mechanism' and that it is sad that dysphoria is now an acceptable first label by therapists when someone comes out rather than understanding other issues behind it. I also commented that 'it's completely ok to understand that this wasn't the right decision, I would certainly stop treatment,' advising someone in that position to take time and get therapy from someone critical about finding their underlying issues. On the question of gender expression, I pushed back hard on what I saw as contradictory messaging: 'OMG this is so wrong like this is erasing the entire idea of gender expression that they claim is different from gender identity but then completely erase when they want someone to be trans. Like why can't tomboys and fem guys exist in peace.' I was supportive of people who were questioning rather than committing, telling one person 'It's ok to take your time when questioning' and suggesting they make new friends who accept them as someone questioning rather than 'pushing ideology onto you.' I also suggested to someone exploring their presentation that they could 'buy some feminine clothes and makeup if you can afford, it's not making any decisions but it can be fun way to start a first step and explore,' and that they could introduce themselves as a tomboy. I was consistently pro-therapy throughout these posts, recommending it several times and noting that 'there are likely deeper issues that are causing these feelings so I'd recommend waiting till you get more of understanding of your mental health.' I also recommended finding a better therapist, ideally online or via Zoom if accessibility was limited, and expressed hope that some would be 'smart enough to be able to think critically about this without being sucked into gender ideology.' I advised forgiveness as a path forward: 'I think you need to work on forgiving yourself because that's what will help you move on, it can be very hard and you might need therapy.' On adjacent medical ethics I stated that 'Circumcision is child genital mutation and should be banned,' and that it's sad anyone has to go through it and crazy that it's still legal today. On the social side, I acknowledged that old relationships can change irreparably when you question or desist: 'sometimes it's hard but you have to accept that your relationship will never be the same,' while suggesting new friendships might be better. I also noted that 'Reddit statistics aren't necessarily the best as those communities may be drawn to those pages at different rates. it is perfectly fine to question.' I did not describe my own mental health diagnoses, surgeries, hormone use, sexuality, or regret in concrete terms in this transcript, so I cannot fill those in. What comes through is a person who is critical of fast-tracked medical transition, believes therapy should precede hormones, sees dysphoria as frequently a trauma or mental-health coping mechanism, is supportive of people taking time while questioning, and is looking for community because they feel unable to speak openly without being labeled transphobic.