Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde (voorheen trans-identificerende) jongere, als man geboren, die vanaf mijn 9e worstelde met genderidentiteit, rond mijn 12e–15e sociaal en medisch transitioneerde met HRT, naar een conversietherapeut werd gestuurd en de hormonen zelf terugdraaide. Sinds de detransitie is mijn leven enorm verbeterd – ik heb vrienden, steun van mijn familie en succes op school – maar de dysforie komt terug nu ik 18 nader. Ik heb besloten nooit meer te transitioneren, vooral om religieuze redenen als moslim, en ook omdat ik geloof dat doorgaan voor het andere geslacht en een goed leven leiden als trans persoon voor mij onmogelijk is. In mijn slechtste periode deed ik ongeveer 11 zelfmoordpogingen en isoleerde ik mezelf zwaar; recente suïcidale gedachten heb ik niet beschreven. Op dit moment identificeer ik me als gedetransitioneerd persoon die transitie voor zichzelf afwijst en kritisch is over transitie als oplossing, en ik denk ook na over geïnternaliseerde misogynie als drijfveer van dysforie.
Volledig verhaal
I have been struggling with my gender identity since I was 9 years old, and I became fully identified as trans between roughly ages 12 and 15. During that period I actually started hormone replacement therapy, but I reversed it myself. My parents sent me to a conversion therapist. Those three years were deeply traumatizing for me, and remembering everything now is painful.
From the very beginning I accepted that a good life was never waiting for me if I transitioned, and during that phase I attempted suicide about 11 times. Things got so bad that I completely isolated myself from existence, sleeping 13 hours a day, attending 8 hours of school, and only being awake for about 3 hours. Eventually I told my mom that I had a "boyfriend" at school, and my parents — who had been parents for 32 years straight until that point — for the first time put their hands on me. I consider that a turning point in my life, although my friends disagree.
Since my detransition my life has been going extremely well compared to that phase: I have friends, my family loves me, and I'm successful academically. But I still feel a sting when I see a woman who can live out her femininity freely, or a woman being treated politely, when I have to pull chairs and open doors for women.
I'm now 17, about to turn 18. All of the dysphoria I pushed down is suddenly coming back up and I don't know why. I have decided I will never transition. The main reason is that I'm a Muslim and it's forbidden; I try to look at it as an exam that God puts me through and have really turned back to religion to help me. Even if I weren't Muslim, I still wouldn't transition, because there isn't a single universe where my life can get better if I do. I'm a pretty masculine guy at 185 cm with broad shoulders and a giant nose, so there's no option of passing without millions of dollars either. Plus, I'm the only son of a nationally well-known family, so there's no option of an actually good life even in purely rational thinking. This isn't to find a way out, because there isn't one — I just have to live through it.
In later discussions I reflected that a lot of transitioners I've seen hold deeply internalized misogynistic beliefs that cause their dysphoria. I recognized that pattern in a transmasculine friend of mine with eating disorder and self-harm issues who keeps saying everything will be fixed once he transitions — I described it as watching someone live my own life, coming from two years behind. I also noted that women face more sexism than men, and that a masculine woman is far less taboo than a feminine man. I've pushed back when people generalize about all trans people, and I've expressed frustration at feeling like I don't have the right to talk about my own experience.