Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een homoseksuele man die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd maar intense druk van familie, leeftijdsgenoten en partners ervoer om mij te verwijfelijken, naast een puberteit die werd bemoeilijkt door gynaecomastie en een chronische ziekte die testosteron beïnvloedt. Nu identificeer ik me als gedesisteerd en geloof ik dat wat genderdysforie wordt genoemd vaak overgeïntellectualiseerde lichaamsdysmorfie is, en ik raad anderen actief transitie af. Ik heb te maken met aanhoudende gynaecomastie die testosterontherapie en operatie niet hebben verholpen, en ik heb geleerd te stoppen met het zoeken naar externe bevestiging, een omslag die ik rond mijn 40e maakte. Ik had een ex-man en heb geen spijt dat ik homo ben. Ik blijf actief in detransgemeenschappen, ben geschorst van Reddit voor mijn reacties en ben kritisch over transitie van jongeren, puberteitsremmers en de medicalisering van genderdysforie.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and grew up gay, knowing I was attracted to other males from around age six, though I hid it because of my religious upbringing. Growing up I was constantly reminded I was not "man" enough — people who answered the phone would say they thought I was my mother — and toward puberty I developed noticeably thicker thighs and hips that made me extremely self-conscious before middle school. I also developed gynecomastia, which resulted in endless unwanted touching and pinching of my chest by other males my age and adults, and to this day I am uncomfortable with physical contact unless I am very familiar with the person or in a sexual situation. I had a childhood chronic illness that made me weaker and reduced my physical activity; I did not learn until decades later that the illness affects testosterone production in pubescent males and that I should have received testosterone therapy at the time.
I was painfully aware during puberty that I was not developing like other males, but I never desired or wanted to be female. I never liked female clothing, makeup, shoes, girls' toys, or behavior typical of women. The only thing I envied about the female experience was their ability to freely form romances with males while I had to remain closeted. The most consistent thing about my upbringing was that other people — peers, siblings, football coaches, even my parents — kept trying to feminize me while telling me I was not man enough. That continued into adulthood when I started dating: men I met, whether openly gay, closeted, or claiming to be straight, would push me to wear wigs, women's clothes, or lingerie. I gave in once for a guy and it made me feel emotionally and physically ill. The more I tried to appear masculine — building muscle, growing facial hair (I struggle beyond an uneven goatee) — the more it encouraged that behavior. I've made it a personal policy to stop talking to any man the second he tries to get me to cross dress.
I never medically transitioned. My understanding of what leads people there comes from my own experiences of external pressure and ridicule for not meeting the standards of my birth sex, plus a puberty where my physical traits did not develop like my peers'. I believe that combination can very easily push someone into believing they are not the sex they were born as and that transition is the only answer. I strongly believe what is often called gender dysphoria is body dysmorphia that has been over-intellectualized, especially after my own experiences.
I have not undergone hormones or surgery, but I do deal with ongoing gynecomastia: I've tried working out, testosterone therapy, and dieting, and none of it reduced it. My advice to others in that position is simply to own it — past partners have found it attractive and appreciated intimacy without it being fetishy.
On relationships, I spent years dealing with men who fetishized feminizing me, and I gave in once in a way that left me feeling ill. I eventually learned, at age 40, to stop seeking external validation and approval from others, and applying that resulted in a much freer, happier existence. I have an ex-husband: at one point I got really high and saw what he would have looked like if he transitioned into a woman, and realized I would still love him regardless — sex would be difficult and might involve compromises, but I still loved the person he was. I don't regret being homosexual.
My life now is full: I work, play video games, spend time with my dogs, do home improvement, cook and bake, lift weights, hang out with friends, and enjoy a healthy sex life. I've been active in detrans and related online communities, commenting frequently through 2024 and into 2025. I received a three-day Reddit suspension for "harassment" after a lurker from an MTF sub insulted me, blocked me, and reported me, and I've had comments removed by automod after discussing detransition. I'm critical of transition as currently practiced — I call cosmetic procedures being called "life-saving" manipulative and coercive language, and I view treating gender dysphoria with cosmetic surgery as medical malpractice by a profit-driven industry. I'm especially concerned about minors transitioning, about puberty blockers whose long-term effects are still unknown, and about parents overcorrecting after the gay rights movement into unquestioning acceptance. I advise people questioning transition to stop consuming porn and trans content, disconnect from social media, get therapy (preferably not with an affirming gender specialist), and to accept themselves as the sex they were born. I also believe pornography, anime with forced-feminization themes, and Covid isolation have all contributed to what we see now. I came out as gay and have lived as an openly gay man; I identify as a desisted gay man who never medically transitioned.