Alle verhalen

Nooit getransitioneerd — maar leest r/detrans als waarschuwing

Man · Gedesisteerd98
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een 21-jarige cisgender heteroseksuele conservatieve christelijke man die nooit genderdysforie heeft gehad en niet is getransitioneerd of gedetransitioneerd; ik post op r/detrans als buitenstaander die het probeert te begrijpen. Ik groeide gevoelig op met een gewelddadige stiefvader, werd gepest, identificeerde me meer met mijn moeder, en heb gezegd dat ik met een andere opvoeding misschien een transidentiteit had omarmd. Ik moedig mensen die transitie overwegen aan hun lichaam niet blijvend te veranderen en zie de verhalen van detransitioners als een rem op progressieve overmaat. Ik heb geen spijt van transitie omdat ik nooit ben getransitioneerd, en ik identificeer me nu als cisgender man.

Volledig verhaal

I am a 21-year-old cisgender straight white conservative Christian guy, and I've never had gender dysphoria. I've been reading and posting in r/detrans mostly to understand what people there are going through, since I'm 'on the outside looking in.' Growing up I was always more sensitive, and I had an abusive stepdad. I got bullied a lot, but sometime in 7th or 8th grade I 'just said fuck it and started doing my own thing.' I always identified more with my mom, and I've said that if I hadn't had the religious upbringing I had, or if I'd been born five years later, maybe I would embrace a trans identity — but instead of trying to be a boy or a girl, all I really wanted growing up was to be myself, and 'God damn them if they think boys cant cry or have long hair or write poetry.' I moved to the DC area as a kid and have been exposed to trans culture since then. I've thought about my own childhood experiences with some relief. I noted that some guys go through things like wishing they were a girl or wondering if they're gay, and I'm 'pretty sure it's part of puberty.' I also reflected on cross-dressing: 'every 7 year old, once they discover girls clothes, wants to try them on. Its just curiousity and some weird kind of autophilia. Its not that I want to actually be a girl. It's that having access to my own girl parts would be super sexy. It's a fantasy. It's as fantastical as age play or furry play.' I've said I'm glad I'm not 8 anymore, because 'I'd probably be wrongly interned as a trans patient.' I've asked the community a lot of questions: whether the detrans community skews toward people who started transition or T in their mid-to-late teens, why fewer trans women seem to have this problem, whether trans women regret their decisions, why detrans people don't just switch hormone treatments, and what 'autourophilics' means. I've encouraged people considering transition not to do it, telling one person they don't have to be a man to be strong, that transitioning won't make them stronger, that there's a glass ceiling for women but 'fuck'em. Girls can do anything boys can do,' and that if they transitioned they'd be giving up a special strength women have 'without getting a lot of the real benefits of being a man.' I told another poster that 'Waking up to the idea that you never will be a real woman must've been earth-quaking for you, but it's a truth you have to encounter and face and hopefully overcome.' I'm politically conservative and have argued that the right has largely accepted that LGBT people exist, distinguishing neocons, classic liberals and young people from boomers, and I've described myself as understanding far-right nationalism as a natural response to post-modernism while clarifying I'm not a nationalist. I've suggested religion, Buddhism, meditation or 'some kind of wellness spirituality' as a 'meta-story to help you process your past,' called hate groups and insider clubs 'ungodly cliques,' and praised r/detrans and r/gendercritical as 'great places to start.' I've said detransitioners' stories seem like 'the final front against some wild progressive takeover.' I've also commented on relationship dynamics from a Christian perspective, arguing that a man who loves you will serve and honor you, and that biblical authority in marriage is not the same as value. I've been critical of Mermaids and told someone 'You're cutter as a girl' and 'You look like my future girlfriend,' and encouraged someone to work out more, describing a friend who lost 20 pounds at the gym.