Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die in november 2024 stopte met HRT na 16-18 maanden, nadat ik maar bij één persoon was uitgekomen en verder als man leefde. Ik besloot te detransitioneren omdat ik concludeerde dat ik nooit zou doorgaan voor vrouw, dat doorgaan een belediging was voor de mensen om me heen en dat ik moest accepteren dat ik een man ben. Ik ben ernstig depressief en actief suïcidaal geweest: ik beschreef een poging op de dag dat ik met HRT stopte, waarbij ik niet op de treinsporen kon stappen, en ik zei dat ik mezelf waarschijnlijk van het leven zou beroven zodra ik stopte. Twee jaar therapie deed niets voor me, en ik was van plan mijn haar af te knippen en alle transruimtes achter te laten. Ik maak me nog zorgen over blijvende lichamelijke effecten van HRT en behandelde detransitie ten tijde van schrijven als een manier om de pijn te verminderen, niet als iets dat mijn leven al had verbeterd.
Volledig verhaal
I'm a man who spent about 16 to 18 months on hormone replacement therapy before I finally admitted to myself that it wasn't going to give me what I wanted. I never properly came out — I only ever told one person, and after that I just kept living as a man in everyday life, so by my own admission I couldn't even really be called trans. That isolation mattered: nobody around me knew what I was doing, and I carried it entirely alone.
For a long time I told myself HRT was helping my mental health a little, but I'd reached the conclusion that continuing to try to be more like a woman was an insult to everyone around me, especially to real women. I described myself as a "sick freak" and said the thought of stopping HRT repelled me even though I knew stopping was the right thing to do. In September 2024 I posted here asking for help stopping, saying I was tired and that I'd "probably kill myself once I stop" — and that "that doesn't matter."
I'd been in therapy for two years by that point and said it hadn't done anything for me. I floated the idea of checking myself into a mental health clinic "until I'm free from my trans delusions and don't want to die anymore." I also decided against going back into trans spaces online, reasoning that leaving all of them behind was probably a good idea, even though engaging with them had helped me realize that detransitioning was the best thing I could do. I explicitly refused to let myself feel better at that stage, because I worried that if I felt better I might want to stay on HRT.
By November 2024 I had stopped. I wrote that I'd been considering detransition for a long time, that I'd posted here before and deleted those posts, and that I could never pass — the pictures on my profile showed how little HRT had done for me. I said I needed to accept that I'm a man, that I'd never been this depressed, and that I wanted to feel numb again like I had pre-HRT: "I wasn't alive, but that was better." The concrete milestone was that I hadn't taken my last three doses, after never having missed a single one before. I said maybe I was finally free.
Around the same time I planned to cut my hair off that night, though I said I'd probably need more encouragement to actually do it. I framed the whole decision as something I was doing for the people around me: they "don't deserve a trans person around them" and should be allowed to have a normal friend or family member. I also said that if I didn't numb myself I would probably kill myself, and that I had almost succeeded that very day — I couldn't step onto the train tracks at the last and most important moment.
On the physical side, I noted that 18 months had done nothing to my body, as was evident in every picture I ever posted, and that going back to being a normal man wouldn't be hard since I'm built exactly like one. Other people told me I passed from my photos, but I said I honestly never saw it no matter how often they said so. I also wondered whether I'd keep some permanent damage from the HRT on my body — that uncertainty was still open when I last wrote.
As for my outlook, I said that if therapy and transition were equal in not helping me, detransitioning was still the better choice overall. I couldn't yet adopt a compassionate attitude toward myself, but I said I'd see where this new path led, that I didn't think it could get worse, and that maybe once I felt a little better I could actually help myself. I rejected one commenter's suggestion outright as "rather appalling." I was, at that point, still deeply depressed, actively suicidal, and treating detransition as damage control rather than a route to feeling better.