Alle verhalen

Van transactivist naar therapeut voor wie twijfelt

Man · Gedesisteerd314
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben man geboren, kwam uit de kast als trans, leefde jarenlang als vrouw en transactivist, en desisteerde later. Ik identificeer me nu als gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde man en voormalig transactivist, en ik werk als therapeut met cliënten die twijfelen aan hun genderidentiteit. Ik ging geloven dat ik was ‘gehersenspoeld’ door wat ik nu een sekteachtige ideologie noem, en dat mijn existentiële angst eigenlijk nooit over gender ging. Ik heb spot en laster van transactivisten ervaren, maar geen vijandigheid omdat ik detransitioneerde. Ik heb geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging beschreven.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male. I came out as trans and lived as a woman for years, and I was an advocate for trans rights at that time. At some point I desisted and began living as a man again — I now describe myself as a past trans advocate and a desister. I never gave a specific date for my coming out, social transition, or detransition in what I've written, so I can't pin those down. What changed for me was realizing that my existential anxiety had nothing to do with my gender. I had to combat self-loathing and, in my words, employ 'radical self acceptance, gratitude for the body and gender I was given and loads of self compassion.' I also came to believe I had been 'brainwashed' — that gender ideology is a trap. I now say things like 'You were never trans. Sorry,' and 'Noone is, to be honest,' and I describe the whole thing as 'a cult with a demonic and destructive ideology' and 'a psy-op perpetrated on the West by malign actors that seek our destruction.' I've urged others to study cults to see the similarities, and I've told people to stop looking at life 'through the lens of gender and gender ideology.' The language of the trans community was a big part of what I've come to see as cult-like: I noted that 'one of the most defining characteristics of a cult is the creation and use of terms and language specific to this group and its ideology,' with new terms appearing and the glossary growing daily, and I said it's 'such a relief to not be exposed to it any more.' On the hate I've received: I said the 'hate and vitriol I have experienced is only coming from one direction' — from trans activists — in the form of 'ridicule, slander, name calling and putdowns.' I said I haven't experienced any criticism or hate 'for allowing myself to become brainwashed.' I also said I feel resentments are understandable in detransitioners who 'felt conned/brainwashed/pressured by members of this group into making irreversible changes to their bodies.' I also wrote that 'it hurt me too and made me feel guilty to be male,' but that 'we are all human and both sexes have the capacity to be assholes and hurt people,' and that 'men should use their physical strength to protect and not abuse.' I believe in promoting 'unity and understanding not division.' Professionally, I am now a therapist myself, working in this space indirectly, with clients who are questioning their gender identity. I said I wish there was more I could do, but in my country I 'will be labeled and probably struck off if I even invite a client to investigate their chosen gender identity,' and I feel 'muzzled by a governing body that has fallen line and sinker for this madness.' I'm very concerned about ideological capture — 'the rush to affirm, the negation of contributing and comorbidities and the erosion of real oversight and the lack of concern around safety and future harms' — and I predicted 'a medical scandal akin to or worse than the thalidomide scandal is looming.' I've called the current approach 'insanity and institutionalised child abuse' and said 'we will look back on this with shame,' and I've described cases as reeking of 'medical malpractice/child abuse.' I'm skeptical of detransition statistics, suspecting 'rates of detransition are far higher than any available statistics are showing.' I'm critical of historical revisionism and of trans proponents citing figures like Joan of Arc, the Hijra, and fa'afine out of cultural context — I argued Joan of Arc took male dress to access military and leadership roles closed to women, and that the Hijra and fa'afine are understood in their own cultures as men impersonating women who never transitioned physiologically and don't see themselves as actual women. I've also commented on geopolitics and culture — defending Iranians as Persian rather than Arab, criticizing Saudi Arabia for pushing extremism, and calling a Blues Clues video 'fucked' and 'indoctrination' — but those aren't central to my transition story. I have not written about specific medical interventions, surgeries, hormones, fertility, mental health diagnoses, trauma, family relationships (beyond noting I'm a dad of a daughter), or sexuality. I have not described suicidal ideation or self-harm. I don't know my current age or the years of my transition milestones from what I've written.