Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die ongeveer vijf jaar als man leefde, testosteron gebruikte en topchirurgie onderging voordat ik in juli 2022 besloot te desisteren. Nu geloof ik dat ik grotendeels transitioneerde om te ontsnappen aan zelfhaat, geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat, trauma uit mijn kindertijd, sociaal isolement en lichaamsdysmorfie, en niet uit een echte behoefte mijn lichaam te veranderen. Sinds ik desisteerde heb ik een golf van acceptatie ervaren naast de terugkeer van oude lichaamsdysmorfie, en ik heb spijt van de medische stappen die ik zette, vooral omdat ik weet dat mijn dysforie steeds meer veranderingen eiste zonder eindpunt. Momenteel overweeg ik borstreconstructie, maar ik ben terughoudend om nog een operatie te ondergaan. Ik deel actief mijn ervaring om anderen te helpen te vermijden wat ik zie als mijn fouten en om me te verzetten tegen het wegzetten van detransitioners als TERF’s.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and was diagnosed with autism a few years before I started questioning my transition. For about five years I lived as a man, and by mid-2022 I was seriously questioning whether transitioning had been the right move.
Looking back, I think the real reason I transitioned was that I was trying to force myself into becoming someone I liked. I had done the same thing with cis womanhood — I had a picture in my head of who I wanted to be that looked nothing like me, because I hated myself. I still hated myself, and now I had a new picture of who I wanted to be. I wrote that I kind of hated myself either way — for being cis or for being trans — so I was confused about whether I was just backing out because I still resented myself for being trans, or whether I could still hate myself while having genuine dysphoria.
I do fit gendered stereotypes for women reasonably well in personality — I'm soft, emotional, artistic — but I resented myself for it because I hated being feminine. I had no interest in dressing femininely at all. Somehow it felt easier imagining those personality traits on a guy; on a guy those traits felt loveable. I figured I probably had some internalized misogyny to work through, and that it didn't help that I felt really isolated socially from my sex at birth because of childhood experiences. It was hard to separate what was loving myself and pursuing who I am from what was pursuing being someone else and loving them.
I'd read that a lot of autistic people, especially females, are trans because they don't feel like they fit in with their peers and seek inclusion elsewhere, and that resonated with me. I never felt like I fit in with either group, and that isolation was what first got me to try on labels. I convinced myself to go further because I never really liked my body — my hips, my ability to get pregnant, or my breasts. I have past issues with an eating disorder, and I said I wasn't going to miss my breasts even if I did desist because they were sensory nightmares. I also noted that the developmental delay and sensory issues explained a lot for me personally. I was skeptical of the concept of "autigender," saying it implies the autistic experience of gender is inherently different from an allistic one, and that I'd only seen it used by people who appeared to roleplay autism.
On July 8, 2022, I decided to desist. My partner was super understanding, but them referring to me in feminine ways was already weird and anxiety-inducing after five years of being a man.
Almost immediately, my old body dysmorphia came back. I had been excited at first, feeling free, but then got hit with a wave of it while trying to decide what I actually wanted to wear now that I wasn't forcing myself to be as unfeminine as possible. I realized this dysmorphia was one reason I'd thought I wasn't satisfied being a woman. I wanted to dress femininely but my head was swarming with how ugly and fat I was, how horrible I'd look in any clothes I wanted to wear, and that I didn't even look like a girl — I never really looked like a girl. These were old feelings I'd buried by being trans, where I could be scruffy and masculine in a way I thought suited my "ugliness" better. I wasn't sure whether I wanted to present femininely because of gender roles or because I'd been suppressing it; there was comfort in more butch appearances because they meant I didn't have to live up to anyone's standards.
The idea of being a woman again was upsetting to me at first, but I couldn't be trans anymore — it was exhausting. Dysphoria kept eating at my body: first hormones and binding, then top surgery, then it wanted a hysterectomy and bottom surgery, and I felt like it would never stop, that I'd never be enough of a man. I could see the path and it was going to eat my entire life, so I had to stop. Getting used to being a woman again brought up some traumas, but I found a community of women to relate to and who accept me, and I felt a lot better. I regretted going that far with it all, especially knowing the place of dislike it came from — my body didn't need to change, it just needed love. I regretted doing that to become comfortable with my gender nonconformity.
I also learned that transitioning had made my body image worse, because indulging the idea that my body was wrong and needed changing made that feeling grow — it wanted more and more changes with no stopping point. I came to believe that the "womanhood" we try to relate to isn't womanhood at all, just societal pressure placed on women, and that womanhood is simply our lived female lives. I noted that I'd thought my brain ran better on testosterone, but part of that was premenstrual dysphoric disorder. After realizing I'd had enough with transition, I felt a sudden wave of acceptance: "i dont have a destination anymore. this is just me."
Medical details: I had been on testosterone and had top surgery (double mastectomy). About two years after top surgery, fat hadn't returned to my chest even in a male pattern; the skin was really thin and hadn't even had fat there before surgery because I'd had droopy, heavy breasts, so the leftover material was thin and stretched nearer my ribcage. In July 2022 I was asking whether breast reconstruction was worth it, saying I was reluctant to get another surgery but missed feeling like a normal woman, and that I didn't want to go through surgeries all my life. I also mentioned having had premenstrual dysphoric disorder.
Mental health: I described myself as pretty depressed in early July 2022, with a history of an eating disorder, childhood experiences that left me socially isolated from other females, and trauma related to being disconnected from womanhood. I recommended therapy for trauma to others in similar situations.
Sexuality: not stated directly in this transcript.
Attitudes: I was frustrated that detrans voices get written off as TERFs, saying "detransition happens, its not some terf conspiracy." I was eager for others to avoid the mistakes I made and openly shared my experience to help them. I rejected the idea that being masculine disqualifies someone from being a woman, and said womanhood isn't a performance or a set of behaviours.