Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde, voorheen als HSTS geïdentificeerde homoseksuele man die zich nu een vrouwelijke, androgyne man noemt — meer 'post-trans' dan detrans — en ik geloof niet in genderidentiteit of dat sekse kan worden veranderd. Ik transitioneerde snel in mijn dertig, na een jeugd met ernstig pesten, geïnternaliseerde homofobie en een vrouwelijke jeugd; ik gebruikte jarenlang met onderbrekingen hormonen en liet gezichtsbeharing verwijderen, maar had geen onderoperatie. Radicale feministen, de AGP/HSTS-theorie van Ray Blanchard, medische zorgen en het ontmoeten van gender-kritische vrouwen in het echt openden mijn ogen en brachten me ertoe te detransitioneren, vooral om politieke redenen, gezondheidszorgen en omdat ik me een leugenaar voelde. Ik ervaar nog steeds episodische dysforie en een constante heen-en-weer-trek naar het vrouw zijn, en ik ben bang voor een terugval, maar ik heb stabiliteit gevonden in een langdurige relatie met mijn vriend, in vrouwelijke maar niet-medische routines en steeds meer in mijn christelijk geloof. Ik ben kritisch over de transbeweging, maar verzet me niet tegen transitie als persoonlijke keuze van anderen, en ik heb momenteel geen suïcidale gedachten.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and I have always been short, thin and slightly curvy, with a naturally feminine build — what I later called the "HSTS body": short height, small-boned, long legs, high waist, soft chin, big eyes, small Adam's apple. I was a very feminine kid: I played with girls and dolls, wore dresses, was bad at sports, and I even had a purse that I wore in public. I dreamt of being a chic lady in high heels and felt happy doing so. My mother was not at all like this, so the fantasy came from women I saw on TV or in shopping malls. I started wearing feminine clothes very early, and I was feminine even before I was aware of what other people thought.
Childhood and adolescence were marked by humiliation: mean laughter, mocking glances, malicious comments, stares, expulsion. At home there were condemnatory remarks from a raging parent. I felt like the protagonist girl in Stephen King's Carrie, but without supernatural powers. I listened to "Self Esteem" by The Offspring and had no self esteem. I was bullied most of my adolescence and parts of my childhood, and I later described something like PTSD from it. As a teen I learned to hide my feminine side and act more masculine, but I described that as a social skill with embarrassing limits, not a change of my core personality.
I came out as gay first and was fairly popular as a young twink. But relationships felt perverted or shallow, and I was always the bottom, always taking the female role. One of my first boyfriends said, "You are like a girl," with contempt and disgust. Many men treated me as a piece of meat — a group of random gay men at a bar touched my ass without limits — while the men I actually liked rejected me. I described a pattern of self-loathing, loneliness, unrequited love for distant charming men, and later addictions and digital porn as the decadence took over.
My trans identity developed late but was a rapid onset. I met my current partner about two years before my thoughts about transition began, and about four years before my actual transition began. It was my first equal and harmonious relationship, after a series of self-destructive ones, including a really bad break-up I had not fully recovered from. I now believe I was afraid of love and escaped into the fantasy world of gender; I also had internalised homophobia and was uncomfortable being in public with him. When he made my true personality slip out, trans started to peak and snowballed into a full-blown trans identity.
I was on hormones on and off for several years and did facial hair removal with laser; I stayed a committed patient for at least two full years. I did not have bottom surgery. I was often passable and got a new kind of attention from bold, mostly straight-identified men who were chasers/GAMP — but they did not want a full transition; the ideal was a "she-male." I also got encouragement from a long-time HSTS friend, female friends and colleagues including a trans woman, and men who encouraged me towards their porn ideal. I had serious dysphoria about my masculine voice, manners and interests once identifying as trans, and I stopped writing the semi-fictional stories I had used to cope. At one point I almost went for a "sex change" surgery.
What woke me up was radical feminists and Ray Blanchard: I learned about AGP and HSTS, and realised that being a feminine gay guy is natural and that a woman is not a failed man. Medical scares also mattered — surgeries gone wrong, unresearched long-term effects of HRT, aggressive promotion of treatment, and the use of transition in Iran with homophobic motives. The clinical setting made me feel sick; I felt solving a psychological problem with a knife was madness. I met "TERFs" in real life and a close female friend talked about problems the trans movement created for her. I detransitioned for political reasons mainly, and also health concerns, and because I felt like a liar.
I am around 40 now (in May 2023 I wrote I was "around 40"). I still have small breasts from hormones which I said can pass as "moobs," and I have no facial hair after laser removal. I keep daily epilation and shaving routines, take supplements (peppermint oil, humulus lupulus, vitex agnus-castus, red clover), do feminine fitness weekly, and wear women's clothes and accessories about once a month with other fem-males. I no longer use make-up. Most of the time I look like "a butch lesbian or an aging twink," and I have been thrown out of men's bathrooms for looking like a woman. At a nude beach a woman commented loudly on seeing my penis after thinking I was a girl, which left me depressed.
I have never been diagnosed but I suspect I might be bipolar, ADHD, OCD or have some dissociative personality disorder, and I have wondered whether bipolar influenced my transition. I describe myself as being in a constant back-and-forth mode since transitioning: oscillating between homophobia and transphobia, between not feeling like a real man and not feeling like a real woman, between masculine and feminine gender euphoria, between AAP/MEF and AGP/FEF. I have written that this constant flux makes me wonder about a dissociative disorder, and I call myself "a DTHS with PTSD." I have also described depression, boredom, restlessness and hopelessness at various points.
I am bisexual and usually not attracted to masculine men. My partner is gay and we are both short, twinkish and slightly feminine; he stayed with me through the whole transition and detransition. Since detransitioning I have become less interested in the ideal "straight-like" relationship, though I still sometimes dream of it. I describe our relationship as happy, easygoing and undemanding but imperfect. I have written that on some level I have always felt neither worthy nor capable of real love, and that my trans life was an escape from my boyfriend's affection.
I regret the trans period deeply in some framings — calling it self-destructive, a lie, a "collective ego-trip" — but I also say the thing I am most happy about from my trans period is the facial hair removal, which combined with feminine workouts and skin routines gives a result that feels good enough. I have said both physically and mentally I am changed for life and can never go back to who I was. Regret is intertwined with ongoing dysphoria: I still dream of being female episodically, more often than once a year, in shorter periods, and I am afraid of a relapse. I have described the gender stuff coming back "like a curse" within minutes of feeling free.
I now identify as detrans, or "post-trans" rather than detrans, and as a feminine male / androgynous male. I do not believe in gender identity, that one can be born in the wrong body, or that one can change sex. I have become more aligned with my Christian roots, which gives me reasons to reject the trans identity, and I describe daily rituals as acts of submission and sacrifice. I am not currently suicidal and have not described self-harm or suicide attempts. I mostly feel a big freedom and inspiration knowing I can live any life I want, but I also get exhausted by stares and sometimes feel that no man will ever be interested in me again.