Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die tijd in detrans-gemeenschappen heeft doorgebracht om na te denken over mijn transitie en anderen botte adviezen te geven. Ik heb te maken met een door testosteron veranderde stem die niet is teruggekeerd, problemen met mijn lichaams- en zelfbeeld waaronder ondergewicht, en vragen over wat me tot transitie bracht, waaronder mogelijke seksuele factoren en familie-invloed. Ik heb een jongere broer of zus die ook trans is geworden, en ik ben aangemoedigd om met mijn familie te praten over mijn transgenderisme. Ik heb verschillende wegen vooruit overwogen, waaronder op HRT blijven in 'boymode' terwijl ik me als man presenteer, of stoppen met testosteron terwijl ik een beslissing neem. Ik heb in dit transcript geen specifieke operaties, formele therapie of één definitieve huidige identiteitsverklaring beschreven, al ben ik wel een detrans vrouw genoemd.
Volledig verhaal
I have spent a lot of time in detrans and transition-related communities, both reflecting on my own path and giving blunt advice to others. I have been through transition-related medical steps myself and have been off testosterone for some time, though I have not fully settled every aspect of my situation.
I have dealt with a voice that changed under testosterone and has not reverted. I have described it honestly to others: it has a high pitch with a buzzing, robotic undertone, and I have been told I sound like a stereotypical gay male. I have also been told my voice is deep enough for a female that people might assume I am male from the voice alone. I have tried raising my pitch and have had voice cracks while doing so. I have asked others to compare clips of my 'natural' testosterone-induced voice against attempts at a female voice, and I have been told the first clip sounds female while the second sounds male. I have considered treating my voice like an unfortunate mistake from the past, being honest with people around me that I am detrans and that is why my voice sounds the way it does, without making a big deal of it.
I have also dealt with body image and self-image issues. I have been underweight, at around 105lb, and I have been told I have a very skewed self-image that has led me to starve myself. I have been advised to gain weight to a healthier level, around 120lb, to achieve a fuller and more feminine figure, since visible abs and ribs read as more masculine. I have at times eaten junk food to comfort myself rather than sticking to a nutritious diet. I have also been told I have scars under my left arm, and I have been advised to talk to someone I trust about my mental health, since cutting myself or abusing testosterone will not help.
I have thought a lot about what led me to transition and what might have contributed. I have considered whether sexual factors such as autoandrophilia played a role, and I have discussed with others the idea that some FtM individuals are autohomoeroticists who fetishize male homosexuality through content like yaoi. I have also considered whether hormones themselves could affect sexual preferences, and I have referenced Ray Blanchard's concept of pseudobisexuality in relation to how identifying as the opposite sex can make previously taboo sexual behaviors feel more acceptable. I have been asked whether I transitioned out of genuine dysphoria or as a rational decision because living as a straight trans woman seemed easier than living as a feminine gay man, and this is a question I have engaged with seriously.
I have a younger sibling who also became trans, and I have been advised that this is likely not a coincidence, since young people look up to family members. I have been encouraged to sit down with my sibling and parents and talk through my transgenderism. I have also been asked whether my parents were the conformist liberal type who immediately affirmed my decision or whether they pushed back, and whether they ultimately did me a disservice by affirming rather than pushing back.
I have considered several paths forward. I have been advised to consider staying on HRT while presenting as a man in 'boymode' to see if my mental health improves before deciding whether to detransition fully. I have also been told that most of the changes from testosterone are largely irreversible, though fat redistribution will return to a female pattern if I quit, and my breasts will probably become a bit fuller. I have been told my voice and facial changes will not revert much even if I stop testosterone. I have been advised to stop abusing testosterone while continuing to present as a man until I have fully made up my mind. I have also been given three options: do my utmost to achieve passability but risk it may never succeed, accept that I may never pass as a woman and live as an unpassable trans woman, or drop the entire trans thing and go back to living as a regular or feminine man.
I have also reflected on broader questions about gender, sex-segregated spaces, and non-binary identity. I have argued that sex-segregated spaces exist for women's sake and not men's sake, since the threat posed by men to women is asymmetrical. I have also argued that trans men would likely be disqualified from women's sports since they take testosterone, a banned substance. I have questioned the difference between non-binary and a masculine woman or feminine man. I have also advised others to stop thinking about gender and passing altogether and just live life, since gender obsession got them these problems to begin with.
I have been told that most of the changes from testosterone abuse are largely irreversible and that I should learn from my mistakes, fix what can be fixed, and move on with life, since dwelling on it will only make things worse. I have also been told that I hurt nobody but myself with my transition, so there is no reason for anyone but me to be mad about it.
I have not described any specific surgeries, diagnoses, or formal therapy in this transcript. I have not described my current age, my age when I first experienced dysphoria, when I came out, when I started hormones, or when I detransitioned in explicit terms. I have not described my current identity in a single definitive statement, though I have been referred to and have referred to myself in the context of detransition and have been described as a detrans female. I have not described suicidal ideation, self-harm beyond the reference to cutting, or suicide attempts in this transcript, though I have been advised to seek mental health help and to talk to someone I trust about my mental health issues. I have not described my current quality of life, family relationships in detail, career, or support networks beyond the reference to my parents and sibling. I have not described my sexuality in explicit terms, though I have been asked whether I am attracted to men or women and have engaged with questions about autoandrophilia and autohomoeroticism. I have not described any advocacy or activism beyond my participation in these online communities.