Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben als vrouw geboren, identificeerde me van kinds af aan als jongen, leefde jarenlang als trans man en nam enkele jaren mannelijke hormonen terwijl ik was ingeschreven in een Europees onderzoek bij de UKE-transgenderkliniek in Duitsland. Toen ik mijn gendertherapeut vertelde dat ik waarschijnlijk gewoon een vrouw was en dat trans voelde als doen alsof, werd de behandeling meteen beëindigd, werd de beveiliging gebeld toen ik vroeg waarom, en nam niemand ooit contact met me op voor de vervolgmeting van het onderzoek. Ik identificeer me nu als gedetransitioneerde vrouw, zie mijn eerdere identificatie als geworteld in trauma in mijn kindertijd en disfunctie in het gezin, en zie gender als een concept waar ik helemaal niet meer in geloof. Ik blijf medisch gedetransitioneerd zonder plannen om opnieuw te transitioneren, en ik pleit actief tegen transitie, vooral voor jonge mensen, in online detrans- en gendercritische ruimtes.
Volledig verhaal
I transitioned after years of identifying as a boy from childhood onward, and I lived for a long time as a trans man. I was born female, but from early on I saw myself as a boy, and every character I made to represent myself was a boy. I was miserable every time I was referred to as a girl or a woman, and I couldn't imagine a world in which I grew up to be a woman. I told myself I was a boy and I felt like a boy, and I pursued medical transition on that basis.
I ended up in the studies of the Transgender Ambulanz am UKE (University Medical Center Hamburg), the biggest institute for "transgender healthcare" in my country. I was on hormones — artificial male sex steroids — for several years, with weekly appointments at the clinic. I was part of a Europe-wide study on transition outcomes. During that time I was able to pass: when I told my friends after years that I was born a girl, everyone was surprised, which surprised me too. I changed my name as well.
What changed everything was when I started having doubts about the concept of trans itself. After years of hormones, I told my "gender therapist" — who was and still is the head of the biggest institute for transgender healthcare in my country and who calls himself a scientist and researcher — that I was probably just a woman and that trans felt like playing pretend, and that maybe I shouldn't have been put on hormones in the first place. The "treatment" ended immediately. When I asked for an explanation for this sudden end of what was supposed to be trustworthy medical care, they called security on me. And of course they simply never contacted me for the follow-up of the study I was in. From what I've heard, I'm not the only one whose detransition got handled this way. I see that as one way to get a low regret rate for the treatment they built their whole career on.
Looking back, I believe childhood trauma and/or unhealthy family dynamics can lead to children resenting and denying their sex — that was true for me. I also think that kind of dysfunction can lead to arrested development, making it hard to individuate from your family. I was emotionally dependent on my family, and I think that kept me from questioning things for a long time. I now see my earlier feelings as escapism and magical thinking — a girl not wanting to see herself as a girl. I also think the "euphoria" I felt when people mistook me for a man could just as well be called duper's delight.
I don't identify as trans anymore. I see myself as a woman who took steroids for years and who wasted time and energy pretending to be something else. I don't have any lingering belief in gender — I feel about gender the way I feel about god as a nonbeliever, which is not at all. I don't think playing pretend is a human right, and I don't think demanding others use words about you that they know aren't true is basic respect. I've spent a lot of time on detrans and gender-critical spaces since then, arguing with people who still identify as trans, including 24-year-olds who say they are boys. I tell them what I learned: that a girl thinking she is a boy has reasons, and her actually not being a girl is not one of them; that declaring something about yourself doesn't make it true; and that sunk cost fallacy keeps a lot of trans-identifying people from reconsidering. I also raise concerns about the lack of long-term follow-up research, the conflicts of interest of clinicians whose careers depend on transition, and what I see as censorship of detransition in the literature. I have no interest in re-transitioning and I try to be honest with others about what I went through, even when it isn't welcome.