Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een desister: een vrouw die even dacht dat transitie de voortdurende verkeerde benoeming en genderverwachtingen zou verlichten, maar die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd en zich nu comfortabel als vrouw identificeert. Ik geloof dat mijn genderproblemen voortkwamen uit maatschappelijke normen, vrouwenhaat, online blootstelling aan genderideologie en het feit dat ik van kinds af aan van labels werd voorzien, en niet uit lichaamsdysforie. Ik heb de labels trans, non-binair, seksualiteit, ADHD en autisme losgelaten, en ik schrijf het aan het nuchtere perspectief van mijn ouders toe dat ze me hebben geholpen. Ik ben kritisch over de aspecten van sociale besmetting in de transbeweging en over het pathologiseren van normaal gedrag, en ik raad twijfelende jongeren aan om niet te haasten naar medische transitie. Nu voel ik me veel vrijer en zekerder in mezelf, met een mannelijk georiënteerde maar vrouwelijke presentatie zonder te overcompenseren.
Volledig verhaal
I was labeled by other people from elementary school onward — classmates told me I was gay before I'd even begun puberty or had a crush, and told me I had ADHD as if it were a fact. I was told I was trans, nonbinary, or had my gender questioned from around age 12 or 13 simply because I didn't fit the stereotypically female mold. I now identify as a desister — I never went on hormones or had surgery, but I did briefly think becoming a guy might help me escape the assumptions people projected onto me.
I first questioned my gender around 12 or 13, and I believe the roots were societal expectations and misogyny rather than body dysphoria. I felt like an unattractive woman and didn't want to have to compete with other women. I also got exposed to what being trans meant online, and I think that played a role, but ultimately I only thought I was trans because of the standards and expectations of what girls 'should' do or look like. I had a huge tomboy phase from about 10 to 15 where almost all my characters in stories were boys, and I loved superhero movies and hated princess movies as a kid — but I still had long hair and hated if somebody thought I was a boy.
I also struggled with feeling I had more masculine features, which I now realize was mostly temporary and caused by late puberty and short hair. To overcompensate I wore heavy makeup and clothing I felt too exposed in. I used to be insecure about my wavy brown hair and casual, nerdy outfits when most girls my age were blond and straight-haired and looked five to ten years older than they were. I've since realized I don't need to overcompensate, or dress fully like a boy or too feminine.
I never had issues with my gender until online exposure to gender ideology. My parents helped and still help me by being some of the only people who don't buy into the trends and offer a fresh perspective. I realized I wasn't trans, wasn't nonbinary, and didn't need to label my sexuality. Recently I've been learning to let go of the 'ADHD' label and stop questioning whether I'm autistic, because I feel these labels often just refer to personality traits. At least two friends told me I was autistic without letting me argue, and one person labeled me a 'baby' for having no interest in sex — I ended that friendship.
I've noticed a parallel between the self-diagnosis community and the trans community in pathologizing normal behavior — the moment someone doesn't fit a tiny box they're labeled 'other' (queer, neurodivergent, trans). I also draw a connection between the social contagion aspect of the trans movement and my own experience. I write and role-play as male characters (the main character in my current book is male, set in WW1, written from a male POV because it fits the story) — I did this at 13 because I didn't know I could like another girl as a girl. I don't think interests or hobbies should be psycho-analyzed as gender signals.
I never went on testosterone, but I noted that any haircut shorter than shoulder length made me pass as a boy 90% of the time. I advise others not to transition at 18 if they're still questioning, since brains don't develop until 25 or older, and I'm skeptical of medical transition for people with eating disorders because that can be an indicator of body dysmorphia driving gender issues. I'm a couple years older than 17 now — when I was 17 I thought I knew myself well but have changed a lot since. I feel the most free realizing I could do anything, even 'masculine' things, while still being me and having my body. Watching Mulan helped me feel empowered as a female. I'm now comfortable as a girl who doesn't fit into one box, and I find it amusing that this 'breaks people's brains' because their notion of girl is a tiny box.