Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I am a female who identified as trans and socially transitioned, but never underwent medical transition. I first realized I wanted to reject femininity when I was old enough to understand what society meant by 'woman' — I hated how women were portrayed as airheaded accessories to men, and I wanted to be seen as cool, smart, and sarcastic without being labeled a 'bitch.' As a kid I had loved girly things — pink, princesses, My Little Pony — and I can now see that my need to be male was really about how much I hated being perceived as female. I had pre-existing self-esteem problems and didn't look like the stereotypical women portrayed in media; I looked in the mirror and felt I didn't look female enough. Combined with social factors and internalized misogyny, my brain decided the solution was to become male instead. Once I started presenting male, the cycle flipped: where I had once hated my breasts and hips for being too small, I suddenly hated them for being too big.
I presented completely male — name, pronouns, and all — and even though I was pre-transition, I usually passed as male due to my height (5'11") and broad-shouldered build. Hearing a stranger call me 'he' made my day. I lived in a mostly-trans social circle, and that hugely shaped how I thought about gender. I never underwent medical surgery, but I was completely planning on it, and I believe now I only wanted to in order to fit into that social group. The moment I got away from those people — not speaking to them in person or online for over a week — almost all of my 'gender dysphoria' went away. I stopped hiding my chest and bought a comfortable bra rather than one manufactured to hide my breasts. Within a few months I was dressing in almost only women's clothes and feeling confident doing it. Looking back, I remember crying and almost having a breakdown because I was asked to wear a tighter shirt, and crying because my mom called me 'she.'
I also had interests considered more masculine — violent video games, traditionally 'male' television, going to the gym, cars, heavy metal — and I was estranged from most female friends growing up because I wasn't interested in guys, makeup, and so on. When I learned what a trans man was, I assumed I must be one, since I didn't fit the stereotyped roles I was raised to believe I needed to fit into. I've been socially outcast for much of my life by other women because of these interests, while men were fine with them. I'm autistic, and I believe that played at least some role in my experience; I know autism rates among people identifying as trans are much higher. I'm bisexual.
Analyzing the reasons I thought I was trans in the first place really helped me overcome shame about my old self. I'd say the thing that moved me toward desisting was simply getting space from trans social groups, social media, and gender norms generally — I realized all of my 'dysphoria' was coming from my lack of adherence to strict gender roles. It was almost embarrassing to me to be perceived as a masculine woman. I made the social de-transition fairly easily. I'm among the younger crowd on the detrans sub and grew up with the idea of transgenderism all around me, having been a club officer of my school's GSA — about 90% of members fit the profile of teens with self-esteem or home problems proclaiming themselves trans, most of whom told me they had no gender dysphoria.
I now hold a critical view of transition as commonly framed. I believe the entirety of trans ideology is based on strict gender roles — 'you're not feminine enough to be a woman? You must be a man.' I've spoken out against what I see as delusional ideas being pushed, including what I view as a redefinition of lesbianism (like the 'bisexual lesbian' movement) and the notion that masculine or androgynous women are just 'transman eggs who haven't cracked yet.' When I see others questioning their gender, I tell them to take their time, do deep introspection into why they identify as they do, and figure out internalized misogyny before questioning gender. I also reject 'masculine/feminine brain' language as rooted in stereotypes. I still notice old voice-training habits resurfacing when I'm nervous or talking to someone I respect — my voice drops deeper, which I see as a defense mechanism and an ego thing, but I don't do it around people I'm comfortable with. I don't describe myself as experiencing intense regret since I never medically transitioned, but I do feel strongly that teens are being taught that the solution to hating your body — a normal part of teenagehood — is a life-altering gender transition.