Alle verhalen

Twee jaar dwangmatig piekeren, zonder medische stappen

Man · Gedesisteerd274
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedesisteerde homoseksuele man, geboren als man. Het twijfelen aan mijn gender begon plotseling op mijn 17e en nam me twee jaar lang in beslag met dwangmatig, opdringerig gedachten controleren, maar ik heb nooit medische transitie nagestreefd en beschouw mezelf nu als volledig hersteld. Het vinden van homoseksuele mannelijke rolmodellen, beginnen met studeren en bewust stoppen met het dwangmatige piekeren losten het op; het scepticisme van mijn moeder over een transgenderdiagnose hielp achteraf ook. Ik heb nu een gezonde relatie met mijn lichaam dankzij de sportschool, al zie ik in dat ik de ene lichaamsobsessie voor de andere heb ingeruild. Ik geloof dat genderdysforie echt bestaat, maar vind dat transitie van mensen die als man en als vrouw zijn geboren fundamenteel verschillende verschijnselen zijn.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male and I've been an openly gay man for about ten years. I never thought of myself as ashamed of being effeminate, but looking back at my period of gender questioning, I think the difficulty was that I struggled to incorporate being an effeminate man into my conception of myself — it just didn't fit somehow, even though I never thought it was wrong. The feeling hit me all of a sudden at 17 years old. I was very lonely at the time. I remember I was in bed listening to the soundtrack to Hedwig and the Angry Inch (a musical about a transsexual) and it was like a switch flipped in my head. From that point I obsessed over my gender for about two years. I would spend all day trying to 'catch myself out' to see if I wanted to be a girl. One question I used to ask myself was whether I'd want to be an old man or an old lady — I would try to catch myself off guard with it so I didn't have time to lie. I would also imagine being in a music video or whatever, and sort of keep watch of my feelings and judge whether I enjoyed it more performing as a man or a woman. I cried every day about this for two years when I was that age; it was like torture. I flip-flopped for those two years before deciding not to pursue any medical support. I never medically transitioned — no hormones, no surgery — and I personally consider myself desisted. My mom said the things that other people's parents didn't: she told me she didn't think I was transgender, that I hadn't really shown signs of that as a kid, and she pointed me towards a blog post about POCD (pedophilic obsessive intrusive thoughts) and said she thought I had that rather than being transgender. She was right, of course, and I wanted to believe her but I couldn't at the time. It didn't really push me one way or the other, although I'm extremely glad in retrospect that she didn't jump head first into it like some people would. She was nice about it and tried to make me feel better, but just wasn't convinced it was the right diagnosis. Nowadays she occasionally asks me how I feel about it, but I think she's forgetting the situation ever happened at all. How I got better: I had to stop thinking about it. I reasoned, if I'm trans then there's nothing I can do about it anyway — it doesn't really matter, it just matters that I'm not thinking about gender 24 hours per day. Fortunately I also started university, which put me around people a lot more and allowed me to think about other things. It was hard to deny my obsessive thoughts like that, but since I managed it I've had no problems like this at all. Today I worry more about other stupid things (like am I sick? am I going to get arrested?) than I ever do about 'am I transgender?'. I now consider myself 100% better. The number one thing for me was finding gay men I could identify with. I didn't feel or want to be masculine at all — it felt quite alien and uncomfortable to me — but when I started spending more time around other gay guys and watching media with other gay guys in it (literally RuPaul), I felt more proud of being effeminate. Now that I have found role models and remade my self-conception, I feel 'fixed' almost. Number two was going to the gym. In retrospect I think I didn't feel comfortable being masculine because I was just bad at it — it didn't look right on me and I didn't feel good or sexy that way. I guess that's a type of body dysmorphia, I don't know. Now I'm one of those people who is borderline addicted to the gym, and I think it's clear I've swapped one weird body obsession for another. I sometimes think about taking steroids, and it occurs to me that it would be rather like me transitioning from male to male — I wonder if people like us have something that makes us psychologically disposed to radical physical/medical changes. I now think about transition for other people in differentiated terms: I believe gender dysphoria is real, pointing to men from 80+ years ago who chose drastic surgeries to live as women as evidence it can't be merely a shared delusion. But I think there are huge differences between natal males and natal females in this regard — many women transition to escape sexual trauma, and many men transition because of AGP — and the dramatic rise in FTM numbers suggests these are two separate problems. I've engaged with this community by writing long supportive replies to others who are questioning or detransitioning, sharing my own experience in detail, recommending reading (Scott Alexander's review of 'Crazy Like Us'), and thanking people who make videos introducing the subject to sceptical audiences. I frequent detransition forums now because I'm not scared of obsessing over the topic any more.