Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een 41-jarige intersekse persoon die als man is geboren, zich voor het gemak publiekelijk identificeert als homoseksuele man, genderonconform is, en niet trans en geen detransitioner. Ik heb pas onlangs mijn genderdysforie onder ogen gezien, concludeerde dat ik nooit zou doorgaan voor vrouw als ik zou transitioneren en koos ervoor mijn mannelijke lichaam voor me te laten werken. Ik ontsnapte ternauwernood aan het gedwongen worden richting transitie op kwetsbare momenten tijdens het opgroeien in de jaren 90 en draag overlevingsschuld over dat geluk, die ik probeer te verzachten door de stemmen van detransitioners te versterken. Ik ben kritisch over harde LGBTQ+-standpunten over transitie en over de medicalisering van genderdysforie, en ik maakte misbruik in mijn jeugd mee, waarvoor ik mijn ouders heb proberen te vergeven. Ik blijf een actieve supporter in deze gemeenschap en bied emotionele steun en medische informatie met voorbehouden.
Volledig verhaal
I'm 41 years old as of May 2023, and I've only just come to terms with my gender dysphoria and how significant it has been in my life. I was born male, I'm 6'1", built like a linebacker, and I describe myself as the archetypal "gay" "bear." Even if I wanted to transition — which I don't — I know the physical reality is that I could never pass; my options for presenting my gender are essentially "man" or "man in drag," so I try to take my male body and make it work as best I can for me. I've said plainly that I am not trans and not a detransitioner, though I later clarified that I am intersex and that "me, my genitals, my gender, and my hormones have had a history," and that things changed a lot over time and I hadn't told anyone when I probably should have.
I publicly identify as a gay man "for convenience," and I'm gender nonconforming. Growing up in the 90s, piecing together my sexual identity as a kid, the pressure to read gender nonconformity as being trans "was absolutely a thing" — gender identity exploration then versus now were, in my view, two completely different animals. I narrowly avoided being led down what I called "the primrose path of changing my identity" by some very well-meaning and weirdly insistent people at a couple of very vulnerable points in my life. I attribute escaping that to sheer luck and weird timing, and I carry a kind of survivor guilt about it, knowing the unspeakable pain others in this community have gone through. The only way I know to assuage that guilt is to give back — to amplify the voices of the wounded and help make them heard when it's convenient to ignore their pain for a clean public narrative. I've said it doesn't make me friends, but I quit caring about who likes me on the internet a long time ago.
I'm critical of how the LGBTQ+ movement currently handles trans issues: there's a hard-line push where anything sliding out of lockstep gets you shut down in liberal circles, and it pushes wholehearted acceptance of transition regardless of how well a person actually conforms to or appears as the gender they're presenting as. I've argued that older people (30 and up) without chronic, years-long gender dysphoria who will struggle to pass deserve honesty about what procedures do and don't do. I also hold strong opinions about the medicalization of gender dysphoria — that very strong negative feelings can just be part of the human experience without being a pathology needing a cure — though I've said that's a topic for another time. I've offered medical information to others (for instance, explaining that finasteride lowers DHT by roughly 70% and that anyone wanting to remasculinize should talk to their care providers about stopping it), while always adding disclaimers that I'm not a doctor and not their doctor.
On family: I experienced childhood abuse. My parents had terrible parental role models themselves — "crazy and drunk on one side, and none on the other" — and were doing the best they knew with what they had. Were they good parents? "Good Christ, no," but they are good people who truly love and care about me. A friend's throwaway comment — "Parents are just adults who have children" — stuck with me and helps me forgive them. I treat forgiveness as a choice and an act I recommit to, and I describe it as in many ways a selfish act: I do it for my sanity, my mental health recovery, and my healing. I've said forgiveness provided me "a tremendous amount of peace" in my own experience as a survivor of childhood abuse.
I've been an active, supportive presence in this community — offering emotional support, hugs, encouragement, and resource-finding (I offered to look up therapy and medication providers for someone in their city). I've engaged thoughtfully with topics like acceptance versus being okay with what happened, the neuroscience of emotional arousal and how BDSM can build associations between sex and trauma, and I've celebrated others' peace with their gender. My own trauma, I've noted, stays "far away" from my sex.