Alle verhalen

Van buitenaf kijken, tegen het hele idee ingaan

Man · Gedesisteerd528
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een commentator die dicht bij detransitie staat, geboren als man en nooit getransitioneerd, maar die veel tijd op detrans-forums doorbrengt om tegen transitie te betogen. Ik vertel trans-geïdentificeerde mensen consequent dat ze mannen zijn die nooit vrouwen zullen worden, dring erop aan dat ze detransitioneren of als verwijfelijke homoseksuele mannen leven, en waarschuw dat hormonen en operaties tot teleurstelling en levenslange medische afhankelijkheid leiden. Ik ben zeer kritisch op trans-bevestigende therapeuten en media, geloof dat porno en autogynefilie veel mannelijke transities aandrijven, en voorspel een grote toekomstige golf van detransitioners. Hoewel mijn toon hard is en ik mensen zeg dat ze niet doorgaan, moedig ik ook mensen die twijfelen of detransitioneren aan te stoppen met hormonen, naar artsen te gaan en contact met familie te herstellen. Ik houd vol dat sekse bij de geboorte onveranderlijk is en dat transitie geen vrouwelijk lichaam kan scheppen.

Volledig verhaal

I have spent a lot of time on detrans and related forums, and I want to be honest about where I've come from and what I now believe. I was born male, and I never transitioned myself — but I have spent years arguing with trans people online, telling them what I genuinely think is true and kind for them to hear. I am not gentle about it. When someone tells me they want to be a woman, I tell them plainly that they are still a man, that they will never be a mother, and that their best option is to live as a feminine gay man if that is what they are. I have told people to stop taking testosterone because I believe hormones will make their mental health worse and will leave them a medical patient for the rest of their life. I have told people that surgery cannot give them a female body, that a neovagina is not a vagina — it lacks the muscles, lubrication, and nerves — and that pursuing it will only leave them disappointed. I have looked at people's photos and told them they do not pass, that they look like a man, that they never passed as a woman. I know this sounds harsh, but I believe that lying to people about passing is crueler in the long run. I have said things like 'you are living in a lie' and argued that if someone were truly sure of themselves they would not feel the need to argue with me at all. I am also deeply skeptical of the medical and therapeutic establishment around transition. I tell people to find a therapist who does not 'force trans ideology,' and I have said that a trans therapist 'should tell you everything' about the bias in the field. I have called trans communities a cult and described transition-positive stories as propaganda from people deep in a psychosis. I believe we will see hundreds of thousands of detransitioners in the future, and I think many people who transition are driven by autogynephilia — I have told people directly, 'you are agp,' and urged them to stop watching porn, arguing that porn use is fueling their identification as trans. I also push back on the idea that trans women can be considered women in any sense. I have argued that only creeps, chasers, or some bisexual people will date trans women, and I have cited a statistic claiming 98% of men will not date trans women. I have said that a person with MRKH syndrome is still a woman because she was born female, to make the point that sex is determined at birth and cannot be changed. At the same time, I am not uniformly hostile. I have encouraged people who were questioning or detransitioning — telling them to stay off testosterone, to give themselves time, to see a doctor if their body is not making enough estrogen for now, and expressing happiness when people share good news about their recovery or their bodies healing. I have told people they can have long hair, be feminine, avoid body hair, not wear bras, or even reduce breast size surgically if they need to — my point is always that they do not need to change sex to be themselves. I have told people 'proud of you' and 'happy for you' when they share progress. I have also dealt with medical questions around PCOS, explaining that it is something you are born with, that it involves naturally high testosterone, that women with PCOS can still have children though it might be harder, and expressing skepticism about heavy periods in someone with high testosterone. I have encouraged someone with a daughter to find a therapist, get mentally better, and reconnect with their child. Overall, my position is that sex is immutable, that transition is a false promise sold by drug companies and ideologues, and that people — especially feminine gay men — would be far better off accepting themselves as they are. I know my tone is confrontational, and I accept that. I would rather be honest than comforting.