Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die ongeveer 10 jaar aan het transitioneren was, waaronder 5 tot 6 jaar testosteron en een bovenoperatie (top surgery), voordat ik me begin 2024 als non-binair en daarna als gnc-vrouw identificeerde. De bovenoperatie loste mijn dysforie op, en nu wou ik dat men me had verteld dat een biologische vrouw geen man kan worden, al heb ik geen spijt van de operatie zelf. Ik ben ongeveer 6 maanden van testosteron af, mijn rondingen komen terug en mijn gezichtshaar wordt dunner, en ik voel me veel gelukkiger nu ik niet meer probeer als man door te gaan. Ik behield mijn gekozen naam Sebastian (nu Seba) en mijn kaalgeschoren hoofd, en ik probeer gezien te worden als kale vrouwelijke vrouw, terwijl ik afwijzing ervaar uit lesbische ruimtes en homofobie in landelijk West Virginia. Ik blijf kritisch over medische transitie en geïnformeerde toestemming, en ik ben het nog aan het uitzoeken met mijn therapeut.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and have never had a problem with being female itself — what I disliked was being called a woman. For about 10 years I transitioned in various ways, and I was on testosterone full-time for roughly 5 to 6 years. I had top surgery, which I now say cured my dysphoria entirely: 'I think all my dysphoria was coming from having breasts and had I gotten them removed before testosterone I don't think I'd ever have gone on it. It was just easier to get than top surgery.' I also have PCOS, which I said made it impossible for me to lose weight off testosterone.
Around January 2024 I first realized I was 'actually nonbinary and not ftm' after being extremely uncomfortable passing as a cis man. I'd been off testosterone for a few months but nothing was changing; I wanted to move into a more androgynous zone so people would stop seeing me as a cis man. I started wearing makeup and dressing more feminine occasionally, but people just assumed I was gay — gay men would approach me and I'd have to explain I was nonbinary and liked women. I felt like giving up.
Within days I changed course. On February 4, 2024, I posted that I was 'Thinking of detransitioning back to a woman after 10 years,' crediting detrans women posting about being gender-nonconforming with giving me 'the courage to admit I'm also a gnc woman and not nonbinary like I previously thought.' A key moment came while on vacation: someone called me a woman for the first time in 10 years and it made me feel really good, even though they quickly corrected themselves to 'sir' after seeing my face. I came to accept all pronouns and realized someone calling me he/him doesn't make me less female, whereas before I was 'in denial and thinking because I looked like a man, I was one.'
I had technically been on and off testosterone for about 6 months, still doing occasional shots to help weight loss (I'd lost 80 pounds). By February 2024 I posted comparison photos: 'My curves are slowly coming back and my facial hair has thinned out a lot. I'm still new to detransitioning but I feel much more confident now than I did in the first photo.' I noted that passing as male on T only took a few months, while detransitioning felt like it was taking forever.
I kept my chosen name, Sebastian, because I hated my birth name Angel: 'My chosen name is Sebastian and I love it, it's the one thing about my transition that I'm absolutely in love with.' I worried about looking silly as a woman named Sebastian and eventually settled on 'Seba' as a more feminine variation. I shaved my head and enjoyed it — 'Shaving it is the one thing I enjoy about myself' — and my goal became 'to read as a bald feminine woman.' I had stretched ears with tunnels and studs, and I was learning to do my own eyebrows and makeup, staying up all night practicing until it looked 'like a cakey mess.'
I live in the mountains of West Virginia, where people often assume I'm a gay man and I've experienced 'weird homophobia.' I worried about going into salons or beauty schools for laser or brow work. Laser hair removal was too expensive for me. I also struggled with clothing: after top surgery, feminine clothes made me look 'like a man playing dress up or an ugly trans woman,' and I worried about looking 'like a weird trans woman' in women's clothing. I posted photos asking if I looked better as a man or now off T, and got downvoted over a sweater I'd worn, which made me feel 'a little shitty' and I asked whether I should delete the post.
On February 14, 2024, I saw a post on asktransgender calling a trans man 'biologically male' because he'd medically transitioned, and wrote: 'Is this really what the trans community has come to? Telling biological females that they're male? I'm glad I'm getting out tbh. I think that was the push that I needed.' On February 15, 2024, I reported being blocked from joining lesbian Facebook groups because I look male, despite my profile clearly stating I'm detrans: 'I get it, admins have to keep the spaces safe but I'm feeling really discouraged by it. I like being a gnc female but times like this make it really hard.'
I have a therapist who helps me, though I remained confused about my identity. I do not regret top surgery — 'I don't wish anyone would have stopped me transitioning but because I wouldn't have gotten top surgery otherwise' — but I do wish more people had told me 'it's impossible for a biological female to be a man,' saying I would still have transitioned but 'not for as long and openly as a gnc woman instead of a man.' I've become much happier since stopping: 'No one tells you how absolutely exhausting it is to try and pass as a man all the time.' I hold critical views of medical transition, particularly informed consent, saying those going through it quickly are 'much more likely to regret medical transition because they were able to move so fast through each step without giving themselves time to think about what it means for their future.' I also said trans people 'base their entire lives around stereotypes created for men and women.' I was still in trans spaces at that point and hadn't fully left them. I identified as a gnc woman/detrans female, though I also said I was 'more interested in being an androgynous person' than fully going back to looking female.