Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik transitioneerde sociaal op mijn 15e, begon op mijn 16e met testosteron en had op mijn 17e een bovenoperatie; ik leefde bijna 15 jaar als man voordat ik in 2022 besefte: 'ik ben geen man'. Gezondheidsproblemen, zoals gevaarlijk hoge bloeddruk op mijn 20e, terugtrekkende haarlijn op mijn 22e, slaapapneu waarvoor ik op mijn 24e CPAP nodig had, frequente blaasontstekingen door vaginale atrofie, chronische hoofdpijn en emotionele afvlakking, zetten me aan het twijfelen aan transitie. Ik stopte met testosteron na 12 jaar HRT (rond eind 2023), viel er meerdere keren op terug door verpletterende depressie en de verslavende aantrekkingskracht van het middel, maar stopte uiteindelijk definitief; begin 2024 was ik bijna 5 maanden van T af en zag ik vrouwelijke vetverdeling en de terugkeer van menstruatie. Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde, als lesbisch identificerende vrouw die toewerkt naar lichaamsneutraliteit, bijna 3 jaar nuchter van alcohol, en nu heb ik kritische, gendercritisch-feministische opvattingen over het reguliere trans-activisme. Ik heb er spijt van dat ik meer dan tien jaar in strikte genderrollen geloofde en ik wou dat ik vrouw zijn een kans had gegeven, al vrees ik in lesbische ruimtes als cis man of als MTF-persoon gezien te worden.
Volledig verhaal
I began socially transitioning at age 15 (around 2010) and started testosterone at age 16, having top surgery at age 17. I lived as male for nearly 15 years, almost half my life. I was told about potential effects of HRT—hair loss, changes in smell, body and facial hair—and warned that in middle age I could face health problems typical of biological males like high cholesterol and heart problems, but at 16 I wasn't thinking that far ahead.
Problems arose much sooner than expected. At age 20 I developed dangerously high blood pressure and was prescribed medication. At 22 my hairline was already receding and thinning. Changes to my throat and larynx from testosterone caused sleep apnea, and I was put on a nighttime CPAP machine at age 24. I started getting frequent UTIs; researching it, I found the vaginal atrophy caused by testosterone was weakening my urethra, and that female-to-male individuals are prone to UTIs and other bacterial infections more than natal women. I have constant headaches and muscle aches, plus extreme emotional blunting and irritability.
What initially led me to question whether I was doing the right thing was searching for information about health difficulties I'd been having. That inquiry turned into a personal crisis. I realized I'd been buying into strict gender roles for over a decade for no reason and couldn't take it back. The realization 'I am not a man' was a creeping thought that suddenly broke through over a period of days in 2022.
I want to detransition but feel 'too late.' Being universally seen as male no longer appeals to me. I'm covered in body hair, have a full beard, a masculine face and jaw, and a voice deeper than many men's. I don't know how to return to a female identity without looking absurd. I'm attracted to lesbian women but worry I just look like a man to them and would feel invasive in lesbian spaces. I think I'll now be read either as a cis male or as a male-to-female person.
I wasn't necessarily naive as a kid, but I had very few female role models and no masculine women in my life to look up to. I assumed if I didn't feel 'girly' I must not be a girl. I wore makeup once at a party when I was 12 and never again. Media jokes about lesbians turned me away from considering that identity as well. I wish I had given womanhood a chance. I also found performing femininity extremely difficult; at the time I transitioned as a teenager in 2010, desisting didn't feel like an option.
I knew nothing about trans men aside from Chaz Bono until I discovered trans YouTubers and Tumblr blogs. That media took the intense dysphoria I had and gave me something to aspire to—something that would make me a better, more confident person. I initially hated the 'social contagion' framing for female-to-male transitioners as too harsh, though I now think an intensely misogynist society combined with teenagers' desire to fit in leads many girls to transition.
If anything, transitioning benefited me socially—I'm treated far better read as male than as a gender non-conforming woman, and the pressures of fitting in as a man are less restrictive than what's expected of women.
My family was always super supportive and will be no matter what I choose, but I'm especially afraid my mom will blame herself; she didn't know and just wanted me to be safe and happy. In the last 3 years alone, numerous friends have come out as trans, started hormones, and gotten top surgery—friends I never would have predicted. I worry that speaking against transition would make me look like a hypocrite and a gatekeeper.
I was already sporadic about taking testosterone but worried about the effects of stopping completely after 12 years of HRT. I went off T and have been off for almost 5 months as of early 2024. The slow return of normal female fat distribution and menstruation was a little distressing but nowhere near as horrible as I feared. Mostly I felt more normal, my body reverting to its natural state outside the permanent effects of T and top surgery. The dysphoria is still there. Body neutrality has been the most helpful outlook for me rather than framing things as a loss.
I think people understate how addictive testosterone is. Even knowing hormones were causing health problems, it took a long time to quit for good. I was unprepared for the crushing depression that hit as soon as I went off it and went back on several times because the energy and libido increase felt worth it—until my blood pressure crept back up and sleep apnea made me miserable. I now get similar energy through regular exercise and better sleep.
I'm coming up on 3 years of sobriety from alcohol. I was really afraid to quit drinking even though it was killing me because sobriety was unimaginably scary and unknown; it was difficult but life-changing. I plan to approach detransition the same way, though I expect less social support.
I have a medical background; even my own doctor shrugged when I tried to pinpoint which symptoms were caused by testosterone. There's frustratingly little research on how vaginal atrophy from T affects the urethra.
I hold critical views of mainstream trans activism: I believe it flipped our base understanding of oppression on its head, silencing the female-to-male community and telling them to 'check their privilege' when discussing misogyny they face. I also hold gender-critical feminist views, arguing feminism is a movement for female liberation that doesn't require coalitions with men, while supporting intersectionality on racial and economic lines since what those groups share is femaleness.