Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerde man die zich ongeveer een decennium lang, vanaf rond 2014, als trans identificeerde, en ik omschrijf mezelf nu als 'agender man': man, maar atheïst als het om gender gaat. Ik transitioneerde na een zware breuk, gedreven door geïnternaliseerde mannenhaat, postmoderne overtuigingen dat sekse puur cultureel is, en doordat mij werd verteld dat mijn gendernonconformiteit betekende dat ik trans was. Na het desisteren doorliep ik een periode van misantropie en schuldtoewijzing voordat ik leerde mijn geslacht te accepteren, mijn lichaam te waarderen en beide periodes in mijn leven te waarderen. Ik ben scherp kritisch geworden over wat ik trans-ideologie noem, wat ik zie als sektarisch en metafysisch, terwijl ik gendernonconformiteit blijf steunen en op mijn hoede ben voor zowel transessentialistische als gendercritische uitersten. Ik heb momenteel geen bekendgemaakte suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging, en ik ga voorzichtig om met vrienden en gemeenschappen terwijl ik werk aan nawerkende schaamte en verwarring.
Volledig verhaal
I started identifying as trans about a decade ago, around 2014, when I was in my early twenties. Before that I was already androgynous — I wore touches of femme clothing, painted my nails, pierced my ears — and I thought it was radical and beautiful. I transitioned after a very rough break-up with a cis woman; I sometimes wonder if I was filling the void of femininity in my life by embracing it in myself, or just looking for an ego boost. I had internalized misconceptions about sex and gender that informed the transition: I sincerely believed the sexes were equal and that only artificial culture distinguished them, I believed men and masculinity were to blame for society's woes and developed a sense of internalized misandry, and I thought cis people were inherently oppressive for constituting gender normativity. I had a very postmodern sense of society being entirely manufactured by illusions. Being told that my gender nonconformity made me trans — that males who enjoy femininity means they're trans — was the reason I fell into it in the first place.
When I was trans identifying, I was publicly very supportive and active for the community, but privately full of confusion. I scoured the internet for versions of the trans narrative that would resonate, but they all felt quasi-spiritual, and videos I once rewatched regularly for affirmation started to feel off-putting and strange. I eventually desisted — I use 'desisted' rather than 'detrans' in places, though I also describe myself as a desisted male, so it's not fully clear from my posts whether I medically transitioned with hormones or surgeries. I don't recall stating any specific medical interventions, dates, or durations.
After desisting I was very misanthropic and hurt — I felt betrayed and humiliated, and for about a year I told myself 'it's their fault.' I've since worked on letting go of that resentment and taking responsibility for my own life. I value both my time being trans and my time desisting. Transitioning gave me permission to explore parts of myself I was repressing; while I'm male presenting now, I still throw in a bit of androgyny and behave more tender and less aggressive than before. Desisting, I've learned to accept my sex and appreciate my body more — I no longer shave my full body hair, I like trying different facial hair styles, I love the hair that grows out of me as a symbol of my sex and ancestry, and I've learned to appreciate my genitals more for the function and pleasure they give. When trans I was too ashamed because of my feminized idealism, but now I see my body as a neutral circumstance of my life. I have a much better relationship with my body today.
I currently describe myself as an 'agender male' — I explain it as being an atheist to gender. I believe in sex, and though I understand there is some material basis for our norms, I still see gender as fictitious. I'm comfortable identifying as 'male' but still uncomfortable with the word 'man' because of how society essentializes it. I still dress a little androgynous and don't aspire to the masculine norm. I don't think I'd simplify my current state as 'happier,' but I'm learning to be more accepting and content in my sex, and I embrace the masc and femme parts of myself now. When people refer to me in a masculine way ('man' 'dude' 'bro') I feel uncomfortable, because those words tend to refer to gender expression rather than sex.
On causes, I think gender nonconformity, homosexuality, neurodivergence, and trauma are being misinterpreted through a new-age lens of trans-ness. I've become skeptical of trans ideology, which I describe as feeling almost like leaving a cult — I've come to see being trans as a civil religion and the ideology of dysphoria itself. I now have a hard time believing transition is good for anyone, and I consume a lot of culture war content on the subject, though part of me wishes I could just live and let live. I've become critical of the affirmation model, of the equivocation of gender nonconformity with transition, and of the villainizing of 'transphobia' which I think censors necessary skepticism. I've also become gnc-phobic in a way that surprises me — I look at friends who came to gender nonconformity late as if they're virtue signaling, and what was once beautiful to me has grown sour, though I acknowledge I may have been the same way.
I've read about autogynephilia and Blanchard's typology recently and found it interesting but not fully convincing; I'm not autogynephilic myself. I transitioned after a rough break-up and have wondered about that timing. I don't currently experience suicidal ideation or self-harm that I've posted about. Detransitioning has made me more culturally centrist and sympathetic to conservative concerns, though I'm still an economic lefty. I've let go of frameworks like 'patriarchy' and 'misogyny,' which I now see as ideologies that mask material relations between the sexes. My father passed away at some point; in detransitioning I forgave him and reflected on what a strong brave person he was and how hard it is to take on the responsibility of being a man and a father.
Socially, I've had difficulty talking to trans and nonbinary friends about my new views. My best friend of over a decade, who I lived with when I started identifying as trans, later began identifying as nonbinary themselves after dating a nonbinary person, and we have never talked about my new feelings on sex and gender — I'm too afraid to bring it up, and I'm embarrassed by them. They now want to start hormones to 'become more trans,' and I'm worried but convinced that pushing back would end our friendship. I did eventually message a mutual friend to talk about it. I've also advised others in similar situations to speak honestly with partners or friends about doubts. I find this detrans community to be an important space where I can safely vent, and I try to be empathetic and cautious, especially as someone who is gender nonconforming rather than medically detransitioned.