Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben als vrouw geboren, leefde jarenlang als butch lesbienne, identificeerde me daarna als trans man, had een bovenoperatie na een decennium wikken en wegen (waar ik van hou en geen spijt van heb) en begon met testosteron, waar ik inmiddels mee ben gestopt. Mijn grootste spijt is T: het veranderde mijn orgasmes blijvend, veroorzaakte groei van de clitoris, haaruitval en een verhoogd risico op een beroerte, en er werden me geen negatieve kanten verteld. Ik identificeer me niet meer als trans, vermijd labels en heb trans- en detrans-groepen online grotendeels verlaten omdat ze me ongelukkig maakten. Ik ben kritisch over hoe transitie online en door therapeuten wordt gepusht, over operaties onder de 18 en over het overhaaste proces van geïnformeerde toestemming dat ik doorliep. Nu ben ik gelukkiger, gericht op reizen, vrijwilligerswerk, Grieks leren en aanwezig zijn in plaats van obsessief bezig zijn met gender.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and lived as a butch lesbian for most of my life before becoming convinced I was a trans man. I contemplated top surgery for about a decade before having it, and my surgery was approved in January 2020 and scheduled for June 2020, but COVID delayed it until late 2021 — a 14-month delay. I love my top surgery and have no regrets about it; I don't miss having breasts or the way men would stare at my chest.
I started testosterone at some point after identifying as trans, but I quickly began questioning whether it was right for me. On T I experienced body odor I disliked, terrible acne, unwanted facial hair I'd have to shave, and fear of going bald. I also worried about losing my place in the lesbian community and about dating prospects. I came off T and have been off it for a long time, but it left permanent physical changes: clitoral growth that permanently altered my orgasms (a more localized orgasm rather than a full-body feeling, and loss of the ability to have multiple orgasms), and hair loss. My biggest regret is T — I've said plainly that it 'fucked up my ability to have multiple orgasms' and that this is a physical, not psychological, change. I also worry about increased stroke risk from blood cell changes on T, and I believe T doses are too high, which is why trans men go bald faster than cis men.
The approval process frustrated me. I had only a 45-minute Zoom call with a psychiatrist — during which the psychiatrist talked about themselves for at least 30 minutes — and received immediate approval for top surgery. Hormones required no real process; I just asked an endocrinologist. The psychiatrist also pushed me to schedule a second Zoom for bottom surgery approval, which I never wanted and had to argue against; I received the OK anyway. I've said that if I hadn't known myself, I might have followed that doctor's advice. I compare this to an earlier era of 'at least a year of scrutiny.'
I'm critical of how transition is promoted online and in medical settings. I believe trans groups pressure people to transition, delete or ridicule any non-fully-supportive comments, and glorify only the positives of HRT while hushing the negatives. I think therapists now tell a feminine boy he's a girl and a butch girl she's a man, wiping out masculine women and feminine men. I think big pharma and the medical community profit from transition in ways they can't from someone simply being gay or an effeminate man. I'm opposed to surgery before 18, though I think puberty blockers are acceptable because they're reversible; I've read of surgeries on people as young as 13 with parental approval and seen parents in transition groups asking how to help their kid pass the psych test. I'm skeptical of some online surgery claims, including a post I believed was a fake throwaway account from someone claiming to be a 16-year-old getting a 'mastectomy.'
I found that being in transitioning and detransition groups had a very negative effect on my psyche. I deleted most of my social media, am rarely on the internet, and went a full year without Reddit; I said I feel 100% better for it. What helped me was shifting focus away from gender — volunteering with animals, studying Greek, and traveling to Greece, which 'changed my life from being self obsessive from being in trans groups constantly comparing myself.' I've recommended the same to others: less internet, get out into the real world, help others. I also referenced Eckhart Tolle's work on living in the present rather than dwelling on the past.
I don't identify as trans anymore. I don't use labels and have said I don't know what words describe what I am now, but I'm a lot happier than when I tried to cram myself into gender word boxes. I've said I feel more hatred from the LGBTQ+ community than from straight people. I'm a caregiver in my work and have talked about watching beautiful people physically and mentally decline with age. I'm currently single, travel the world solo, and have said being single is amazing. I started dating at 19 and now wish I'd waited longer. I've mentioned being a parent and that a baby is arriving. As I age I sometimes feel invisible to others, but I take comfort in the fact that loving relationships exist between people of all appearances. I'm generally supportive of other people's choices while being critical of how transition is pushed, of under-18 medical interventions, and of the informed-consent process.