Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben nooit getransitioneerd, maar ik heb een flink deel van mijn late tienerjaren serieus overwogen het te doen en voelde me verraden door de veranderingen van mijn puberteit. Ik werkte die gevoelens door door met andere vrouwen te praten en te beseffen dat anders gezien worden niet zou veranderen als ik een man was, maar alleen een andere vorm zou aannemen. Ik identificeer me nu als vrouw, al voelt het woord nog steeds beladen met bagage voor mij. Ik ben sterk kritisch geworden over gender als concept en over medische transitie, vooral voor tieners, en ik pleit voor poortwachterschap en toestemming voor medische ingrepen alleen voor volwassenen. Ik heb zelf nooit hormonen of operaties gehad.
Volledig verhaal
I never actually transitioned, but I spent a good chunk of my late teens thinking about it. I remember feeling betrayed by my body when I got my first period — it was like overnight the game had changed and everyone was treating me differently. I hated that everyone else had decided what I was supposed to be without asking me, and I wanted to be treated like I was when I was a kid who could do and be anything. Being a boy felt better because the restrictions aren't the same and people don't have such different expectations of you, so you feel more in control of how people see you.
I overcame those feelings by talking to other women about their experiences with their bodies and growing up. I realized that people would make assumptions about me based on how I look either way — if I were a man it would just be a different set of assumptions. I also came to realize I don't have to identify with the entirety of any one group, and that not identifying with anyone in particular doesn't mean something is wrong with me. I still feel weird about being called a woman, but that's more because the word has become loaded with baggage for me.
Over time I developed a strongly critical view of gender as a concept. I came to believe gender is really a 20th century invention — before that everything was based on sex. I think the human concept of men and women is inherently flawed and based on resource control: men wish to control the reproductive resource that is women, women object, and men gaslight women into believing being controlled is for their own good. I'm radical in believing that the brain/soul/essence is not a gendered thing; if I didn't have a body, the thing that is me would not identify as a man or a woman — the only reason my 'soul' would be gendered is because of the sex of the body I inhabit.
I've spent a lot of time in online discussions pushing back on transition, especially for young people. I've argued that teenagers are more vulnerable because their identity is still forming, and that anyone with an unstable identity is likely to be led astray. I've argued that all dysphoria is a symptom of mental illness — 'if you have dysphoria, of any type, you are by definition mentally ill.' I've questioned puberty blockers, asking why they're prescribed so cautiously for precocious puberty or prostate cancer if they're truly harmless, and I've said I'd only support medical transition on the condition that it's a legal adult over 19 making the decision. I've warned people about the side effects of cross-sex hormones, including impotence, and I've told people considering testosterone that it won't make them a man and they may make themselves more miserable becoming obsessed with passing. I've also suggested to posters that their feelings might come from porn use or social media, and recommended detoxing from both.
I've been critical of what I see as appropriation of women's medical conditions, telling one person that women with PCOS don't randomly tell people about it and it's disrespectful to co-opt a disease you don't have. I've also been blunt with people about their appearance, telling one person they look like a 12-year-old girl, and telling another that their face would have widened with age anyway to make room for wisdom teeth and that they look very feminine even when they were on testosterone.
I've thought a lot about why women don't identify with femininity — I've suggested it's because 'the male is lauded as the default' and women have essentially been trained not to identify with the feminine, and I've suggested that being seen as a woman can make you anxious about how men may treat you and objectify you. I've also raised the question of women who don't want to share single-sex spaces with anyone who has a penis.
I've dealt with my own mental health struggles — I've mentioned being depressed at times, and I've discussed anxiety. I've been told by others I seem fragile and should get off social media. I've suggested SSRIs to others as worth trying despite side effect fears. I've never had any medical interventions related to transition myself.