Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die zich een periode als genderfluïde en non-binair identificeerde nadat ik was opgegroeid met de overtuiging dat ik een jongen was. Ik transitioneerde nooit medisch, maar had aanzienlijke gender- en lichaamsdysforie, een voorlopige autismediagnose en een beperking die mijn lopen steeds meer beperkt. Het vinden van gendercritical gemeenschappen begin 2019 en mijn lichaam herkaderen als gereedschap in plaats van object hielpen me mezelf te accepteren; ik ben nu meestal gelukkig als biologische vrouw, ongeacht gendernormen. Ik betoog online actief dat gender ons sociaal wordt opgedrongen, dat mensen die twijfelen moeten stoppen en wachten in plaats van transitioneren, en dat de plastische-chirurgie-industrie maatschappelijk conformisme is.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up convinced I was actually a boy — so convinced that I believed my parents had secretly had some kind of surgery performed to turn me into a girl. For a period I identified as gender-fluid and non-binary, and I told others that being better at talking with girls didn't indicate I was a woman. I struggled for years with what I called gender dysphoria, and I also had significant body-image distress: I planned to get a nose job and had even picked out specific surgeons before deciding against it.
I have a provisional diagnosis of autism, with a full screening still pending as of mid-2019. The realisation came relatively late: I was around 23 when I was speaking to a psychologist about an unrelated issue, mentioned difficulty interacting with other people, and he suggested a referral to the local autism service. There was a long wait. Once I looked up what autism is actually like — particularly in women — things clicked into place. I had largely ruled it out for myself beforehand because I thought autism was mostly a 'male thing' involving being very smart and completely socially inept. No one had offered any other explanation before that. I believe better awareness of autism and better mental health services would prevent a lot of the distress I and others experienced.
Around the beginning of 2019 I found gender-critical communities, and that was a turning point. Before that I hadn't felt 'right'. Working out which of my feelings came from thinking and acting differently, which came from societal expectations, and which came from clinging onto whatever community would have me or promise to 'fix' my distress was very useful. I now describe my remaining difficulty as less gender dysphoria and more 'corporeal dysphoria' — a general discomfort with having a physical body — and I can accept my body better than I used to.
I never medically transitioned; there is no mention of hormones, blockers, or surgery in my history. Instead I changed my thinking by brute force over many years: being very conscious of my thoughts about my own and other people's bodies, concentrating on the aggressively neutral rather than the negative ('I have arms that can hold things', 'I have eyes that can read'). I have a disability that has worsened — I used to be able to walk across a city and only hurt when I got home, and now I cannot walk down the street without pain — and I have worked hard to stop the 'yeah, but...' reflex that follows each neutral statement. I had a certain amount of therapy, though I did not learn this technique there; I picked it up from experience and from people online with body-image and eating disorders. Looking at my whole body as a tool rather than an object or a set of parts helped: 'Decorate the tool, don't take it apart and criticise it.'
I now describe myself as a biological woman doing whatever I want regardless of 'gender' or how people perceive me, and I am mostly happy where I am. I hold strongly gender-critical views: I argue that gender is forced on us before birth through names, clothes, toys, and how people interact with us, that nobody chooses a gender and it is not innate, that there is no meaningful 'trans' or 'cis', and that 'you are your body, not just a brain in a meatsack'. I note that sex is observed at birth rather than assigned, and that I do not have a difference of sex development and don't wish to speak for those who do. I have been active in online discussions, arguing with people who identify as trans or non-binary, pushing back against the idea that masculine traits or a lower voice make someone a man, and advocating that people who are questioning should stop and wait rather than plough through their doubts, because it can seriously affect their health and the rest of their life. I also argue against plastic surgery as societal conformity, drawing on my own near-experience with a planned nose job, and I hold feminist positions on sex-based oppression, including that women face the fear of sexual violence simply going for a walk in the park.