Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die tien jaar transitioneerde, een operatie onderging die ik nu zie als lichamelijke gruwel en verminking, en zich door mijn medische team in de steek gelaten voelde. Ik heb medische nalatigheid en een gewelddadige opvoeding meegemaakt, en ik verwerp het label 'dysforie' ten gunste van termen als extreem geslachtsgebonden leed, seksisme, lichaamsdysmorfie en homofobie. Ik benadruk nu persoonlijke handelingsvrijheid boven slachtofferschap, en stel dat transitie mijn keuze was, al was het een slechte, en ik bekritiseer tribalisme en zwart-witdenken in zowel trans- als detrans-ruimtes. Ik ben de afgelopen twee jaar in therapie en pleit voor nuance, beleefdheid tegenover transitioners en afstand van online cultuuroorlognarratieven voor de geestelijke gezondheid. Ik blijf kritisch over medische winstbejag en over transitie voor iedereen onder de 18, terwijl ik te paternalistische verboden op niet-chirurgische transitie voor volwassenen afwijs.
Volledig verhaal
I detransitioned myself and have spent a lot of time talking to others in detrans spaces over the past few years. I transitioned for a decade, and I consider my surgery to have been body horror and mutilation; I felt abandoned by my medical team afterward. I have experienced medical negligence as well. I have been in therapy for the past two years, having found my therapist through Genspect, though I have since distanced myself from that organization and am now only in contact with the therapist directly.
I first posted in mid-2022 asking other detrans males about their experience supplementing with testosterone after surgery, saying I was curious whether people felt more lethargic before or after and that I wanted to talk to people who are being realistic about this. I have described myself as having surgically altered my body and as post-operative, and I have referred to myself as a detransitioner and as someone who has transitioned and detransitioned. I have also said that my detransition helped open me up to playing with gender even more than during my transition, that my hair used to be a safety blanket but no longer is, and that I am more comfortable being 'inbetweeny' now.
On causes, I have said that extreme sex-based distress, sexism, body dysmorphia, an abusive upbringing, homophobia, gynocentrism, and reproductive essentialism are all more accurate descriptions than the term 'dysphoria,' which I consider a misnomer and a marketing term. I acknowledged my sex, was in therapy, and still transitioned. I have written about complex trauma in my own life. I believe gender roles are stupid and narrow, and that trans is people trying to rebel against them, sometimes to the point of overcorrection, and that misogyny plays a large factor in the broader cultural context of the gender roles people rebel against when they transition.
On process and thinking, I have argued strongly against what I see as a victim mentality in detrans spaces, saying that transition was our choice, even if a poor choice, even if there were other influences, even if we got hurt, and that part of growing up is accepting your role in how things have turned out. I have criticized the hypodermic needle model framing that casts transitioners as a passive audience injected with ideology, saying it ignores agency. I have said that being tuned into the narratives around all this is a complete distraction holding people back in a state of passive victimhood. I have recommended people take distance from these conversations for their mental wellbeing, log off, spend time outdoors, and get therapy.
I have been critical of both trans and detrans tribalism, saying there's crazy in every group, that detrans can be an overcorrection to an overcorrection, and that it's gender cults all the way down. I have pushed back against black-and-white thinking, against calling trans people delusional, and against banning non-surgical transition for adults, while saying transition should be relegated to adults if at all. I have expressed anger at clinicians who ruined teens' and youths' bodies for a decade with little regard for consequences, and at profiteering and predation in the field. I have also defended basic civility toward transitioners in the workplace and said that not all LGB or T people are activist types.
I have been downvoted heavily at times for holding nuanced positions against the dominant sentiment of detrans subreddits, and I have asked others to encourage conversation about gray areas rather than downvoting dissent. I have noted that some who never transitioned and are anti-trans are also anti-detransitioner, treating us as a convenient tool and collateral damage in their culture war. I have said I don't want to intrude on women and that it matters to be aware of that, while also saying that identifying as trans doesn't necessarily mean intruding on women, and that entering sexed spaces is separate from being trans. I have said I've only had decent reception from trans people in real life. I have also said that overly scrutinizing sexuality and gender is detrimental to wellbeing, whether you're detransitioning or transitioning, and that over-categorization from the discourse tends to do more harm than good.