Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde man, man geboren, die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd. Rond mijn 22e, getraumatiseerd door verschillende dingen, vroeg ik mijn huisarts om een verwijzing naar een genderkliniek en hij weigerde, een besluit dat ik nu toeschrijf aan het redden van mijn voortplantingstoekomst en mentale gezondheid. Ik identificeer me als man met ASS die aan trauma wilde ontsnappen, en ik kleed me nu zoals me het gelukkigst maakt. Ik ben zeer kritisch over gender-affirmerende zorg, beschrijf transitie als een leugen en een sekte, en ik raad anderen actief hormonen, binden en operaties af. Ik heb geen persoonlijke medische spijt en voel me nu stevig en goed.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male, and I asked my GP for a referral to a gender clinic when I was about 22. At the time I was, in my own words, 'traumatised from a few things', and my GP — a family man — flat out refused to refer me. I didn't know what I would feel like a few years down the line, and I now see that his refusal protected me from a path that is 'not without a lot of complications and medical upkeep'. Looking back I think he was right: 'How right he was. It's far too easy to completely f-up your reproductive future and mental health nowadays.' I have described myself elsewhere as having ASD, and I have said that my reason for transitioning was to escape trauma — 'You've put detransitioned to escape trauma. So it was an escape, which isn't unusual.'
I never went down the medical route, and I am grateful for it. I have never had hormones or surgery, and I now identify as a man who is simply dressing in the way that makes me happiest. I have said plainly: 'I can 100% guarantee you'll make a better man than a woman, because it's what you are and always have been.' I also tell others that 'None of us can change sex. It was a lie sold to us.'
I have been active in detrans and desisted spaces, mostly offering advice and opinion to others rather than describing my own medical history in detail. I have never used makeup, and I have a friend I have known since she was 14 — she is now 50, is 5'11 with a deep husky voice, and has never had trouble finding friends or male partners. I have also mentioned a friend who married a man with premature ejaculation and has been together with him about 25 years.
I am strongly critical of gender-affirming care. I believe the suicide rate after gender-affirming medicalisation is higher than before it, that the outcomes are often 'botched and failed', and that 'trans' is 'not a real thing'. I think sex is a fixed, immutable chromosomal classification and gender is a nebulous set of social stereotypes. I have argued that detransitioners are hated by some because they are 'literal and actual proof that trans is not a thing'. I have suggested legal action against physicians, predicted a class action, and described the whole phenomenon as a cult or pyramid scheme. I have recommended role models such as Maia Poet to younger people, and Erica Moise as an example of an angry, regretful detransitioner. I have told people that no binding method is safe, that cross-sex hormones are neither safe nor reversible, and that mastectomy is 'a one way street'. I have also suggested that some who claim to be trans are fetishists and opportunists exploiting a loophole created by people with genuine gender dysphoria.
I am encouraging and warm towards people who desist or detransition, praising supportive mothers, urging self-kindness, and telling people to 'be the very best, honest version of the original you'. I have no regret about my own non-transition, and I feel my GP saved me and my future children.