Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I never pursued any form of transition, and I'm not detransitioned — I only have a past of questioning my gender, starting as early as age five. I've been open about that when I've commented in detrans spaces, asking moderators to remove my comments if they were inappropriate for the community. What I have done is spend a lot of time thinking and writing about why so many gender-questioning people, especially women, get pushed in only one direction.
I've said plainly that the trans community presents itself as open to gender exploration but somehow always pushes gender-confused or distressed people into only one direction and only one explanation for their pain. I think current culture discourages exploration in any direction other than going trans, and that anyone suggesting an alternative gets told that's conversion therapy. I've asked why convincing people to go down the trans path isn't conversion therapy, and why exploring a "non-trans" path is.
I care a lot about gender-nonconforming people. I've written that society isn't accepting of GNC people's existence on either side — conservatives who want a woman to be traditional, and progressives who want her to be trans or non-binary. I called this a failure on a socio-cultural level that encourages extreme options because it refuses to show a healthier middle ground and nuance. I pointed to the internet — Tumblr, X, BlueSky — as giving a strong impression that GNC equals trans, with no professional questioning it, and I said our current culture requires a huge overhaul.
I've been critical of how dysphoria is described online, saying the social contagion aspect is real and that the description of gender dysphoria is vague enough to be inclusive of almost anything. I listed many reasons women are uncomfortable with their womanhood that aren't simply feeling like a man: tired of sexism, tired of societal expectations of conventional attractiveness, discomfort with not having a skinny hourglass figure, not being a typical heterosexual woman, being more sexual than society allows, fetishizing gay content, or not enjoying what other women are supposed to enjoy. I said today you can't confront any of that — you have to nod along that she's a trans man, and I said it pains me. I described an unsaid rule in the spaces I hang out in to never question someone's identity even when it clearly stems from a different issue, and said I'd just be called a TERF so no one has to face the more uncomfortable, complex truth. I called it lazy and bad for mental health that trans has become the answer to everything, with no one encouraging actual exploration of trauma, body dysmorphia, self-esteem issues, or personality disorders.
I've written about my own body. I said I had feelings of detachment from my body when I was obese, and that since losing weight — though I'm still in the overweight range — I feel less detached, and being referred to by feminine pronouns doesn't feel so jarring. I connected this to a friend who felt confident as a woman when skinny, put on weight, and suddenly said she didn't feel like a woman and wanted to go on T. I argued that social media presents perfect skinny women as the example of womanhood, while men are more forgiven for being fat and bald, so it's easier to just ID as trans men.
I've never taken testosterone, but I've said I've heard from other detransitioned women that sexuality shifted from lesbian to bi, and that sex drive can go disruptively high. I've also said I heard women on T report inability to cry and emotional numbness, and I questioned whether injecting large monthly doses differs from natural stable production. I've said I no longer wish to be a man because I know I'd just be a mimic — an expensive, soul-draining mimic performing mental gymnastics for the rest of my life — and that I'd rather stay as I am now. I added that I don't exactly feel attached to being a woman, but that doesn't change physical reality.
I'm in art and fandom spaces, and I've written about being bothered by identities affirmed without a second thought, including people who want to be called "it/its" because they don't view themselves as human. I said I can call a woman "he" if she wants — comparing it to not angering someone in psychosis — but I absolutely can't call someone "it," and I avoid the topic and avoid interacting with those people. I've said I don't mind gay shipping but object to calling ships between trans and cis characters gay, saying PiV is straight, period. I've described straight women who enjoy yaoi as just straight and experiencing their sexuality that way, not trans, and said I'm nearing my 30s and too tired to fight the world.
I've described a friend with a fetish for "ladies" with a penis or man voice who calls herself a lesbian, and another friend who mindlessly spreads what I consider lies because allies assume it must be true since trans people said it. I've said I was lucky to meet trans people who are actually chill, and that the hostile ones are usually really young. I've written about queer spaces asking you to ignore rational discomfort, calling it extreme inclusivity that tears down boundaries.
On medicine, I've questioned why the official consensus on treating gender dysphoria is only one path — transition — when depression has medication, therapy, diet changes, and more. I called it suspicious that gender dysphoria has one perfect cure with below 1% regret, saying it sounds fishy. I've argued that depathologization should mean HRT and surgeries are purely cosmetic, like plastic surgery or tattoos, so calling them life-saving makes no sense. I've said transition is proven to work but not for all, and shouldn't be so liberally suggested, and that detransition is frowned upon and not properly recorded or tracked.
My first exposure to detransition was about seven years before I desisted, witnessing it on Instagram — an account I rooted for whose owner announced they realized their reason for transitioning was internalized misogyny. I was surprised but happy they figured themselves out. I've used that to argue that if people regret big life choices like marriage or careers, an impossibly low transition regret rate doesn't seem possible.
I've advised others against surgery, saying society and its values failed them, not their body, and that wanting to be treated like a human isn't a gender issue. I've suggested being a feminine man is an option, questioned why someone identifies as non-binary instead of just being themselves as a GNC woman, and related to the autistic need for specific labels. I've said I relate to black-and-white thinking and needing labels over keeping things vague. I've also noted that autistic people masking as normative plus being trans is double masking.
Current status: I desisted, I identify as a woman, I never medically transitioned, and I hold critical views about how transition is currently promoted, while not opposing transition outright for those who genuinely need it.